Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com. Let’s get started:
Ron Matthews, Pittsburgh: Who was/is more overrated; Jaime Dixon is his last seven seasons at Pitt, or Mike Tomlin in his last eight seasons with the Steelers?
Zeise: I love this question. They are similar in their careers in that they both had a ton of success early and then had a hard time maintaining it. Dixon’s first six seasons at Pitt were spectacular, and frankly he was on his way to a Hall of Fame career. He got to the Sweet 16 three times, the Elite Eight once and won a Big East tournament title in those first six seasons. He would never come close to that again, and his last five or six seasons at Pitt fell to just above average, which is why a change was made. Tomlin got to two Super Bowls in his first four seasons and won a total of five playoff games. He has been to one AFC championship since then, has won only three playoff games and has missed the playoffs three times. Both, however, had enough success after their fast starts to keep a segment of the fan base and media firmly in their corner. I think the answer has to be Tomlin. Dixon fell off from what he did at the start of his time, but take a look at Pitt’s history and what he did his last seven years is still impressive. He went to five NCAA tournaments in seven seasons, which is something Pitt had only done once before Ben Howland and Dixon arrived. The Steelers have had much better periods than the past eight years, and they have done it without having a Hall of Fame quarterback in place.
Rob Gateway, Export: Do you think Jeremy Fowler's report actually makes Mike Tomlin look worse than Antonio Brown?
Zeise: I think it makes Tomlin look bad. Real bad, actually. But let’s not lose our minds here — Antonio Brown has made his own bed and needs to lie in it. He is responsible for his own problems. Tomlin clearly enabled Brown, but Brown clearly took advantage of that and ran all over him. Brown deserves all the criticism he has gotten. Your larger point is correct, though. It makes me wonder if he will be able to get the situation under control.

Gerald Delon, Pittsburgh: Assuming that the Pirates perform as expected at around .500, what is your over/under figure on expected attendance drop from last year? Fan anger/apathy (including mine) seems to be running at an all-time high.
Read More
Zeise: The Pirates need to understand that their fan base is not happy. The front office also needs to understand that there is a very different dynamic now with fans than there was, say, eight or nine years ago. Back then, there was genuine anger, people were passionate and at least they cared. Now, there seems to be apathy setting in. Fans are tired of a front office that always seemingly puts the bottom line ahead of trying to field the best team possible. Last season the average attendance was 18,786, the lowest at PNC Park history and the first time the Pirates failed to get to 1.5 million fans in park history. The record for PNC Park attendance was set in 2015 at 30,847 per game (2.5 million total). That’s a huge drop in just three seasons. The Pirates need to get off to a fast start to avoid another disaster at the gate. If they don’t, I could easily see the average attendance dropping to somewhere in the neighborhood of 16,000 per game. That would be the worst case, though, as there is a crowd who will always attend games regardless of the product for a variety of reasons.
Dac, @Dac00272734: Does Neal Huntington really believe what he says and that unicorns are real?
Zeise: No, I don’t think he believes everything he says. I think he comes from the Bill Clinton school of creating a narrative, though, and that is if he says something enough as if it is fact, it becomes fact even if it isn’t. He has talking points he likes to hit and he continues to hit them. He is very smart and understands the market and how people feel about the ownership and the team in general. He is also at times taking the hits to protect his boss. I do believe Huntington is a good guy who is just not always so good at public relations.
Bob Washington, Pittsburgh: Why does Pitt seem to struggle closing with the big recruits? Even when Pitt was really rolling under Dixon, few four- or five-star recruits signed. Pitt has a decent basketball rep, urban school, reasonably close to NYC, Philly, D.C. So far, Capel has missed out on some coveted recruits this signing period. (I'm not making any judgments with Capel at all, just saying...) What is it going to take for Pitt to finally score some elite players?
Zeise: Would it be too cynical of me to say — well in light of the adidas investigation, the Panthers problem has been their bag men!! There aren’t that many four- or five-star recruits out there, and the ones out there almost always go to the top tier teams. It is about getting to the NBA, and those teams have a track record of producing NBA players. Pitt has gotten a few of those big-time players — Khem Birch, Chris Taft, Dante Taylor, Steven Adams, etc., so it isn’t like they never get them. Jeff Capel is in the door with some of those guys, but he will need to continue to win and build a program to be able to start closing the deal with them.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise
Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.