Click here to submit your question
Dave Molinari will be on vacation the next four weeks. His Penguins Q & A will return on Aug. 26.
Q: Are the Penguins looking into hiring a "capologist" like most, if not all, NFL teams have? Also, with the draft-lottery system the NHL is planning on using, is it possible for a team like the Rangers or Penguins to drop out of the top four picks? Is there a certain spot below which they can't drop?
Eric Howard of Baldwin
MOLINARI: There's no indication the Penguins plan to hire a capologist, and not much reason to believe that they'll need one anytime soon. Having a specialist on the staff who is familiar with every nuance of the cap, who can assess the plusses and minuses of buyouts and deferred money and other such financial issues, will be critical for teams that are flirting with the cap ceiling and might need to massage their numbers, but the Penguins figure to have a nice cushion between their payroll and the cap.
As for today's draft lottery, the only promise the Penguins and Rangers -- along with Buffalo and Columbus -- have is that they'll each have a 1-in-16 chance of ending up with the No. 1 choice in the lottery, better odds than any of the other 26 clubs. But the draft order will be determined entirely by the lottery. No matter how much, or how little, success a club has had, it could end up with the first choice, the last choice or any choice in between. The draft order, incidentally, will be reversed for Round 2, then again in each subsequent round.
Q: With all the talk about the Pens signing free agents, I am wondering how things look down on the farm. I know we have quite a few good young defensemen who will be ready soon. But are there any talented goal-scorers who might compete for roster spots this year?
Ian Leyda of East Liberty
MOLINARI: The Penguins have a nice collection of young goalies and a very impressive stable of thoroughbred defense prospects, but there is not a true game-breaking goal-scorer anywhere on their depth chart. Winger Michel Ouellet looked as if he might grow into that role during the first half of last season, but lost his touch during the final months of the AHL season. Alex Kovalev, who played the best hockey of his career in Pittsburgh, could help to fill that void, which is why he has been the subject of so much speculation here during the past 12-plus months.
Q: What are the chances that Evgeni Malkin and Aleksey Morozov come over and play in Pittsburgh this year? With a new rookie cap, Malkin might be able to make more money at home, and with the success Morozov had last season and with him still being relatively unproven in the NHL, he will probably be able to make more money overseas, also.
Rob Sroka of Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
MOLINARI: The notion of salary disclosure hasn't taken root in the Russian Super League yet, so it is not known precisely how much Malkin and Morozov will earn if they play in their homeland this winter. There's no doubt, though, that in both cases, it's more than either could make in North America.
It seems reasonable to believe the Penguins will extend a qualifying offer to Morozov, if only to retain his NHL rights. There's not much reason to think, though, that they'll feel obliged to match the money he's getting in Russia; chances are they'll be content to use that $1 million-plus to help sign someone to fill Morozov's spot on the roster.
While the Penguins apparently have not had meaningful negotiations with Malkin's agents since last summer -- such talks have been prohibited since the lockout began -- the point is pretty much moot until the NHL negotiates a new transfer agreement with the International Ice Hockey Federation. That agreement sets the price the Penguins would pay his Russian team, Metallurg Magnitogorsk, to free him from his obligations to it, clearing the way for him to play in the NHL.
Malkin has said all the right things about wanting to prove himself in the NHL, but as long as he can make more money -- and not have to go through any cultural adjustments -- while playing in his hometown, he'll have plenty of incentive to put off joining the Penguins.
And even though the new CBA will put a limit on how long they will retain Malkin's rights -- previously, they could have kept them forever, but now they must have him under contract by June 1, 2008 -- there is no great urgency to get something worked out. Aside from the Penguins' desire to have Malkin begin to get acclimated to life in North America, anyway.
Q: There has been much discussion regarding Sidney Crosby. He is clearly viewed as the consensus No. 1 pick. What does the rest of the draft look like? Is it a deep pool of talent? Who is the No. 2 pick, or is it a toss-up?
Kevin Carpenter of Charlotte, N.C.
MOLINARI: Most scouts seem to think this year's crop of prospects is reasonably good, with 15-20 pretty promising players headlining the Class of 2005. (OK, 14-19 if you put Crosby in a class by himself, where he belongs.) There is, however, no clear-cut choice for the No. 2 prospect. There's a good chance that the identity of the player chosen immediately after Crosby will be determined, in large part, by the needs of the team that ends up with that pick.
