If you just read the headlines about Pitt from Thursday it all sounds really bad. Three years of probation, coaches with show cause orders, recruiting restrictions, fines, etc. It seems as if Pitt must have broken some major rules and cheated on the level of the Houston Astros. It must be terrible stuff that the school and its coaches engaged in, and heads are going to roll.
And then you read what actually went on, and it is yet another confirmation of what most of us already know and that is that the NCAA and its enforcement office have become a parody of themselves and need to go away ASAP.
I mean, this is a joke, right? Extra coaches coaching at practice and holding up play cards? Oh, the horror!
Look, I am all about rules and law and order, but this is absolutely stupid stuff from a stupid organization. If the NCAA is so concerned about how many coaches are on the field or court coaching at practice, here is a novel idea: Limit how many people can be on the staff.
All the NCAA has to do is take away all of the extra guys on every staff. Take away the quality control guys, director of operations guys, assistant film guys, coaching interns, graduate assistants and all the job titles that head coaches give to guys once they have already hit the limit of actual assistant coaches they are allowed.
What in the world is the reason for allowing all these guys on the staff if, for instance, they aren’t allowed to participate in practice? And more importantly, what turnip truck did you have to just get off if you believe these people — literally thousands of them across the country — sit quietly and never get involved in helping in some capacity outside of their normal scope?
Read More
Non-official assistant coaches holding play cards up for the scout team is an NCAA violation, apparently. Are you serious? Why have these people around if they aren’t allowed to help out?
But until such time, stop with all of these silly rules that do nothing except make it nearly impossible for any school to comply. Truth be told, if a compliance officer and athletic director look hard enough, they could probably find minor violations in just about all of their programs. And most of them exist because coaches either don’t know or don’t understand the nuance of every one of these rules.
And just to be clear on where I am coming from: I have no sympathy for Pitt, here, because the athletic department did it to itself. The department was clearly looking to find some leverage for its buyout negotiations with Kevin Stallings. This isn’t the first time a coach’s minor NCAA infractions were used to win a court battle or in the court of public opinion.
In this case, though, they caught a non-assistant participating in practice in some capacity. I guarantee you the athletic department wasn’t interested in finding anything other than dirt on the basketball program, which is all a part of the hypocrisy that comes with these kinds of things.
And there is strong evidence to this fact given that this negotiated settlement between Pitt and the NCAA gave Pat Narduzzi, who did essentially the same thing as Stallings, a far lighter punishment. Why isn’t Narduzzi’s show cause three years like Stallings is? Because it’s a trumped charge against both coaches, and both Pitt and the NCAA knows it.
It is funny, though, that Stallings has a three-year show cause but we have head coaches at places like Arizona, Kansas, Auburn and Miami — programs that were immersed knee deep in the shoe company/FBI/bag men scandal — that are unscathed and still coaching. How does that work?
Don’t answer, I’ll tell you — because the NCAA Is a bully, but it is a coward and only looks to show how serious it is about the rules on the backs of the patsies like Stallings.
This kind of nonsense will continue as long as schools and college presidents allow it to continue. The NCAA is archaic and not particularly useful any more as an institution. And now with the way the economics in college athletics have changed, schools and conferences don’t need the NCAA in order to make big money deals.
It is time for the top programs to break free of the NCAA and form their own league with their own rules — rules that make sense, rules that aren’t designed to create confusion and rules that don’t require a PHD in compliance to understand and enforce. The NCAA at one time probably was good at what it does and probably did understand its mission statement, but those days are long gone.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.