CINCINNATI — Neal Huntington listened.
Intently, too.
But in the end, nothing that came across the Pirates general manager’s desk on Wednesday involving a potential deal for closer Felipe Vazquez made sense.
“We did not feel that this was the right time, nor do we feel like we got the right potential return to [trade Vazquez],” Huntington said.
With Vazquez still a Pirate after the trade deadline, the team is confronted with a bit of an odd competitive landscape.
The Pirates aren’t in total rebuild mode, as evidenced by Huntington saying, “We’re still in it this year, technically speaking.” But they also began the day Thursday with the second-worst record in the National League, 10½ games out of first place in the National League Central and 10 back of the wild card.
Read More
While playoff baseball should not be a realistic focal point for fans the rest of the way, there are a bunch of reasons why these final 54 games matter. What are they? Let’s take a look.
Infield logjam
This shouldn’t come as a shock given his .169 batting average and alarming strikeout rate (60 in 172 at-bats), but the Pirates were forced to keep 32-year-old Jung Ho Kang at the trade deadline.
On Friday, it wouldn’t be surprising if the Pirates decided to designate him for assignment.
“That is a valid question and conversations that we need to have as a group here now that the trade deadline has come and gone,” Huntington said of potentially DFA’ing Kang.
Why do that?
Because Kang, who’s on an expiring contract, is simply taking up space at this point. Colin Moran, Kevin Newman and Adam Frazier have all done things this season to earn regular playing time, and the Pirates should take this final stretch of games to examine what they have in Ke’Bryan Hayes and Cole Tucker.
The clock is also ticking on Erik Gonzalez’s rehab assignment; he could/should be back next week, if not before.
Huntington emphasized a couple times that the Pirates are going to do everything they can to win games until they’re officially eliminated from the playoffs, but that doesn’t exactly jibe with another statement he made.
“We’re working to build a quality foundation for next year,” Huntington said. “These young players and even some of our mid-level veteran players, they’re gaining experience.
“They’re learning what they can and can’t do. They’re learning how teams are pitching them and how they need to make adjustments. Every single game at the major league level is a learning experience as well as an opportunity to go out to compete to win.”
Outfield auditions
With Corey Dickerson now a member of the Philadelphia Phillies, the Pirates have an open outfield spot with which to work. What happens?
A couple things, possibly.
One, look for Jose Osuna (7 home runs in 89 at-bats) to get some playing time out there. The Pirates would also like to give another shot to Pablo Reyes, a 25-year-old who was on their opening day roster.
Reyes suffered an ankle injury earlier this season but has found his stroke of late, hitting .351 (20-for-57) with five home runs and 11 RBIs over his last 16 games at Class AAA. They’d even like to take a longer look at Jason Martin.
“[The Dickerson trade] gives us some opportunities to give some young players who are going to be or could be key parts of our 2020 and beyond clubs major league experience, major league exposure,” Huntington said.
Pitching problems
For the first month of the season, as Huntington pointed out, the Pirates had the best starting pitching in baseball. Once the water found its level, however, it wasn’t pretty.
The Pirates began the day Thursday with the eighth-highest ERA in baseball (4.96). Meanwhile, their ace, Jameson Taillon, is in a weird holding pattern when it comes to his right elbow/forearm, with another serious surgery possible.
We’ll get to Chris Archer. Trevor Williams and Joe Musgrove have shown flashes, but even Huntington said Wednesday that “short-term results have not been what any of us are looking for” when it comes to those two and other members of the starting rotation.
The rest of the season should be looking for good news on Taillon, getting enough out of Williams and Musgrove to feel good about their rotation spots next season and making a final determination on Archer.
Per Spotrac, Archer has a $8.25 million option for next season, or the Pirates can buy him out for $1.75 million.
Looking strictly at numbers, the buyout makes more sense. In 2017, one win above replacement cost about $10.5 million. Archer this season has given the Pirates 0.3, carrying a theoretical price tag of $3.15 million.
Furthermore, it’s hard to imagine the Pirates spending $8.25 million on much, let alone a pitcher who went 3-8 with a 5.58 ERA the previous year, as Archer has done.
The problem is what the Pirates gave up to get Archer: Austin Meadows, Tyler Glasnow and Shane Baz. Buy Archer out, have literally nothing to show for those prospects, and the deal looks even worse.
Best-case scenario is that Archer builds on what he did during his first start out of the break — his best in a Pirates uniform — and makes it a no-brainer for the Pirates to pick up his 2020 option.
“We still see the stuff out of Chris Archer,” Huntington said. “We’re going to get him right.”
Catching fever
The Pirates need more out of Elias Diaz and Jacob Stallings, plain and simple.
After a weird illness, Diaz opened his season strong enough and Stallings does handle pitchers well. But the Pirates’ .610 combined OPS out of their catchers ranks last in the National League. The guys behind the plate have combined to hit .237 with four home runs and 29 RBIs — not good at all.
Sure, Francisco Cervelli’s concussion issues have thrown a wrench into their plans, but we’re talking more about next year than anything. Use the rest of this season to figure out what you have, if anything, behind the plate. Then put getting a catcher very high on your offseason shopping list.
“We will explore the trade and free agent markets to see if there’s a way that we can improve our catching,” Huntington said.
Also problematic: Among the Pirates’ top 30 prospects according to MLB Pipeline, not one of them is a catcher.
Bell ringing
Another reason to pay attention to the rest of this season has nothing to do with young guys getting additional opportunities.
Josh Bell was a legitimate MVP candidate for the first couple months of this season. Lately, he’s been a ghost.
Over his past 19 games, Bell is hitting just .156 (10-for-64) with no home runs, four RBIs and 19 strikeouts.
The baseball season is long. Even the best players are going to encounter slumps. But for a guy coming off a pretty bad season last year, Bell and the Pirates will want to see things pick up — not expecting the level Bell was at in May, but somewhere in the middle would work.
Keller question
Mitch Keller will return to the big leagues at some point this season. The question, really, is when.
Manager Clint Hurdle said during the Reds series that he did not envision a scenario where Keller came up for one or two starts — without some sort of assurance that he would be around awhile.
From how Huntington made it sound, Hurdle may get overruled here, or there’s some sort of happy medium between the two ways of looking at this.
“Part of the [Jordan] Lyles move and part of the Dickerson move is to clear a spot for [Steven] Brault as he comes back or for Keller at some point here looking forward depending upon health and whether we go to a six-man rotation at some point in August,” Huntington said.
Regardless of the reason, the Pirates need to see what they have in Keller, if for no other reason than the fact that it should inform what they do (or don’t do) in the offseason.
“We do believe we have the core of a good rotation,” Huntington said. “We’ll look to add to it if something makes sense this offseason.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.