U.S. defenseman Jack Johnson, a punishing hitter with excellent offensive skills, is regarded as the top defenseman available, and is directly behind Crosby on a lot of clubs' wish list. Other teams, though, seem partial to wingers like Benoit Pouliot, who is coming off a breakthrough season, and Bobby Ryan, whose power game makes up for lackluster skating.
(The Post-Gazette, by the way, plans to profile several of the top prospects in the days leading up to next Saturday's draft.)
Q: Once the ratification moratorium is over, GMs will be given a few days to sign unsigned 2003 draft picks. Those who aren't signed will added to the 2005 draft. The bigger question is, if some of these guys are European and no transfer agreement is made yet, how can we sign them? Also, what about the 2002 guys not signed?
Joseph Esposito of Rochester, N.Y.
MOLINARI: Players from major-junior hockey must be signed within two years of being drafted, or they're placed back in the talent pool for the entry draft. That is not true of college players, or those from Europe; teams retain the rights to college draftees the entire time they're in school, and hold onto the rights of European prospects for four years. That's a change under the new CBA. Previously, they retained the rights to such players forever. Consequently, while getting a transfer agreement in place would spark movement of prospects from Europe to North America, there is no deadline got getting that done. As for the 2002 draftees to which you referred, the ones who played junior hockey and didn't sign a pro contract by last June were available to be claimed by another team in the 2004 draft.
Q: Now that the NHL has a salary cap, I hear a lot of talk from the Penguins' organization about how they are now able to go out and hit the free-agent market hard. Could this all be just a big bluff to help get the fans excited and sell tickets?
Kevin Schafer of Mount Pleasant
MOLINARI: The Penguins have made a lot of awful decisions over the years -- trading first-round drafts choices for duds like Hartland Monahan and Rod Schutt and giving Howard Baldwin access to the corporate checkbook, for example -- but lying to the fans about how aggressive they plan to be in free agency would be a hands-down winner as the worst in franchise history.
If management would do something that short-sighted -- do you think it would take the public long to figure out that it had been deceived? -- it might as well just takes its season-ticket holder records and any other files it has that pertain to its fan base and feed them into a paper shredder.
Most fans in recent years seemed willing to accept, though sometimes grudgingly, the concept of rebuilding with young players, of enduring short-term setbacks for the sake of long-term success. Consequently, there was no reason for the Penguins to mislead those people about their intention of trying to accelerate the process by bringing in a handful of high-impact veterans this summer.
Now, just because the Penguins are aggressive in the free-agent market doesn't mean they'll be productive; after all, there will be a lot of teams with a lot of money and a lot of open roster spots looking for talent at the same time they are. Nonetheless, there is absolutely no reason to believe that they won't try. Not unless they're looking to break new ground in the field of suicide-by-stupidity.
Q: With the new deal in the books, I am looking forward to a more balanced league. I know there will be much speculation as to the winners and losers in this dispute, but I, for one, am only interested in getting the product back on the ice. From what I have seen, the owners did well, but I would say the players are not going to soup kitchens anytime soon. Looks to me like some give-and-take on all sides.
Tom Roehl of Johnstown, N.Y.
MOLINARI: A comprehensive rundown of what's in the CBA won't be available until at least sometime this afternoon, after it has been ratified by the NHL's Board of Governors. Until the deal is made public, even information from the most reliable of sources must be viewed as at least a little suspect.
With that asterisk in place, it certainly looks as if the owners got most of what they were looking for -- if not everything they wanted -- in the agreement. Most important, the CBA provides the "cost certainty" they craved, because payrolls are linked to a percentage of league-wide revenues. Unless there is some covert provision reporters haven't unearthed (and that the league's lawyers didn't recognize as a dire threat), all 30 franchises should have the tools they need to be competitive on the ice and economically viable.
The players weren't completely shut out, however. Perhaps the biggest concession they received will eventually grant unrestricted free agency to all players whose contracts expire when they are 27 or older, and to players who have seven years in the league, regardless of their age. That will give players, whose freedom has been restricted until they were 31, the ability to shop their services around to the highest bidder at a time when they are in, or just entering, their prime.
And, for all the effort the league put in to closing every conceivable loophole, there's always the possibility someone in the NHLPA or a shrewd agent will find a way to exploit some facet of the CBA in a way no one has imagined yet. After all, it's happened in the past with things like salary arbitration and qualifying offers.
Q: The moment this CBA is approved, if it is, a new CBA needs to be worked on so hockey fans don't lose another year because of stalling and poor planning/time management.
