OTTAWA, Ontario — Of the 20 Penguins who will dress for Game 4 Friday night, I would guess a distinguished dozen or more live in houses in which the pantry closet is larger than the home locker room at the practice rink this week — the cozy, fragrant den of the University of Ottawa fighting Gee Gees.

A Gee Gee is a slang term for a racehorse, and the University adopted as its colors Garnet and Gray to play off the twin G’s, probably because Green and Gold was too easy. Why it adopted the Gee Gees as the mascot in the first place is a longer, even-less-interesting story dating to the 16th century, but I have it on reasonable authority that it wasn’t because Bee Gees was taken.

It’s a quirky little backdrop in which to have your Stanley Cup title defense hanging in the balance, and the spectacle of Stanley Cup-winning goaltenders Marc-Andre Fleury and Matt Murray standing six feet from each other with 60 or so hockey journalists between them Thursday seemed to goose the drama considerably.

“Even if I [had been told], I wouldn’t tell you,” said Murray on the question that was the elephant in a room better suited to, at most, two housecats.

Advertise with us

But then, Murray didn’t have to tell us who’ll start in goal for Game 4; it’ll be Fleury, who has started every game of this postseason. That’s unless I’m misreading the 100 or so other indicators.

I know, what are the odds?

Head coach Mike Sullivan yanked Fleury out of Game 3 when four of the Ottawa Senators’ first nine shots hit nothing but net (OK, maybe the odd shin pad or skate, too), and Murray mopped up a 5-1 pie in the face that left the Penguins in the uncomfortable position of having suddenly dropped four of their past six playoff games. That in what had begun to resemble a charmed postseason.

Sullivan officially was noncommittal on the identity of his starting netminder Friday night, but he was instructive on the question of whether he’d be starting Fleury out of some sense of loyalty to the beloved Flower.

“I think we have loyalty to our whole group; I don’t think it’s to any one particular guy,” Sullivan said near the ice surface after a practice of less than 45 minutes. “This is a team, and it’s a team in the true sense of the word, so are we appreciative of the contributions that all our guys make — Marc-Andre included? Yes, absolutely. We wouldn’t be to the point where we’re at without these guys. Any of them.

Advertise with us

“So that’s how we look at it; I think we have loyalty to our whole team.”

General manager Jim Rutherford, the old netminder himself, had watched a slightly goalie-centric practice from a standing position between the sixth row of seats and the seventh and last row of seats. Murray and Fleury and even backup backup Tristan Jarry were on the ice — and wait, is that Jeff Zatkoff?

But here on the campus of the largest university in Ottawa, which just happens to be the most educated city in all Canada, Rutherford and Sullivan and goaltenders coach Mike Bales, in colloquy with additional consultants, were all trying to make an educated guess on the immediate ramifications of Fleury vs. Murray.

It’s entirely possible the urgent conversations predated the practice, and the decision as well. The announcement was probably delayed to make the Senators mull it for as long as possible.

All parties seemed sworn to the pretense of indecision.

Advertise with us

“I don’t know yet,” said Fleury. “[Sullivan] hasn’t spoken about it.”

For his part, Fleury seemed completely unaffected by being run off by the Senators, both during a playful practice and in the tiny locker room. He stood smiling near his locker, his hands folded calmly at his waist, fingers interlaced.

“It’s not going to go 16 games in a row perfectly,” he said of his heretofore sensational postseason. “So I put that one behind already, and I’m ready to go.”

You can’t persuade me, at least for the moment, that Sullivan is going to sit Fleury for one bad period when he’s getting multiple dreadful efforts over stretches of multiple periods from just about everybody else, all of it wilting the Flower. If Fleury sits tonight, a lot of his most vocal supporters among the veterans — Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, Chris Kunitz, and more — are going to be either moderately confused or sorely hissed off.

And that’s no way to play playoff hockey, in this view.

Advertise with us

“I think all the guys are supportive of each other, especially when it’s your goaltender,” Crosby reminded. “I think everyone knows that we didn’t give him a lot of help. So I’m sure there’s more than one guy saying, hey, you know what, it’s on us, and we’ve got to be better in front of you. Just like everyone else, he’ll turn the page, and we will as a group and make sure we’re better.”

That’s what this team likes to call the right way to play. Starting Fleury, albeit with a slighter shorter leash, happens to be the right way to coach this situation.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.