Neal Huntington traded for Chris Archer hoping he was bringing a top-of-the-rotation-type pitcher to the Pirates. He gave up a lot to make the trade happen and he was, for the most part, praised for making such a bold move.

It didn’t happen for Archer last season, but there was plenty of optimism that he’d find his form again in 2019.

So far, well, it still hasn’t happened. And at this point, the trade to get him here is looking more and more like it will be the worst of Huntington’s time as general manager. Archer has made 15 starts and is 3-6 with a 5.49 ERA and a 1.47 WHIP. Perhaps even more disappointing is the fact that in 15 starts, he has made it further than six innings only twice and has gone less than six innings 10 times.

Those aren’t the numbers — or anywhere close to the numbers — of a top of the rotation pitcher. Those numbers suggest a pitcher who is below average, one not reliable enough to help stabilize the Pirates rotation.

Advertise with us

That has to change after the All-Star break if the Pirates want to have any chance to still be in contention in September. The Pirates, especially with Jameson Taillon on the shelf, need Archer to step up and become the pitcher they thought they were getting when they traded for him.

There are simply too many unknowns in the Pirates rotation to have one of the pitchers who was supposed to be a sure thing be so unreliable. Archer needs to pitch more efficiently, eat more innings and give the Pirates a quality start (or better) pretty much every outing. If he doesn’t, it will be the hard for the Pirates to win consistently enough to make a legitimate push for the playoffs.

It may seem unfair to put so much of the pressure on Archer, but it isn’t. Trevor Williams has struggled since he returned from the injured list, but I expect him to round into form and become the dominant pitcher he was for most of last season. The other three starters — Steven Brault, Jordan Lyles and Joe Musgrove — all must do their part too, but all of them are limited in some capacity and thus will have a degree of inconsistency. Lyles was lights out early in the season but has regressed; Brault is gritty and a fighter ,but he hasn’t had a history of sustained success as a starter, and the same goes for Musgrove.

If one of those three falters, the Pirates have some other options in the minors to call up to fill their roles. They cannot replace what Archer can be if he is pitching to his capabilities.

My colleague Jason Mackey wrote that he is moving away from the Pirates’ “pitch to contact” philosophy and instead is going back to the way he pitched — and had success — when he was with the Rays. He will get back to trying to strike out batters and throw more sliders.

Advertise with us

I don’t know if that will work, but it is good that he is trying to do something to change the course of his season.

Archer’s last last three seasons in Tampa, however, were mostly mediocre. That tells me it isn’t about philosophies or strategies; he just needs to throw better pitches. That will give the Pirates a much better chance of staying in the playoff race.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise