Heather Lyke breathed life into the Pitt athletic department when she was hired in 2017. Her energy and passion were tangible at a time when it was needed most.
She was a breath of fresh air for an athletic department reeling from a 10-year period of instability and uncertainty.
I maintain that, in fact, she was the right person for the job at the right time. Even though her tenure here came to an end Monday when it was announced that she was fired, she deserves credit for bringing some stability to an unstable position.
Lyke followed the short tenure of Scott Barnes, who is most remembered for hiring Kevin Stallings as basketball coach. That remains one of the biggest disasters, as Stallings' hiring was not well received, and the once successful program hit rock bottom by the end of his second season.
Making matters worse, Barnes hired Stallings in March 2016 but left to become the athletic director at Oregon State, meaning he never had to deal with most of the fallout of the Stallings era. One of Lyke’s first acts at Pitt was to hire Randy Waldrum as the women’s soccer coach, and he has since built that program into a national contender.
Stallings, however, was 24-41 in his two years and lost all 18 ACC games in 2017-18, which was Lyke’s first full year at Pitt. She promptly fired him at the end of the 2018 season and replaced him with popular former Duke assistant Jeff Capel. That act alone gave her instant credibility with many of Pitt’s boosters and alumni, as the Pitt basketball program had been the source of pride for many years but had become an embarrassment.
Read More
However, Lyke’s record of hiring coaches has been spotty at best.
Capel was viewed as a disappointment until his fifth season when he led the Panthers to the NCAA tournament for the first time. Capel was given a lot of time, though, because the program was such a disaster when he arrived. Lyke deserves some credit for sticking with him when many other ADs would have fired him after his fourth season.
She didn’t fare so well hiring women’s basketball coach Lance White, as he never could get the program moving forward. She had to fire him after five seasons that yielded zero winning seasons and a .298 winning percentage. Lyke also hired (and then fired after a lack of success) coaches in the softball and gymnastics programs.
Lyke gets credit for extending the contracts of successful coaches Pat Narduzzi (football), Dan Fisher (volleyball), and Jay Vidovich (men’s soccer), but all three were hired by previous administrations.
In today’s Post-Gazette story about Lyke’s firing, many of the details of her tenure are chronicled. Still, this particular paragraph probably lays out one of the biggest reasons friction developed between chancellor Joan Gabel, who was hired in 2023 and is in her first full year as a chancellor.
“She also oversaw Pitt athletics’ largest development project since Petersen Events Center, Victory Heights — a 240,000-square-foot facility that will include a new home venue for volleyball, gymnastics and wrestling, plus several other training facilities and offices for Pitt sports teams. As of April 2023, Lyke said Pitt had raised around $12 million of the $240 million she said was necessary to complete the entire project.”
That last sentence speaks volumes, as the project was sold as a development project but has not generated nearly enough donations and fundraising funds. It is an expensive endeavor that, given the current financial landscape of college athletics, has been classified as excessive and even not needed by a number of people in Pitt’s administration, according to sources.
The Victory Heights project was especially problematic because it will accommodate sports that don’t generate revenue, and the project will likely have to be supplemented by university money to cover a shortfall in fundraising.
The university also faces the prospect of finding ways to cut costs in the athletic department to pay for the impending settlement between the NCAA and college athletes. The settlement was currently put on hold, but every Division I university in the country is bracing for the financial fallout and trying to figure out ways to pay the estimated $20 million-$30 million yearly to athletes.
Sources said Lyke’s fiscal responsibility was questioned by Gabel, and a number of expenditures on projects at the Petersen Events Center seemed excessive. Frustration mounted with Lyke from Pitt’s NIL coalition, 412 Alliance, as the group believed she could do more to help them raise funds to pay athletes.
Lyke was looking for an extension, but a few weeks ago, it was leaked that she was a finalist at Northwestern. Sources told me that also did not sit well with Gabel, and the friction between the two has grown in the past six months.
In a statement about the firing, Gabel said the quiet part out loud after thanking Lyke and reciting her accomplishments.
“....However, as we enter a new era in college athletics, one that seems to change by the day, we need a new vision and a new leader of our athletics department. On behalf of all Panthers, we wish Heather and her family the best with appreciation for their service to Pitt.”
In the end, Lyke’s tenure should be remembered as a net positive for Pitt, but it also seemed like the university needed to change direction.
Some very difficult fiscal and financial decisions will need to be made. A new way of doing business will have to be developed to accommodate the big changes coming to the world of athletics, and Pitt will have to hire someone with the vision to see it through.
That person will need to embrace NIL and fiscal responsibility regarding vanity projects that have traditionally been standard operating procedures for athletic departments. That person will also need to embrace the new world where universities actually pay athletes and what that will mean in terms of budgeting priorities.
It will not be easy for whoever Pitt hires, and Gabel thought Lyke was not the right person for the job.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.