Joe Berret of Alexandria, Va.
MOLINARI: Chances are the league and NHLPA won't wait until the new CBA has expired before they begin serious discussions to sculpt the next one. After all the time and effort the negotiators put into the talks during the weeks leading up to last week's settlement, though, they probably deserve to take the weekend -- OK, at least Saturday -- off before they begin swapping proposals on the next labor agreement.
Q&A readers might not view the CBA as the closest thing to a flawless document to come along since the Constitution, but few seem inclined to tear it up and start over, either. Still, most respondents to last week's question about which facet of the agreement they would change did determine that it could use a bit of fine-tuning. A sampling of those responses, with many edited for brevity and/or clarity:
Joshua Panitzke of Shadyside: The lowered age for unrestricted free agency will lead to stars or extremely popular players leaving earlier and maybe playing for several teams instead of staying put. I understand the financial reasoning behind it for the players, but the fans will see the ill effects of it.
Brian Jackson of San Francisco, Calif.: The one thing I would change about the new CBA is how long it took to make it. I would have created it oh, say, a year ago.
John Latzy of Cary, N.C.: Revenue-sharing should be diminished. With a salary cap, I don't see the reason the small markets need to take more money away from the big.
Garrett Glaser of Baldwin: The worst part of the CBA it is that the league did not adopt more comprehensive revenue-sharing. I believe all teams should have their revenue placed into a central pot and distributed equally amongst the franchises. It's a system that works in the NFL, where teams like Green Bay, Pittsburgh and Oakland can attract and retain top talent on an even bargaining field. My fear with the new NHL CBA is that larger market teams will still find a way to circumvent the cap.
Joseph Esposito of Rochester, N.Y.: I would change the range on the salary cap. It should only be $5 million.
Dave Glass of Clearfield: Having seen the results of other salary cap/revenue-sharing CBAs, I am pretty confident that the worst element of this CBA is still unknown. In a year or two, some really smart GM and his staff will find a loophole to exploit, the rest of the league will quickly follow, and then we'll know.
Dave of Peters: I would remove any link between the terms "player" and "NHLPA" from the CBA. Why make the players join, or stay in, an association that has just been cut off at the knees?
Gary Vater of Bethel Park: Given the cap restrictions for rookies, I fear some of the talent might pursue contracts overseas. As a deterrent, the new CBA should stipulate that, regardless of age, a player's first year in the NHL is considered his first as a pro. In order to move up the pay scale, all players must start at the low end.
Eric Groft of Boston: The year it is implemented. You know: Put it in place for the 2004-2005 season and not lose a year of hockey.
Greg Dober of Plum: At this point, nothing. Worrying about changing this CBA would be like worrying about what was on the dinner menu when the Titanic hit the iceberg. The players don't realize that their TV monies are behind NASCAR or Texas Hold 'em and that there is not an unlimited amount of money for the NHL. The owners need to realize that you can't set up franchises in areas that won't support the game.
Gerry Mangold of Richmond, Va.: I would change the terms for buying out contracts. Instead of buying out at two-thirds of their value after the 24% salary rollback, a team would "pay" the full contract amount before rollback. However, the extra money from my formula would not go to the player. Instead, it immediately would go into the first year's revenue-sharing fund for dispersal to the small-market teams.
Jeff Thieret of Harmony: I think that having no more than 20 percent of the maximum cap value available for any one player will result in some fine European talent staying home instead of playing in the NHL. Overseas markets have to be licking their chops at the prospect of some of their best players staying home.
Kurt Wilson of Mountain View, Calif.: The only CBA change I would made would be to lessen the amount of regular-season games to 72.
Art of Franklin Park: This one is for the fans. I would allow any player re-signed by his current team to have 20% of his new contract not count against the salary cap. This will give teams an upper hand on keeping their free agents.
George Hanna of San Diego, Calif.: In regard to what I would change about the new CBA, it would actually be two things -- Gary Bettman and Bob Goodenow.
Joel Lesher of Lancaster, Pa.: I would like to see the salary floor a little higher. A potential $17 million disparity between the floor and ceiling could encourage the Jeremy Jacobses and Bill Wirtzes of the world to lowball on payroll and pocket the difference.
B>Question of the Week (for Aug. 26 Q&A): Who is the Penguins' best free-agent signing this summer, and which free agent who ended up elsewhere do you wish they'd gotten?
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.