CLEVELAND — Hi there and welcome to our weekly Pirates mailbag. You’re stuck with me this week, but it looks like yinz have a lot of question about the club, which is 2 1/2 games out of first place at the All-Star break.
As always, ask your questions via email or Twitter; both addresses are at the bottom of this file.
Joe Paul (@_JwP4_): What is your outlook on Archer going into All-Star break, and do you think he will be producing better numbers after a break?
Jason Mackey: Chris Archer is one of the biggest story lines to watch for me going into the second half.
Talked to Archer the other day about how he’s approached things. It’s a story I’ll write later this week.
But the gist is this: He’s getting back to pitching more like he did in Tampa and less how most guys do in Pittsburgh.
Read More
I think that’s big for him. I think he’s a lot better than he’s shown. And if he gets back to being more of a strikeout guy and forgets about pitching to contact, I think things could really improve for him.
That means more sliders and fewer two-seamers, and I think you’ll see more of that from Archer in the second half.
KRJonj (@krsaundry): With Will Craig being having a good season in the minors, but being blocked at 1B by Bell, will the Pirates move him at the deadline for pitching help?
Jason Mackey: If this continues, meaning the Pirates are within striking distance of the division, I would imagine they will at least entertain doing something; however, given what Neal Huntington said on Sunday — essentially that his approach the past three deadlines hasn’t worked — I’m sort of expecting them to stand pat. I’m not sure that’s the wrong approach, either.
Should they decide to do something, though, and a team was interested in Craig, yes, I could see it happening. But I think the bigger question is for whom the Pirates would be moving Craig. I don’t think they’re going to go out and get a marquee name.
If they make a minor add, I’m not sure it would take a top prospect to get him.
mike fouse (@Mfouse300): Who would win a fight between Clint Hurdle and Joe Maddon?
Jason Mackey: Neither. Joe West would get in between them, and it would never happen. Dude should maybe think about re-careering as an offensive tackle.
Joe Valentine (@donuncly): Who are the odd men out when Polanco, Gonzalez, & Cervelli return?
Jason Mackey: I don’t see a spot for Gonzalez on this team. I think they’ll try to get Polanco in the mix because of how he heated up last year during the second half and also because I think he would be tough to move.
I also think it’s going to be tough to move Cervelli, but given what he’s working on — learning a new position and no longer being able to catch — I’m not sure what the market is going to be there.
I could see them keeping Cervelli around as an extra set of eyes and ears with the pitching staff and a late-inning bat off the bench. If they have injuries, I guess I could see them using him as a platoon backup, too.
Lynda Brooks (@_keithlynda): Why isn’t Bryan Reynolds in the talk for ROY? By MLB rules, what is the minimum number of games that he has to play in to be considered? Also, can either Moran or Newman have a shot at ROY this season or have they been around too long?
Jason Mackey: He should be getting some talk, but it is a tough race. Actually a really tough race. I think Pete Alonso at this point is a runaway winner. But when we’re talking about Fernando Tatis Jr., Alex Verdugo, Chris Paddack, Mike Soroka and even Austin Riley, that’s a crowded field.
Not saying Reynolds doesn’t belong, but I think maybe that’s why the other guys are getting more buzz.
Moran isn’t eligible, and I think you would have to put Newman behind Reynolds.
Larry VANALLEN (@LarryVanallen): Why isn't Josh Bell having his dad throw at the HRD?
Jason Mackey: Because Earnest Bell can’t pitch. Seriously.
Josh has said it, and his mom talked about it in the takeout piece I did on Josh. The dad doesn’t even like to pitch; so, it was never really in the conversation.
Jonathan Marasco (@JonathanMarasc1): Who are some trade possibilities?
Jason Mackey: I think it’s too early for this type of stuff, Jonathan. Also, as a general rule I had on hockey, the blind speculation thing is pretty much always futile. I think they could add a starting pitcher on the cheap. But who that is? That’s nearly impossible to predict at this time.
JMcDermott (@DaddyDerms): With seemingly the Pirates being 'buyers,’ would you go for a starter … who, and who would be on the hook to get shipped out?
Jason Mackey: Again, I don’t think it’s going to be any big names; I think Huntington plans on respecting this club — his words — by at least standing pat should things continue down this path.
JohnMon (@John_Mon13): Will Pirates be slow with Hayes as Moran is having a good season or do you see Moran being used more in LF and 2B in future?
Jason Mackey: I think the Pirates are letting Hayes develop, as they should. He’s not ready, especially now. Where would you play him?
Right now, you pretty much have to play Moran, Newman and Frazier. You have Kang as a platoon backup and maybe Cervelli. Plus, Erik Gonzalez could be around, if they so choose. Then Cole Tucker is ahead of Hayes, and he could bump Newman over to third or second, as he’s more position flexible.
Hayes has more to do to prove he’s ready to make his MLB debut. I don’t see it happening this year.
Neil Parker (@NeilPar49897889): If Cervelli, Gonzalez and Polanco are activated later in July, how do you see the roster shuffle? Who gets sent down, traded or DFA’d?
Jason Mackey: I don’t see them DFA’ing any of those guys. If they got a deal for Gonzalez, I could see that happening.
I question what the return would be for the other two; you’d be selling both with low, low value, and I’m not sure that makes sense.
They could DFA Cervelli, I suppose, but I don’t get the sense they’re considering that given how Huntington has talked about a position switch with him.
Bobby Reese (@BuStA607): Who would be some prospects that the Pirates are willing to trade if they decide to add?
Jason Mackey: I would imagine that Mitch Keller is probably the only one who is untouchable at this point. But again, I don’t see them being aggressive buyers here.
Chip Kissinger (@chipkissinger): Is Kevin Newman a good enough defensive shortstop to stick long-term at the position, making Tucker available for pitching prospects and leaving Frazier and Kevin Kramer to battle for 2nd base?
Jason Mackey: Long-term, I think I probably see Tucker there. He’s a better defensive shortstop. But you need to have a spot to get Tucker reliable at-bats at this point, and I’m not sure that opening is there.
It does help that Newman can play other positions. If they went Newman, Tucker, Frazier and Moran and rotated them among three spots, I don’t think that’s the worst thing. But what do you do with Kang?
Bacon Burt (@BaconBurt): Do you think Erik Gonzalez has a long-term future in Pittsburgh, with Newman performing so well and Cole Tucker in AAA still?
Jason Mackey: I don’t see it, Bacon Burt. I think when they acquired Gonzalez, it was under the assumption that neither Newman nor Moran would do what they’ve done.
Those two have been fantastic, and they’ve hit way better than Gonzalez conceivably will. I don’t see how you could take either out in favor of Gonzalez, honestly.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.