OTTAWA, Ontario — Four games deep in this perplexing Eastern Conference final, we know exactly as much or as little about its ultimate direction as we did when it began.
Every time you look up, it’s different; the furniture has been re-arranged or the lighting has been altered or the interior has been torn apart and re-jiggered like on one of those maddening home improvement shows on HGTV.
Soon I fully expect someone to flatly insist on granite counter tops or the whole deal is off.
“There’s been a different identity to every game,” said Penguins forward Carl Hagelin, who helped dismantle four Ottawa power plays Friday night to help the Penguins pull even at two games apiece. “That’s the way it goes nowadays, teams are so close in talent. If you don’t have every single guy showing up in these games, it’s going to be hard to win. It’s 2-2, we’re going back to Pittsburgh, now it’s best two out of three.”
A few things, a very few things, have been learned, however.
We know, I guess, that the Penguins have not come by accident upon a 12-2 record in games after a playoff loss under Mike Sullivan, who only removed the centerpiece of the Penguins’ postseason when he announced at midday Friday that Matt Murray would replace Marc-Andre Fleury.
Read More
We know, I guess, that Sullivan is not to be second-guessed, let alone first-guessed, least of all by me, when it comes to making critical decisions as to which of his Stanley Cup-winning goaltenders to put in front of the net for any particular assignment.
And we know, I guess, that the Ottawa Senators will be a torment to the psyche of the defending Stanley Cup champions for most of another week, just as they were as they peppered Murray with a flurry (and certainly not a Fleury) of shots in the final minute of a 3-2 Penguins victory.
“They were the better team tonight,” said Ottawa coach Guy Boucher, who quickly added, “for two periods, and they deserved the game. We deserved two games and we got two games; they deserved two games and it’s 2-2. That’s how it is.”
Playing still again without critical components such as forwards Bryan Rust and Patric Hornqvist and defenseman Justin Schultz, the Penguins nonetheless came up with a burst of genius at 19:14 of the first period when they got the game’s first goal.
In this adventuresome postseason, you see, they are 9-1 when they score first and 1-5 when they don’t, so Olli Maata pounding the biscuit past Ottawa’s Craig Anderson was a hell of an idea.
“I think it’s just been all dictated by that first period,” said Chris Kunitz, who turned up on the top line again in Sullivan’s offensive re-jiggering. “A good first period puts the other team back on their heels and once you do that, it’s tough for that team to build their way out of it, especially when you score early. I think the team that’s scored first has won every game.”
That is correct, and it is also correct that Anderson finally got tested in earnest for the first time in this series in those first 20 minutes, as eight of the Penguins’ first 12 shots came from below the dots. The Penguins outshot Ottawa, 14-9, in the first period, upholding some predictions they’d made Friday morning.
“I don’t think we’re gonna let that happen again,” said forward Scott Wilson of the disastrous start to Game 3, in which Ottawa’s first nine shots yielded a 4-0 lead that made periods 2 and 3 little more than an intense aerobic workout.
He was right, and then the Penguins had an even better idea — a meaningful goal by Sidney Crosby, the first since Game 1.
Of the Washington series.
A mere three-plus weeks ago.
Crosby tucked his own rebound past Anderson at the right doorstep to make it 2-0, and when Brian Dumoulin somehow clattered a puck past Anderson from near the left point little more than four minutes later, it looked as if Ottawa would only be using Game 4 to further emphasize its astounding ineffectiveness on the power play.
A ridiculous 0 for its past 25, the Senators power play was so useless it appeared the Penguins were taking penalties just to get it out on the ice. Too many men on the ice? Yeah, that whole counting thing can be vexing.
Even after Clark Macarthur swept a nifty crossing pass from Bobby Ryan past Murray late in the second, the series’ endemic unpredictability remained fully established.
The Penguins scored as many goals in the first two periods Friday night as they had in the first three games, but at least one Senator had predicted that.
Wait, I just said the whole thing was unpredictable didn’t I?
“We expect their best game of the series,” Ottawa’s Dion Phaneuf had blurted hours before the puck drop. “We know they are going to come with a push, and we’ve got to push back.”
And so they did. Almost hard enough. But it got them nowhere. That’s where we are after four of these confounding things, nowhere even close to knowing where it’s going.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.