NEWARK, N.J. — Penguins players who spoke Thursday were openly critical of where the team’s game is at right now.

And while there’s no sense panning the pursuit of perfection, a closer look at the supposed “Stanley Cup hangover” shows the Penguins will be just fine. Really, they already are.

If this — a 10-4-2 start — qualifies as a hangover, the Penguins may not even need coffee, a shower and a greasy breakfast to shake it.

A Pittsburgh Post-Gazette analysis looked at the 11 salary-cap era Stanley Cup champions and divided their subsequent seasons into fifths — perhaps appropriate given the subject matter -— with the caveat that the last one runs 18 games instead of 16.

Advertise with us

The Penguins are one of only four teams in the salary-cap era (2005-present) to record double-digit wins in that first segment. Furthermore, their 22 points exceed the average of 19.6 collected through the first 16 games by reigning Cup winners, and their points percentage of .689 out-paced the league average (.614) during the same timeframe.

“I think we’ve been pretty good to this point,” captain Sidney Crosby said before the blowout loss against Washington Wednesday night. “but we need to make sure that we stay on track.”

The Penguins have certainly stumbled off the track a few times, with the game in Washington their ugliest performance. They’ve hardly been perfect, with a penchant for taking penalties, an inconsistent penalty kill and the tendency for an out-of-nowhere lopsided loss on the road, but it’s probably not worth canceling the season just yet.

Numbers chronicling how the alleged Stanley Cup hangover has affected teams in the salary-cap era has the Penguins keeping pace, if not exceeding it.

Look at who won what and when, and the aggregate points percentages look like this: .614, .638, .663, .580 and .583.

Advertise with us

That’s not a hangover. That’s waking up the next morning and remembering you were the designated driver.

In fact, no Stanley Cup-winning team has finished with fewer than 17 of a possible 32 points through the first 16 games. The lowest winning percentage equates to a 95-point season, a reasonably competitive playoff pace.

“It’s a hard lesson to learn because it’s a humbling experience,” Sullivan said. “We believe in the group we have. We have to take strides here to move as a team in the right direction.”

The 7-1 loss in Washington should provide more than a few teaching points. The Capitals had been anemic offensively, then caught fire against the Penguins, who allowed the most goals in a game during Sullivan’s tenure.

The Penguins also took 10 minor penalties, an NHL-high this season, and lacked any tangible sense of desperation for much of the game. It led Sullivan to call the loss “humbling.”

Advertise with us

"It’s part of the season,” forward Matt Cullen said. “Obviously, you would rather not have these tough ones. This one was especially tough. We played really poorly, but we all understand that in order to make sure that that doesn’t happen again, we need to get on our game.”

The fourth segment appears be the only stretch where Cup-winners struggle the next year, perhaps because of the sheer volume of hockey they played. It is important to note Boston’s 6-9-1 funk in 2011-12 that may be dragging down the relatively small sample size.

The Penguins have an interesting antidote when it comes to the Stanley Cup hangover. Their version of Gatorade and Tylenol is the fact that Sullivan wasn't hired until Dec. 12, 2015, and they didn’t truly jell until the 2016 calendar year — starting, of course, with that come-from-behind win in Detroit on New Year’s Eve.

“Our team is really hungry,” Eric Fehr said, speaking of collecting points and not greasy cheeseburgers. “We only really had half the year last year to get this team working together with the coaching staff. I think our team thinks we can get better.

“We’re trying to improve upon last year. It’s not going to be easy to do, but we have the guys in here with that work ethic and that desire.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.