Zion Williamson shouldn’t have had to go to Duke in the first place. He shouldn’t have had to play this game of charades that basketball players are forced into because of an archaic and flat out un-American age limit rule in the NBA.
Now Williamson is injured and it has two sets of people against each other. There are what I’d call the self-appointed “guardians of the game” who still romanticize about college athletics, amateurism and the idea of student athletes This group is led by college administrators, coaches and many media members who cover college athletics.
This group swears that Williamson will benefit greatly by staying around Duke, playing with his teammates and trying to win a national championship. They swear he shouldn’t worry about getting injured because he’d still be the first pick in the NBA draft even if he does.
That group lives in a fantasy world. The second group is where I sit, the group that believes the NBA needs to change its age-limit rule and Williamson shouldn’t play another game for Duke.
What more does Williamson have to prove? What more does he have to do? His marketing and endorsement value is extremely high already and isn’t likely to get any better even if he hangs around. He will be the first pick of the NBA draft and sign a contract worth about $9 million per year. There is nothing left for him to prove and a lot for him to lose.
John Calipari, the king of one-and-dones, often says that when he talks to players at the end of the season about whether they should go to the draft or come back to school, he makes it real easy for them if they are a sure first-round pick. He tells them, “If you come back it is the best thing for me and my family, but if you leave, it is the best thing for you and your family.”
Read More
That’s the approach Williamson needs to take. He got injured on Wednesday night against North Carolina and this idea that he should leave school immediately was floated on social media by a number of people. It was then met with a whole lot of push back.
The argument for him to stay is he went to Duke to play in the Final Four and win a national title with his teammates. The argument is that basketball isn’t like football, injuries are different and players don’t suffer career-ending injuries in general.
That’s not the point, nor is the severity of Williamson’s injury. The point is the only person who benefits from Williamson staying in school is Mike Krzyzewski and the alumni and fans of Duke. Williamson is a mercenary and he, like all the one-and-done players, has no attachment to Duke other than it is the place he chose to spend his one year as a so-called student athlete.
The argument that “he is getting a free education” doesn’t fly with one-and-done players because they aren’t in school for the education. They are in school because they are made to be there by a system that is just unfair. And while we are at it, please spare me the “Europe is always an option” stuff because that’s ridiculous. An 18-year old kid who is capable of playing in the NBA should not have to go to some foreign country for one year to play professionally.
I do agree that student-athletes should not get paid because there is absolutely a lot of truth to the fact that those who are in school to be in school do benefit greatly from the free education. My son Elijah will graduate in May with two bachelor’s degrees and several internships under his belt and that wouldn’t have been nearly as easy if it weren’t for football. It isn’t feasible to pay student-athletes for a variety of reasons but that isn’t the point, either.
The Zion Williamsons of the world should be getting paid — by the Hawks, Nuggets, Celtics or whoever else is lucky enough to draft them. And they shouldn’t have to wait until they satisfy some arbitrary age requirement in order to get paid. I’d say the same thing for football, by the way. Why does Trevor Lawrence have to wait two more years to cash in when he would clearly be the first pick in this year’s NFL draft?
I have no problem, by the way, if Williamson wants to continue to play the season. But if he decides to play it safe and start working out for the NBA, then he should be praised, not criticized for it. He isn’t at Duke because he needs to be in order to get to the NBA; he is at Duke because the NBA told him that he has to go somewhere for a year before he’s eligible for the draft.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.