Neal Huntington is convinced the Pirates will be a contender next season. Of course, that’s what he said about last season. And this season. And I’m sure he will say the same thing about 2021.
And it’s wonderful that he believes it. But as we’ve found out every year since 2015, that doesn’t make it so.
The Pirates front office lives in a fantasy world these days, but not because they believe they are building a playoff roster. They are living in a fantasy world because they actually think people are still buying the stuff they are selling. There may actually be a plan in place, but nobody outside of Huntington has any idea what it is or when it is actually going to come together.
Huntington and Co. got away with all of their rationalizations and explanations for a long, long time. And that’s mostly because fans wanted to believe better days were coming, and the three playoff seasons gave them something to hang on to. The fan base, however, has finally grown tired of all of the condescending nonsense about how hard they are actually trying to win.
And days like Wednesday’s trade deadline don’t do very much to help the credibility of the front office. Nor do they give fans any reason to be optimistic about the future.
The goal of this trade deadline for the Pirates should have been to either improve the big-league team or improve the farm system. Huntington accomplished neither as the Pirates are actually worse now than they were a day ago. And their farm system isn’t any better now than it was a day ago, either.
Read More
I had no issue, by the way, with the Pirates holding on to closer Felipe Vazquez if the Dodgers weren’t willing to give up a king’s ransom for him. Nobody will ever know what the discussions between the two teams were, but I’d have to believe Huntington held out for the deal he wanted and walked away when he didn’t get it.
And I will be OK with the Pirates apparently not trying very hard to trade Starling Marte provided they give him a contract extension and keep him around for a few more years. Marte is their best player, and while he has hit that magical age of 30, he has shown no signs of slowing down. He has two option years left that will pay him $24 million. I say the Pirates should offer to tear them up and then offer him something like a four-year, $48 million deal, with most of the money in the first two years.
What the Pirates did give away, though, were Jordan Lyles and Corey Dickerson. The question is why did they stop there? Why not move on from Melky Cabrera, Francisco Liriano and Jung-Ho Kang (even if Kang needed to be designated for assignment) and go with a full on youth movement?
There is no reason to keep those players around on a team going nowhere. Huntington gave some gibberish about their “leadership,” but again, thankfully fans aren’t buying what he is selling any more. There would have been buyers for Liriano and Cabrera, and even if the return was similar to what he got for Dickerson and Lyles, it would have been worth it.
The Pirates need to go with their younger players and top prospects such as Ke’Bryan Hayes and Will Craig for the rest of this season. Huntington said, “We are still going to try to win games,” but the fan base is way beyond celebrating trying to get to 81 wins. That ship sailed in 2013, which, in the world of sports, is a long, long time ago.
Maybe there is a method to Huntington’s madness, but based on the recent track record, I doubt it. It was a lot easier to give him the benefit of the doubt when the three playoff years were still fresh in our minds. It would also be easier to give him the benefit of the doubt if it appeared as if there was a plan in place, but there doesn’t seem to be one, and that’s Huntington’s biggest problem.
The trade deadline is supposed to bring hope, but in the case of the Pirates, all it did was bring more of the same. And that’s just not good enough for now, and it’s certainly not good enough for the future.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.