Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.
Let’s get started:
Thomas: The Pirates need to trade, but how can anyone trust this job to Huntington? After his misadventures last year and his sharp trading for Hutchinson before that, he can't be trusted to make a good deal or even a MEDIOCRE deal.
Paul: I understand the sentiment, but I don’t know that it is particularly fair. Huntington has not had a great run of success recently, but his body of work overall is still very good. The Chris Archer deal has been a bust. The Keone Kela deal has been a bust. The Gerrit Cole deal has been a bit underwhelming, though Colin Moran and Joe Musgrove have brought some value with them. The Andrew McCutchen deal looks more and more like a big win for Huntington. Even the best of the best general managers miss from time to time. Huntington needs to do better than he has the last two or three years, but for the most part his track record shows he is indeed the man for the job.
Ron: Has Ray Searage lost his touch? He has not helped a pitcher regain his groove since J.A. Happ in 2015.
Paul:I don’t believe coaches “lose their touch” and I have often thought the pitching coach’s impact is overrated. Like Huntington, Searage’s body of work is mostly positive and the good has outweighed the bad. The “pitch to contact” philosophy has not worked well for some pitchers — like Gerrit Cole and Charlie Morton — and that helps explain their success elsewhere. The writing about Archer has been on the wall for quite some time. He is a slightly above average pitcher and not much more than that. Searage is not the problem, and if you want to give him grief for Cole, Morton, Glasnow and Archer, then you have to give him credit for Trevor Williams and Jordan Lyles, too.
Read More
John: I agree Archer was painful to watch for at least two innings. For a while there he was very effective keeping the ball low in the hitting zone. It seems to me that he locked in his concentration for a while and just as quickly, lost it. The same seems to be glaringly true of Gregory Polanco and Starling Marte. Any thoughts?
Paul: I think you are tying three players together whose issues are not the same. Archer, as I said before, is just a painfully average pitcher, maybe a little better. The expectations for him are too high. And one of the knocks on him has always been that he is a little too casual and doesn’t quite push himself enough, and that is easy to see. Polanco is just a bad defensive player and bad base runner, mostly because he doesn’t have a natural feel for either. Marte is the one who seems to lose focus on the base paths from time to time, but you live with it because he is so good in so many other areas.
Joe: Has Gregory Polanco hit his expiration date here? At this point he is Jose Tabata with more power.
Paul: I don’t think so because he does bring something to the table offensively. He is — or at least can be — a very good hitter. He has power, he can hit the ball into the gaps and he has gotten better at hitting it the other way. His defense is below the line, he is not good at judging balls and not good at running bases. But the Pirates won’t have many options for the outfield after they sell off a couple of players at the trade deadline. The Pirates need as many major league players as they can afford to have hanging around, and Polanco is a more than competent hitter.
Nate: Jay Bell led the National League in sacrifice hits in back to back years, 39 in 1990, 30 in 1991. Last year Julio Tehran and Delino Deshields had a dozen a piece. With all the awful hitters in the game today, why aren’t more guys laying down bunts and taking their chances with the horrible fielding in today’s game? I like the home runs, but the strikeouts are out of control.
Paul: One word: analytics. The numbers suggest if you sacrifice bunt, you are essentially playing for one run. If you don’t give up an out and have all your hitters swing away, you are playing for multiple runs in that inning. A lot of managers don’t sacrifice because they don’t want to give away an out and hinder their chances of having a big inning.
Bossman: Did you ever work on a college beat here in Pittsburgh, Paul? If so, how did you manage it being a Temple alum?
Paul: The “controversy” among Pitt fans with regards to the Post-Gazette’s new beat reporter (John McGonigal) and his alma mater (Penn State) is the most Black Helicopter-level Pitt fan conspiracy theory ever. First off, Jerry Micco, the “Penn State fan head of department” hasn’t been the head of our sports department in at least five years, and in fact we’ve already replaced the guy who replaced him. Our new boss is Tyler Batiste, an LSU grad from New Orleans, who I am quite sure has no dog in this fight. He hired John because John does and will do good work. Yes, I get it, the one PSU fan beat reporter a few years back did things to intentionally troll Pitt (like wear his Penn State coat to practice), but I think you all should give John a chance before you start the “go back to crappy valley” chants at him. In short, do better Pitt fans — much better.
Barry J: In a former life, was Craig Meyer a sharpshooting 3-point specialist?
Paul: So I am told. However, I played hoops once with Craig and am fairly sure I did not see a poor man’s Steph Curry. He is indeed a 3-point shooter, but not really a 3-point maker.
Pittsburgh Sports Trump Fan: How is your son doing with the Chargers?
Paul: He is doing well. He is working hard and just taking his shot. He is a little homesick, I think, but he will get a chance to come home for a few weeks before training camp. He is having fun and he enjoys the team and the coaching staff, so I can’t complain.
Rob: Do you think the Pitt football team can repeat as ACC Coastal champions this season?
Paul: Yes, if they win their opener against Virginia, they should be favored in all of their Coastal Division games the rest of the way. I think this is the year that they put it all together and actually get back to Charlotte and win the game once they get there.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.