There are a lot of reasons why the Steelers should be better than they were last year, but all of that is on paper. Starting Wednesday, it gets real, as all of the offseason fantasy football comes to an end.

The Steelers start training camp Wednesday, and once that begins, we go from the hypothetical to the real, and I prefer the real always.

There was a lot of discussion about the quarterback position, and while the Steelers had the opportunity to stick with one of the two they had last season — Russell Wilson or Justin Fields — they opted not to sign either. Instead they signed Aaron Rodgers and basically rolled the dice that a 40-something quarterback still has enough left in the tank to get it done.

They upgraded their WR1 spot with DK Metcalf, but the rest of the receiving corps is the same, so I am not sure if they are actually better at that spot. Metcalf is an upgrade over George Pickens, but he will still face the same issues Pickens did unless some of the other receivers step up and prove they are better than they were last year.

Advertise with us

They upgraded their cornerback spot with the addition of Jalen Ramsey and Darius Slay Jr., but they made themselves weaker at safety, theoretically, with the trade of Minkah Fitzpatrick.

I think Kaleb Johnson is a good running back, but he is a rookie. Is the backfield of Jaylen Warren and Johnson really better than the backfield of Najee Harris and Warren? I know why people want to believe that, but I am not sure it is true or will be true until we see it on the field.

I also think moving on from Dan Moore Jr. was necessary, but is Broderick Jones really that much better? Is Jones going to be the answer at left tackle? And, for that matter, will Troy Fautanu going to be ready to go from being an injured player to starting and playing every week?

And Derrick Harmon was a beast at Oregon, but last time I checked, Oregon isn’t in the AFC North. I think he is going to be a guy who takes on double-team blocks and all that, but I have to see it. He is a rookie. And while he seems to be a plug-and-play guy, until we see him play in an NFL game, how does any of us know whether he is ready to play?

I’m not trying to sit here and be a Debbie Downer. That’s not my point at all. I am actually very optimistic about the Steelers and think if all of these things fall into place, they have a chance to be a playoff team that actually wins playoff games.

Advertise with us

All I am saying is that while it is fun to talk about the team and its upgrades on paper and all of the stuff we have talked about for the past six months, games are not played or won on paper. There are some real questions about the Steelers that need to be answered, and I think those answers will start to come Wednesday when training camp opens.

The Steelers have had a lot of moving parts and they have a lot of big names like Ramsey that have been added, but the reality is some of the big names that have been added are past their primes. Some are coming off of injuries and some haven’t been great for a few years.

I get a kick out of the Rodgers discussion, as it is so polarizing. I don’t know how much he has left, which is why I want to see him in training camp before I pass judgment. I think he is an upgrade over Fields and Wilson, but until I see him move around a little and throw the ball, I really won’t know and I am not sure how anyone could know before then, either.

Training camps are usually boring and non-stories when there isn’t much to get excited about, but this Steelers camp should be interesting to anyone who cares about the team. There are so many moving parts and so many variables that I can’t wait to see what it all looks like when it comes together.

It has been a lot of fun dissecting every offseason move of the Steelers and it has been a lot of fun trying to figure out how it all fits together. But that was all basically fantasy football stuff, and things are finally getting real now that training camp is opening. The Steelers may be as good on the field as they appear to be on paper, but only time will tell.

Omar Khan has gotten a lot of credit for putting this team together and he should, but ultimately he will be judged by how this team performs when the lights go on and the games get real.