OTTAWA, Ontario — As the media filed out of the locker room after the Penguins’ practice Thursday, goalies Marc-Andre Fleury and Matt Murray were comparing notes.
Not about the Senators, but about the packed interview sessions both had just gone through.
It got pretty hot in the cramped University of Ottawa dressing room, Murray pointed out, especially with the bright lights of TV cameras shining on you.
Of course, one of the two goalies will be more directly in the spotlight Friday night, when the Penguins take on Ottawa in Game 4 of the Eastern Conference final.
Coach Mike Sullivan did not commit to a starter after practice, saying he’ll name one Friday morning. That has been the team’s protocol all season, and that’s not going to change just because the Penguins are now two losses away from the end of their season.
“It’s always a hard decision,” Sullivan said. “But it’s a good hard decision because we have two really good goalies. It’s never an easy decision, it never has been all year long for us.”
Read More
This time, the choice carries a bit more weight than it did over the course of the regular season. For the first time under Sullivan, the Penguins are facing a 2-1 deficit in a playoff series. A loss Friday night would push them to the brink of elimination.
Sullivan faced a similar situation at around the same time last year, when he opted to bench Murray — who had been the playoff starter — after a loss in Game 4 of the Eastern Conference final against Tampa Bay. Murray’s playoff numbers at the time (9-4, 2.33 GAA, .923 save percentage) are remarkably similar to Fleury’s so far this postseason (9-6, 2.56 GAA, .924 save percentage). Of course, Fleury and the Penguins lost that Game 5 against the Lightning, and Murray returned to lead the Penguins the rest of the way to the Stanley Cup.
As Sullivan often says, the Penguins have two really good goalies. But the net is only big enough for one of them. So, who will it be?
The case for Fleury
The listless 5-1 loss in Game 3 Wednesday drew comparisons to the 5-2 drubbing they took at the hands of the Capitals in Game 6 of the previous round.
Fleury responded to that one by putting together his best performance of the postseason in a Game 7 shutout.
Through 13 playoff games, Fleury largely has been excellent for the Penguins. His .924 save percentage is still the third-best postseason mark of his career, and second among the four starting goalies remaining in the playoffs.
“Flower’s definitely played unbelievable, and he’s kept us in a lot of games,” defenseman Brian Dumoulin said. “Obviously, we wouldn’t be here without him. I’ve got full confidence in Flower.”
It’s hard to pin too much of the 4-0 deficit the Penguins faced on Fleury, too. The Senators’ goals — especially the first three — can be chalked up to a combination of poor defensive play and some unlucky bounces around the crease.
“Everyone knows that we didn’t give him a lot of help,” captain Sidney Crosby said. “I’m sure there was more than one saying, ‘Hey, it’s on us. We have to be better in front of you.’ Just like everyone else, he’ll turn the page.”
Fleury said he went back and watched tape of the game Wednesday with goalie coach Mike Bales. He also added that he had a trick on moving past bad games that former teammate Tomas Vokoun taught him a few years back, but he wouldn’t divulge it.
Whatever it is, it has worked for Fleury this postseason. In the games after his five playoff losses this season, Fleury is 4-1 with a 1.80 goals-against average and a .946 save percentage.
“I’ve really been enjoying this playoff run,” Fleury said. “It’s not going to go 16 games in a row perfectly. I’ll put that one behind me and be ready to go.”
The case for Murray
The goalie situation this year might have been described as a timeshare, but — especially when both goalies were healthy — the starting duties certainly tended to tip toward Murray.
He got 47 starts to Fleury’s 34 and put up a better goals-against average (2.41 vs. 3.02) and save percentage (.923 vs. .909) than Fleury.
Based on the split this regular season, Sullivan seems to trust Murray a bit more. Up until the playoffs, Fleury had not started back-to-back games with both goalies healthy since Dec. 27. Murray had stretches of as many as eight consecutive starts over the final four months of the season.
The only times this year Murray has gone long stretches without playing — including in these playoffs — has been due to injury.
“It’s definitely frustrating in that regard, but it’s a long season,” Murray said. “You’re going to have ups and downs, and that’s definitely what happened this year. I think I persevered well through it. Each time I’ve gotten hurt, I’ve come back stronger.”
And he feels like he’s ready to do the same Friday if called upon in Game 4. Murray said it felt good to knock some rust off when he came on in relief in Game 3, but his role since he has returned to the bench has been to be ready no matter what.
“You don’t need to play all the time to be good,” Murray said. “Sure, it was nice, but, at the end of the day, it doesn’t matter. You might not get that chance, so you’ve got to be ready, no matter what.”
There probably isn’t much to take away from Murray’s performance in Game 3, given that the game was already out of reach at that point. But Sullivan often has spoken highly of Murray’s consistency, and his soundness positionally could give him an edge in this specific series, where chances both ways are at a premium.
“I have no expectations,” Murray said. “Either way, I have to be ready. That’s kind of how I look at it. I’ll be ready to go either way, whatever the coaches’ decision is. I’m not really hoping one way or another. It’s out of my control, so I don’t really think too much about it.”
Other key factors
Unlike Murray, the rest of Pittsburgh likely has put plenty of thought into who should be in net when the puck drops in Game 4 Friday night.
So, too, has Sullivan.
Ultimately, the man between the pipes won’t be the deciding factor if the other 18 players on the bench don’t play significantly better than they did in Game 3.
“It doesn’t matter who’s in net,” center Evgeni Malkin said. “Players need to help, blocking shots, [in] open ice. Do our job. I know the goalies did a great job this year. They’re both ready.”
And the one who doesn’t get the nod will return to backup duties, a role both players have experienced more than they would have liked over the past calendar year.
Just as both could empathize with the discomfort of the media sessions Thursday afternoon, they also know what it’s like to be in both positions.
“Goalies are kind of like a brotherhood,” Murray said. “It’s a different mental mindset than the rest of the players on the team.
“It’s kind of just knowing when a guy needs a pat on the back, when he needs some reinforcement or when you just need to stay out of a guy’s way, let him do his thing. I think goalies are pretty good at knowing when to do which. I think that’s what we’ve been pretty good at all season long.”
Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.