Click here to submit your question
Q: When names are mentioned of guys who have stepped up their play this year, no one ever talks about Brooks Orpik. While he will never be a top-two defenseman, his play has impressed me of late. He's improved in front of the net, more efficient along the boards, much better with his first pass out of the zone and most noticeably, he's taking fewer penalties. How dramatic has been the decline in his penalty minutes, and what is your impression of Orpik's play this year?
Randy Waddell, Newburyport, Mass.
MOLINARI: Frequent visitors to this forum probably can anticipate part of the moderator's response. The part that preaches the importance of patience when dealing with goaltenders and defensemen, because they need extra time to learn their positions and, thus, realize their potential.
Orpik might not seem like the poster boy for that concept because, at 26, he's reached an age where most players are beginning to move into their prime. However, his progress was retarded when he did not play during the 2004-05 season because of the NHL's labor dispute, opting to work on his college degree instead of going to Europe. His performance this season suggests he still has not reached his professional peak.
Orpik had 124 penalty minutes in 64 games last season, an average of .1.94 per game. He had 76 minutes in 65 games, an average of 1.17, in 2006-07 before the Penguins played at Boston last night. The drop in his time in the penalty box reflects an improved understanding of the game, along with more polished technique and better execution. It certainly doesn't stem from a decline in his physical play; Orpik easily is the most punishing and frequent hitter on the Penguins' defense.
He also merits at least a bit of credit for the upgrade in defense partner Ryan Whitney's performance this season. Whitney deserves the overwhelming majority, of course, and the value of experience in his progress should not be overlooked (see opening paragraph), but Orpik's stay-at-home, defensively responsible style has given Whitney the latitude to get involved offensively and take full advantage of his point-producing talents.
Q: Is there any rule governing the length of a player's stick? We always hear about Jordan Staal's long reach, and while he is fairly tall and rangy, he isn't exactly Zdeno Chara and he does use a long stick. I realize most players prefer to use a stick that's more or less proportional to their body size, but is there any rule that keeps players from using a stick well outside the regular range?
Jay Roddy, Robinson
MOLINARI: Rule 10.1 reads, in part, that "no stick shall exceed 63 inches in length from the heel to the end of the shaft," and Staal presumably operates within that guideline. Happily for him, the NHL has not tried to regulate the length of a player's arms.
Q: I know he doesn't score points, but I look at the Penguins' record with Mark Eaton and think he may just be the most valuable player of the team.
Gregory Paris, Hershey
MOLINARI: Well, even Eaton's blood relatives and agent probably wouldn't go that far -- after all, one of his teammates looks like a pretty fair bet to be named MVP of the entire league -- but their 21-6-1 record in the 28 complete games he had played this season before facing the Bruins is pretty tough to ignore. And it isn't entirely a coincidence.
Eaton probably was best-known for his offensive ability when he broke into the league with Philadelphia in 1998, but has evolved into an outstanding penalty-killer and force in the defensive zone. He plays an intelligent game -- positioning himself well and using his stick effectively -- and is a superb shot-blocker.
His play alongside Sergei Gonchar during the first month of the season was a significant factor in Gonchar's stronger-than-usual start, and even though coach Michel Therrien seems satisfied to use Gonchar with Josef Melichar, it wouldn't be a major surprise -- or a bad move -- if he would opt to reunite Gonchar and Eaton before or during the Stanley Cup playoffs.
Q: It's been said that you go with the "hot" goaltender. It seems to me that Jocelyn Thibault has been hotter than Marc-Andre Fleury lately. Should he get more work, with the possible effect of damaging Fleury's ego and/or confidence?
Jeff Johnston, East Norriton, Pa.
MOLINARI: Your e-mail was sent before Fleury recorded his fifth shutout of the season against Boston Sunday, but the premise of your question is legitimate. And the subject is sure to come up again if Fleury stumbles sometime in the waning days of the regular season.
Although egos shouldn't be a factor in personnel decisions, the confidence of key players -- a young No. 1 goaltender, for example -- has to be. That's not the reason Fleury should hold onto his spot as the Penguins' No. 1 goalie, though. He is one of the cornerstones of the Penguins' building program, and it is in the franchise's long-term interest to get him playoff experience, as well as to see how he fares in high-stakes games at this level.
