The Penguins took a 3-2 loss against the Washington Capitals in overtime of Game 3 of their Eastern Conference semifinal series Monday at PPG Paints Arena. Here are some initial impressions from the defeat, which cut their series lead to 2-1.

It was over when: Capitals defenseman Kevin Shattenkirk ripped home a shot on the power play early in overtime after the Penguins had rallied to tie the game in regulation.

Heroes: Goalie Marc-Andre Fleury. What else can you say after a play like this?

That second-period sequence of stops was more spectacular than most of Fleury’s stops, but he kept the Penguins in the game all night, amid injuries and some prime Capitals scoring chances. He stopped 30 of the 33 shots he faced, yielding only on a tough play on a 5-on-3 power play and the odd-man rush that led to Kuznetsov’s goal before Shattenkirk scored in overtime. The last goal was more ordinary, but then, the Penguins wouldn’t have made it to OT without Fleury’s work in regulation.

Advertise with us

Evgeni Malkin had an on-and-off game, but boy, did he pick the perfect time to announce his presence in this series. Between scoring the Penguins’ first goal to halve their regulation deficit with just under 2 minutes left in regulation to finding defenseman Justin Schultz for the tying goal seconds later, he was every bit the super star you’d want him to be in the absence of Sidney Crosby, who left the ice in the first period after being cross checked by Capitals defenseman Matt Niskanen and did not return. (More on that in a minute.) At the very least, Malkin gave Washington something to think about ahead of Game 4.

Shattenkirk’s shot was huge for the Capitals, obviously. They were seconds from having life in the series with a win, then found themselves on the brink of a 3-0 series deficit after the Penguins rallied to force overtime at the end of regulation. For them to overcome that shock to win has to be a huge relief.

Goats: The Penguins power play looked rough in the absence of Crosby. The unit had multiple opportunities with a man advantage and either couldn’t get organized at all or failed to convert the good chances it did generate. Overall, they were scoreless on five attempts. This is a worrying sign if Crosby is going to miss significant time. Which...

Crosby’s absence looms large: ...seems like a distinct possibility. Take another look at the play that injured the Penguins captain.

If you’re a Penguins fan, there’s a lot to be concerned about there. There’s the shot Crosby took to the head, then there’s the way his leg bent awkwardly underneath him. We may or may not hear from the Penguins about which ugly looking thing knocked Crosby out of the game, but either way, his absence was noticeable, on the power play and otherwise.

Advertise with us

Conor Sheary’s, too: The winger hasn’t had a spectacular post season so far, but he was one of the Penguins’ most consistent scorers in the regular season, and it hurt a lot when he had to go to the dressing room after being run into by winger Patric Hornqvist. The Penguins had to play the rest of the game with 10 forwards. That’s a lot of extra minutes for a lot of guys late in a game when they were trying to mount a comeback, then find a spark in overtime.

More penalties: Losing Crosby was bad enough, but the Penguins compounded their bad luck with self-inflicted wounds. Malkin was penalized shortly after the Penguins were given a five-minute power play for the Niskanen cross check on Crosby, breaking up that advantage for two minutes. Then wingers Carl Hagelin and Bryan Rust took penalties within seconds of each other, setting up a 5-on-3 advantage for Washington that led to the Capitals first goal. Finally, the overtime goal came on a man advantage for Washington, the Capitals fifth power play of the game. All of this after the Penguins took five penalties in Game 2. The Penguins can’t control their injury fate, but if they’re going to win this series without Crosby, this is something they can, and must, get under control.

But shots even out: The Penguins were badly outshot in the first two games as Washington dominated possession. Not so much in Game 3. Both teams had their moments as Washington won the shot margin, 33-30, in the end. If you’re looking for an encouraging sign moving forward after this loss and sans Crosby until who knows when, this is it. If the Penguins can keep Washington from dominating possession, it will be a big boost to their cause as they look to secure two more wins in the next four games to advance.

What’s next: Game 4 between the two teams is 7:30 p.m. Thursday back at PPG Paints Arena. The Capitals will be looking to tie the series before it heads back to Washington for a Game 5 that is now necessary.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter, @fugimaster24.