Here are some thoughts from my notebook that I haven’t gotten to this week. In this weekly feature, I will touch on a number of subjects on all things sports. If you have any news tips, column ideas or want to call me names, you can reach me at pzeise@post-gazette.com.

Let’s get started:

Kevin Stefanski led the Cleveland Browns to an 8-26 record over the past two seasons. He mangled the quarterback position worse than just about any NFL coach I can remember. He made the playoffs only twice in six seasons as head coach of the Browns.

He was fired this month, immediately became one of the hottest names on the coaching market and was quickly hired by the Atlanta Falcons.

Advertise with us

What am I missing here? I suppose there were times when Stefanski showed competence, but overall his resume suggests far more bad than good — especially recently.

Stefanski is the poster child for the recycled coach whose reputation far exceeds his record and resume. Maybe it works in Atlanta but I’m not sure I would have a ton of confidence in it given Stefanski’s track record.

And therein lies the issue I always have with this annual coaching carousel in the NFL — it feels a lot more like teams are playing musical chairs on the deck of the Titanic. And it is always amazing to me which guys become the hot candidates despite what their record might actually be.

John Harbaugh was one of the most successful coaches in the NFL over the past two decades. The Ravens fired him — and probably rightfully so because it had the feel of a coach who had gone as far as he could go.

If you move on from a coach like Harbaugh, you better hire someone with a lot of pedigree who isn’t a shot in the dark. The Ravens, instead, hired Jesse Minter, a former Harbaugh assistant who was defensive coordinator for Harbaugh’s brother, Jim, with the Los Angeles Chargers.

Advertise with us

In other words, they replaced Harbaugh with Harbaugh lite.

The Giants hired Harbaugh, and while he is a recycled coach, that made sense. He will make that team and organization better and, unlike Stefanski, has a track record of success.

Another one of the hottest candidates on the market was Robert Saleh, the defensive coordinator for the San Francisco 49ers. Apparently his 20-36 record with the New York Jets and four straight seasons of missing the playoffs before being fired didn’t happen, so the Titans quickly scooped him up.

The Miami Dolphins hired Jeff Hafley, a local fan favorite, and I am rooting for it to work out because he is a great guy I got to know back when he was on Dave Wannstedt’s staff at Pitt. But his only head coaching experience was at Boston College where he was 22-26 (12-22 in ACC games) before moving on to Green Bay as defensive coordinator.

Hafley is a really good coach, but what about that resume jumped him to the top of the list in Miami, with five or six other interviews lined up?

Advertise with us

The NFL is a billion-dollar business and should employ the best and brightest in the world of football and in business. But every year we go through this carousel song and dance, and it never ceases to amaze me how bad many of these people are at hiring and firing coaches.

Let’s put it this way — there will be 10 new coaches hired in this cycle. The question is how many of those 10 coaches will still be in the same job four years from now?

My guess is less than half.

• Speaking of the coaching carousel, the local club is in the midst of conducting interviews. The Steelers have generally been a team that likes to find young, up-and-coming coaches, hire them and let them grow into successful NFL coaches. And that is why it was so head-scratching when they interviewed twice-fired Mike McCarthy the other day.

I was probably like a lot of people who hated the idea of McCarthy at first, but then I dived into the numbers and I will simply say it wouldn’t be the worst hire ever.

Advertise with us

Yes, he is old and would be a recycled coach, but he has been a lot more successful than you think. In fact I would argue this — he was more successful than Mike Tomlin since 2009.

In 2010, McCarthy and the Green Bay Packers beat Tomlin and the Steelers in the Super Bowl. He won five of the next six NFC North titles and led the Packers to five playoff wins and two NFC championship games. He was fired in 2018 and went to the Cowboys. In five seasons in Dallas, he won three division titles and a playoff game. Overall, he is 174-112-2 and 11-11 in the playoffs (Tomlin was 8-12).

Again, I am not in love with the idea of McCarthy, but he would not be the worst hire the Steelers could make.

• Last Saturday, I flipped on the Pitt basketball game against Louisville and it was already something like 28-7 Cardinals, which made it easy to flip off and find something else to do. The other night, I watched some of the Panthers’ game against Boston College and it was brutal to watch — another bad loss on this miserable season.

I have no idea what the school’s plans are for Jeff Capel. But if they ultimately decide to pull the plug, his downfall may very well be loyalty to his assistants. A lot of coaches change and shake up their staff. They want to add new voices, new ideas, fresh energy and so they move on from some assistants. But Capel has been staunchly loyal to his staff.

Advertise with us

That is admirable, but when the program is stagnant or moving backward, there needs be an honest evaluation of what changes make sense. At the very least, if Allen Greene wants to change the direction of the program and can’t afford to buy out Capel’s contract, he should force some staff changes. A lot of coaches have saved their jobs by making staff changes. It isn’t always successful but it is a lot better than doing nothing.

• Basketball season used to be fun and something to get excited about in this region. Now, it is mostly depressing.

Pitt’s struggles have been well-chronicled, Duquesne is 10-9 and near the bottom of the Atlantic 10 standings and Robert Morris is 5-5 in the Horizon League and somewhere in the middle of the standings. It looks like barring a miracle run in a conference tournament, the three Division I programs in this area will be shut out of the NCAA tournament.

It used to be when the men’s teams failed, we had the women’s teams to give us a taste of March Madness. But it is just as bleak on that side.

• The Pirates have moved the needle but their job isn’t done and spring training is coming fast.

Advertise with us

They still need a third baseman, as Jared Triolo is the ultimate utilityman but not an everyday corner infielder. It will be interesting to see if Nick Gonzales can handle shortstop every day defensively. The Pirates need Bryan Reynolds to have a bounce-back year. And, of course, Oneil Cruz has to begin to fulfill his potential, hit better and drive in more runs.

The other major question is at catcher. The Pirates have two light-hitting catchers in Henry Davis and Joey Bart. This needs to be the year that Davis finally arrives.

At the very least, the Pirates need to add a third baseman and it probably wouldn’t hurt them to find a little bit more offense to come off the bench. It has been a good offseason but I’m still grading it as an incomplete.

• A lot of people have asked me, “Why can’t Pitt be the next Indiana?”

The answer is simple — Mark Cuban chose Indiana, not Pitt, to support.

Advertise with us

I am only half-joking, as Cuban is merely one piece of Indiana’s success story. The bottom line is that Pitt needs to find a Mark Cuban or two to push their NIL and revenue sharing numbers higher. Pitt has some generous donors and raises some money, but they are still behind a lot of the teams they are competing with.

Obviously, those resources alone wouldn’t guarantee success, but it would put Pitt in the ballgame at the highest level. The next step would be for Pat Narduzzi and his staff to be incredibly smart in building a roster of transfers and continue to develop players. Curt Cignetti is a wizard and obviously a master evaluator of talent. And his staff did an incredible job, which is the second part of the equation.

In short, Pitt has to decide as an institution if it wants to compete with the big boys. And if it does, it needs to find the resources to do so.