FORWARDS - Grade: B

Bryan Rust and Patric Hornqvist were unavailable again because of injuries, prompting the Penguins to reconfigure their forward units while adding Josh Archibald to the mix for the first time in his playoff career. The result was a 35-shot effort, the Penguins’ highest total in regulation during these playoffs. The forwards didn’t generate an even-strength goal, but created plenty of chances, and members of the supporting cast – guys like Carl Hagelin, Carter Rowney and Archibald, among others – did a nice job of complementing strong showings by the likes of Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin.

DEFENSEMEN - Grade: B

The Penguins’ two best offensive defensemen, Kris Letang and Justin Schultz, spent the evening in street clothes, but a couple of their colleagues, Olli Maatta and Brian Dumoulin, picked up the slack. Maatta put the Penguins in front, 1-0, in the first period with his first goal in 47 playoff games, and Dumoulin got the eventual game-winner midway through the second period. There were a few hiccups on the blue line, like Ron Hainsey losing his balance to trigger the sequence that led to Clarke MacArthur’s goal late in the second, but it was a pretty sound showing by a group that played the final two periods without Chad Ruhwedel.

Advertise with us

GOALIE - Grade: B+

Coach Mike Sullivan made his most controversial – and critical – decision this spring when he chose Matt Murray, not Marc-Andre Fleury, to start Game 4, and Murray rewarded him with a strong performance, stopping 24 of 26 shots. He made some big saves before the Penguins generated their first goal, most notably on Derick Brassard about seven minutes into the game, and never allowed the Senators to get a lead. Whatever rust had accumulated on his game during a month-long layoff clearly was shaken off during his relief appearance in Game 3.

SPECIAL TEAMS - Grade: B+

The Penguins won the special-teams battle for the second game in a row and, this time, it translated to a victory. Crosby scored a man-advantage goal for the second game in a row, and the penalty-killers prevented Ottawa from converting any of its four tries with the extra man, including one during the final 34.3 seconds of regulation. The Senators’ power play is in a miserable slump, failing to score on 25 chances over the past nine games. If the Penguins can keep that streak going, their prospects for another Stanley Cup final appearance will be greatly enhanced.

COACHING - Grade: B

Advertise with us

There’s not much reason to second-guess any of the decisions Sullivan and his staff made for Game 4. Murray played well, Archibald was solid and the Penguins’ overhauled line combinations meshed nicely. And while sluggish starts have been a problem frequently during these playoffs, the Penguins turned in one of their best first periods of the spring. That allowed them to get a lead, and it’s a lot easier to beat a good defensive team like the Senators when you don’t have to play from behind.

Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG