The Pitt football team took a few steps forward last season despite going 7-7.

Yes, the Panthers were blown out by Penn State, Central Florida and Clemson and they lost to an awful North Carolina team. They also lost their last three games and looked fairly bad -- especially on offense — at times in doing so. They also blew a chance to win a bowl game for the first time since Pat Narduzzi took over, as they lost to a depleted Stanford team in the Sun Bowl.

All of that is why the Panthers’ successes last season have been overlooked. Pitt did finish .500 overall, but the Panthers were 6-2 in ACC games. They won the ACC Coastal Division title for the first time. They also improved defensively as the season went on and first-year coordinator Randy Bates put his personal touches on Narduzzi’s scheme.

It is impossible to call a .500 season an overwhelming success, and so that’s not how I’d classify the 2018 season. At the same time, it is also impossible to call a season in which a team won a division title a total failure.

Advertise with us

The truth is somewhere in between, but as the team prepares to play its annual spring game Saturday, the reality is that this is a big season for the Panthers under Narduzzi. He is entering his fifth year as the Panthers’ coach, and it is time for him to take the program to the next level.

Narduzzi has a winning overall record (28-24) and a winning record in ACC games (20-12), but his teams have generally left you with the “should have done more” feeling. That is what many rebuilding programs do in the first few years, but it is time for Narduzzi to show he has the program on the right path.

Pitt hasn’t been an elite program since the early 1980s, but the Panthers have knocked on the door of that a few times since then. Mike Gottfried had some of the most talented Pitt teams ever but he never could figure out how to make that translate into wins. The Larry Fitzgerald era followed by a trip to the Fiesta Bowl was the height of the Walt Harris era, but he could never get them over that hump, either.

Dave Wannstedt took over for Harris and got the team close to that breakthrough again but was fired essentially because he couldn’t win that one big game to put the Panthers into BCS bowl games. Pitt had been a bit of a disaster since Wannstedt but Paul Chryst got the program stable and Narduzzi was supposed to use his recruiting prowess to take the program back to the level it was at under Wannstedt and beyond.

That hasn’t happened yet, and some in the Pitt fan base are getting restless with Narduzzi. They see a disturbing trend of losing games they are supposed to win. They see a team that pulled off huge upsets early in Narduzzi’s career that has recently gotten blown out by the best teams on the schedule too often.

Advertise with us

That may or may not be a fair way to look at Narduzzi’s tenure, but fans and administrators want results. Narduzzi has delivered on some of those things but in Year 5, with an experienced quarterback in place, it is time for him to take the Panthers forward.

There are many discussions about what is “next level” for the Panthers and often they yield a lot of unrealistic expectations. That is a silly discussion in some ways because it is so subjective, but a good place to start would be to just win all the games Pitt is supposed to in a given year.

That is easier said than done, apparently, as the Panthers have underachieved almost every season since the early 1980s. Last season the Panthers lost to North Carolina, Miami and Stanford even though they were better than all three.

It doesn’t sound like that big of a deal, but those three games were the difference between Pitt being 10-4 as opposed to 7-7. That is a huge difference and even though all that would be reflected would be wins over bad teams, had the Panthers won 10 games in 2018 nobody would feel uneasy about what this season will bring.

As it is, there is some uncertainty and Narduzzi needs to show that he has indeed recruited well and raised the profile of the program. The Panthers have a little easier schedule next season and that should help, at least with respect to the overall record.

Advertise with us

The Panthers’ offense was a big problem in 2018, but Narduzzi hired Mark Whipple as his offensive coordinator. Whipple specializes in quarterback whispering and that’s exactly what the Panthers — and Kenny Pickett — need more than anything.

Narduzzi isn’t on the hot seat, nor should he be because he has done a good job so far. It is a bottom-line business, though, and nobody has a lifetime contract. This has to be the year his program truly arrives,or there will be some tough questions both he and athletic director Heather Lyke will have to answer about the direction of the program.