NEWARK, N.J. — As Penguins general manager Jim Rutherford spoke, his players filed onto the ice for practice here at the Barnabas Health Hockey House next to Prudential Center.

About 18 hours earlier, in Washington, D.C., Rutherford’s Penguins pretty much set fire to any hope they might have had of winning a hockey game by taking 10 penalties, the most for an NHL team in a single game this season.

Through 16 games, they have only six instances on their ledger where they’ve taken three or fewer penalties in a game. The Penguins are on the hunt for overall consistency in their game, and the penalty problem is arguably their most obvious offense.

“This is not good,” Rutherford said. “We’re taking very undisciplined penalties that are ultimately costing us games. It has to get fixed. It has to stop. Whether we’re only 15 or 16 games or we’re 80 games in, this is an area we have to focus on and fix.”

Advertise with us

It’s not just penalties, and it’s not just the general manager voicing his displeasure with the Penguins’ third road dud of the season. Ramifications from the flat-liner Wednesday were felt in a variety of ways.

Earlier in the day, coaches and players met and discussed their current shortcomings. Coach Mike Sullivan said he’d prefer to keep the nitty-gritty of what was said inside the room, but it’s not hard to grasp the general message: Stop making foolish mistakes and handing out two points at a time like Halloween candy.

On the ice, the first thing the Penguins did was skate sprints in a circle, presumably as punishment for their poor performance the night before. Sullivan called it an “act of recovery.” He didn’t specify mental or physical. It could have been both.

“Coaches have certain tactics that they can use to try and hold the group accountable, and that’s part of our responsibility,” Sullivan said. “Different coaches choose to exercise different tactics depending on the team that they have, the group that they have and where they’re at. That’s one of them.

“I believe we have a mature group here that understands what it takes to win. Right now, our thought process is to work with these guys and try to get us moving in the right direction as far as our consistency of play.”

Advertise with us

The majority of the Penguins’ penalties have been stick-related infractions — high-sticking, hooking and tripping. Despite just one regular-season fight in his NHL career — according to hockeyfights.com — and none this season, Evgeni Malkin leads the Penguins with 28 penalty minutes.

Tom Sestito is second with 24, followed by Ian Cole (17) and Chris Kunitz (16).

Not only did the Penguins permit Washington seven power plays Wednesday, on which the Capitals scored twice, but they spent eight of 20 minutes in the second period on the penalty kill while facing three- and four-goal deficits.

Taking so many ill-timed penalties has stopped the Penguins, in a way, from playing to their identity, Matt Cullen said.

“You look at the numbers, and it’s pretty glaring,” Cullen said. “That’s a problem for us right now. We’re a team that thrives on rolling four lines, just coming at teams in waves, imposing our will on teams just one line after another. When we’re in the box, it really kills that. You can see that in our own game right now. We’re struggling to find that momentum that we need so often.”

Advertise with us

It’s not just penalties, though. The Penguins entered Thursday next-to-last in the league in shots allowed per game (34.0) and 28th in faceoff percentage, two issues that Sullivan believes are related.

The Penguins penalty kill has been up and down at times, too. There was also a stretch where the Penguins started games lethargically. They’ve seemingly crammed a little bit of everything into their first 16 games, but the bad has their attention more than the good right now.

“There’s definitely been games where we’ve given up chances and found ways to win either with our power play or getting timely goals,” captain Sidney Crosby said. “Sometimes, that catches up to you. That happened to catch up to us [Wednesday] night with the way we played.

“You can’t expect to show up and play that way and do anything well. It’s all about our mindset and making sure we’re ready to play. There’s no excuse for that. We have to make sure we bounce back tomorrow.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.