Matt Canada had become a lightning rod for criticism, and in recent weeks it almost felt like people were piling on.

No, I don’t think all of the Steelers' problems were caused by him. And no, I don’t think this should be the only change.

Make no mistake, though: the Steelers — particularly Art Rooney II — had no choice. He absolutely needed to fire him.

There are some who will say that this is scapegoating, but it is not. Canada earned it over the course of his two-plus seasons as the Steelers offensive coordinator.

Advertise with us

The numbers are ugly, and quite frankly, I am not sure how Canada survived this long when you look at them.

Canada called plays for 45 games (44 regular season, one playoff), and the Steelers achieved 30 points only two times, both in losses. The Steelers averaged 18.56 points per game during the 44 regular season games, but that is actually a little inflated when you consider the defensive touchdowns they scored.

The Steelers never put up 400 yards in a game under Canada, and in 32 of those games, they failed to score 20 points. The Steelers have been outgained in every game this year, have some ridiculous streak of not achieving 27 points and are 28th in offense (280.2 yards per game) and 28th in scoring (16.6 points per game).

I could go on and on and on, but at some point it becomes redundant.

The fact is the Steelers' offense has stunk pretty much since Canada took over. It stunk with Ben Roethlisberger. It stunk with Mason Rudolph. It stunk with Mitch Trubisky.

Advertise with us

And it has stunk with Kenny Pickett.

So that’s that - Canada deserved to be fired, should have been fired long ago and should not have even been hired in the first place. He was never going to work as an NFL offensive coordinator given his offensive philosophies. More importantly, if you take away one year when he had James Conner and company and a great offensive line at Pitt, his resume as a college offensive coordinator is a whole lot of “meh.”

He should not have been hired; he should have been fired a long time ago, and he got his dismissal the old-fashioned way: he earned it.

Now that it is done, however, don’t kid yourself into thinking that the problem with the Steelers' offense has been solved. Canada was a problem, but he wasn’t the only problem, and I don’t necessarily think the Steelers will become the early 1980s Chargers now that he is gone.

Canada needed to be removed because the Steelers invested a first-round pick in a quarterback last year, and in year two, not only has he not progressed, but he seemingly has regressed.

Advertise with us

Pickett was better last year than he is this year, was more confident last year than he is this year, and that is on Canada as much as anyone else. When an NFL team hands the offensive coordinator a first-round quarterback, that is a significant deal, and if it doesn’t work out, the coordinator almost always will pay with his job.

The thing is ... Pickett — and I am going to be kind here — has not been good, either.

He has been slow to make decisions, taken bad sacks, overthrown and underthrown receivers and has yet to play consistently well for an entire game.

The decision to fire Canada means Pickett is on the clock. The Steelers made the first decision so they could evaluate Pickett absent Canada as they need to figure out if he is their quarterback of the future. Pickett needs to improve — and significantly — between now and the end of the season, or the Steelers need to be in the market for a quarterback in the offseason.

Pickett has been the biggest factor in the offensive struggles, but like Canada, he was only a part of the factor.

Advertise with us

A couple of weeks ago, Broderick Jones replaced Chuks Okorafor at right tackle, and that move, in hindsight, was similar to shuffling the chairs on the deck of the Titanic. The offensive line has been incredibly inconsistent in run blocking and has had too many breakdowns in pass protection.

That is disappointing because the Steelers have invested a lot into the offensive line over the past two seasons, and it is mediocre at best. Dan Moore at left tackle has had a rough stretch of games. Mason Cole at center is not good enough.

Jones is a rookie and has shown it in his inconsistency. Isaac Seumalo was supposed to be the big addition, but he has been a disappointment. If your offensive line isn’t performing well, it is really hard to run good offense, and so while I think Canada’s offense was elementary and made no sense, again, it wasn’t all his fault.

I haven’t even gotten to the running backs, because they have actually, for the most part, run well. But someone needs to explain to me how one running back averages 3.9 yards per carry and the other averages 6.2, and the first guy is the starter.

And here is one other thing: Diontae Johnson needs to play better, and for all of his glory, George Pickens is a lazy route runner, a lazy player and a guy who I haven’t figured out if he really wants to be a great player. The rest of the receiving corps is pedestrian, which is on the front office, as they clearly didn’t adequately address this area during the offseason.

Advertise with us

Yes, Canada was a big problem and it was time for a change, but the Steelers offense has a lot of flaws, and removing the coordinator won’t solve them all.

Nevertheless, this isn’t about the rest of the offense now; it is about Pickett, and he has seven games to prove he is the right quarterback to take the Steelers into the future.

And now that Canada is gone, it is all up to him to prove that Canada was indeed the problem.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com or Twitter: @paulzeise