Thibault has been excellent of late, turning aside 90 of 93 shots during his past three starts, and if he can continue to perform at that level, Therrien will have a viable option if he decided a goaltending switch is in order. That might be a bit too radical, though, unless Fleury experiences something close to a total meltdown.
Q: Does it surprise you to know that when I tried to order playoff tickets, there was a disclaimer from Ticketmaster saying that they were only selling tickets to people in Western Pennsylvania, eastern Ohio, and West Virginia?
Timothy Herman, Akron, Ohio
MOLINARI: A number of Penguins fans who reside outside the general Pittsburgh area -- in this instance, approximately a 120-mile radius of the city -- were disappointed when their attempts to purchase tickets for Games 1 and 2 of the playoffs failed Monday.
They were thwarted by a policy devised by officials of the team and Ticketmaster, who limited the sale of playoff tickets to people who live in specific zip codes in an effort to prevent ticket brokers and others interested only in reselling the tickets from getting control of a significant number of seats at Mellon Arena.
Tom McMillan, the Penguins' vice president of communications, said the "vast, vast majority of our fans" were able to purchase tickets, but conceded that "there's no perfect system" and that some fans who live in other parts of the country and wanted tickets only for their personal use were unable to get them.
Q: Alain Nasreddine has been a steady plus-14 this year, yet not much has been said about it and there are times where he is a healthy scratch. Has he been that solid, or is the plus/minus stat overrated?
Justin Beiter, Berwick, Pa.
MOLINARI: Nasreddine has given the Penguins exactly what they were looking for when they promoted him from their farm team in Wilkes-Barre in early December -- steady, reliable play in the defensive zone. That's what he's been looked to throughout his career and, at age 31, Nasreddine won't be making any significant changes to his style.
Although plus-minus ratings shouldn't always be taken at face value because a lot of factors other than an individual's performance can affect them, when viewed in context, they do offer some insight on how someone is playing, and Nasreddine's is a reasonable reflection of his contribution in the role in which he has been cast.
He lost his place in the lineup when Eaton returned from a sprained knee Sunday. That doesn't mean he's out of the mix forever, but he's a No. 6 or 7 defenseman at this level, and spending some nights in street clothes is an occupational hazard for guys in that role.
Q: Do you find it out of the question that the Penguins win the Stanley Cup this year? No one I know has even mentioned that, but I, for one, think it can and will happen.
Nick, New York City
MOLINARI: Want a list of the reasons the Penguins can't even dream of winning a championship this spring? How about: Most of their core players are barely old enough to vote. Their go-to goalie has a spotty history in high-stakes games. They might be the worst faceoff team since the invention of artificial ice. They don't have a single winger who would be mistaken for a consistent scoring threat.
Clearly, any suggestion that this team could win a Cup at this stage of its development is preposterous. The most ridiculous thing uttered since, oh, about a year ago, when someone said Carolina and Edmonton would meet in the Stanley Cup final. Which, of course, few people -- if any -- did, because such a thing would have been too outrageous to even consider. Anyone who was paying attention, and wasn't wearing partisan blinders, had to know there was very little reason to believe that either, let alone both, would get that far.
Which brings us (finally) to the point: Making a convincing argument for why the Penguins can't win the Cup in 2007 is pretty easy, because they have some significant flaws and soft spots, and logic says it will be a couple of years before they become serious championship threats. But logic didn't give the Hurricanes or Oilers much of chance in 2006, and that didn't seem to matter. Too many things can happen in a best-of-seven series for anything to be taken for granted.
No, the Penguins won't be a favorite in these playoffs, and that's as it should be, given what teams like Buffalo, Detroit and Nashville have done during the past six months. But they're the kind of opponent no team will care to face -- who would ask for the challenge of trying to neutralize Crosby and Evgeni Malkin and a power play that can be downright ferocious? -- and that is capable of taking four games from any club.
Realistically, they should be happy to win a round, maybe two if things break their way. That would be a remarkable accomplishment for a team that finished with the second-worst record in the league a year ago. But like the other 15 teams that quality, the Penguins will enter the tournament with the goal of being the last one standing. After all, someone has to be. And it's not always one that most people expect.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.