Why the Penguins ...
Will win the Stanley Cup
1. Marc-Andre Fleury has been the team’s most valuable player all season, and he’ll need to continue to be that way in the playoffs. As the team’s offensive production dwindled as the season wore on, Fleury was the main reason they were competitive in most games. Fleury, 30, appeared in 64 games this season, had a 34-20-9 record, a 2.32 goals against average, a .920 save percentage and a league-leading 10 shutouts. Fleury’s postseason history will always be in question, but his steady effort in last year’s playoffs answered many of those questions.
2. The Eastern Conference doesn’t have a particularly dominant team. Even with the Rangers winning the Presidents’ Trophy as the top overall team, the top four teams in the East have some notable flaws. The Rangers have injuries on defense. The Canadiens have trouble scoring goals. The Lightning has little playoff experience. And the Capitals have the stigma of past playoff failures.
3. There are few tangible reasons to believe the Penguins will beat the Rangers in the first round let alone win the Stanley Cup. But luck, which hasn’t been on their side all season with injuries, bounces and penalties, could switch allegiance for the postseason. And with no salary-cap restrictions, the Penguins can dress a full lineup with six defensemen. They didn’t have that luxury in the last three games of the regular season.
Won’t win the Stanley Cup
Read More
1. The Penguins don’t have anyone who can replace the variety of roles Kris Letang assumes. Out since having a concussion March 28, Letang is their best defenseman and has significant roles in even-strength and special teams play. With Letang unlikely to return, the Penguins won’t go far in his absence. Christian Ehrhoff’s possible return will make things easier, but there is no way to account for Letang’s absence.
2. Depth, a point of emphasis under general manager Jim Rutherford, has not lived up to expectations, particularly in the late stages of the regular season. Role players such as left winger David Perron (two goals in 15 games), center Nick Spaling (no goals in 26 games), left winger Chris Kunitz (one goal in 21 games), left winger Blake Comeau (one goal in 18 games), center Maxim Lapierre (no goals in 35 games) and others have struggled to score.
3. This isn’t a very good team. After losing five consecutive games, the Penguins needed to grind out a tight, 2-0 road win against the Sabres, the NHL’s worst team, in the final game of the regular season just to make the playoffs. Injuries, a lack of depth and inconsistent play have sunk the Penguins’ postseason hopes before the playoffs have started. With a first-round matchup with Rangers, a team they went 1-2-1 against this season, avoiding a sweep will be a significant accomplishment.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.