Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, former Alcorn State star Larry Smith (aka “Mr. Mean”) and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Lou Falsetta, @LouFalsetta: In the past you have been a Tomlin supporter/backer despite all the evidence in front of us. What specifically made you somewhat change?
Starkey: I “somewhat changed” — at least to the point where I’m dead against a Tomlin extension this offseason — for a number of reasons, Mr. Falsetta …
1. The Jacksonville playoff debacle.
2. The worst late-season collapse in recent Steelers history.
3. The Oakland debacle.
Read More
4. The AB saga.
Until Jacksonville, I defended Tomlin on a very simple premise: He won a lot. At that point, he’d just been to an AFC championship (even if it did end with Tom Brady shredding his passive defense in a non-competitive game) and a 13-3 regular season.
Then came Jacksonville, and even though the Steelers desperately missed Ryan Shazier, the defensive effort that day could only be described as an alarmingly historic embarrassment. Totally inexcusable. If I recall correctly, Jacksonville’s only negative-yardage play was a kneel-down at the end. Tomlin, having taken a larger hand in the defense by that point (and always having significant influence in accumulating defensive personnel) was hugely complicit.
Then came this season’s collapse, exemplified by the ridiculous loss in Oakland, when Tomlin arrogantly decided he would try to escape town without using Ben Roethlisberger — until he had no choice. That’s a season-wrecker right there. Not to mention another hideous road loss to a terrible team on Tomlin’s resume.
Then came the latest scenes from the A.B. saga — and man, did Jeremy Fowler’s ESPN piece make Tomlin look bad. The Great Enabler. It’s not that we didn’t know as much, but it sure drove the point home when you read about Brown’s Airbnb — “AirAB” — rental home at training camp and him getting dropped off for Latrobe practices in luxury cars.
Also this nugget: “Several say Brown routinely showed up late to team meetings that set up the upcoming game week. If he was loosely on time, he might be the last one to walk through the door. One player went as far to say he didn't see Brown once in the Wednesday morning meetings during his one season with the team.”
It’s one thing for a coach to overlook a star player’s tardiness to a meeting now and again. It’s quite another to wholly abrogate one’s responsibility as a leader of men and let one guy do whatever he wants all the time.
That philosophy starts at the top, by the way. As Fowler reported, “One recent teammate said he never heard Tomlin call out (Ben) Roethlisberger in a meeting over his multiple years with the Steelers.”
Compare that to this line from Gary Myers’ 2015 story on the Bill Belichick-Tom Brady relationship:
“(Belichick) knows he can yell at (Brady) and Brady can take it. The greater message is being delivered to the team: If the coach can yell at the four-time Super Bowl winner, you’d better watch your ass. You’re next.”
Thank you, Mr. Falsetta. And please say hello to Mr. Soprano.
Christopher Matich, @PghMatich: Do you think Jameson Taillon leaves the Pirates after his arbitration years are up?
Starkey: If he’s not traded before then, Mr. Matich, should he become too expensive in arbitration. The Pirates’ dilemma is this: It would be ideal to see one more big year from Taillon before offering him a multi-year contract, but one more big year might propel him right out of their price bracket — which, the way things are going, is about $4.75 per hour.
Taillon is under team control through 2022 and becomes arbitration eligible in 2020. If I’m the Pirates, I’m looking, right now, to get him signed at least through his arbitration years and hopefully beyond. I’d be willing to take that chance, but it takes two to tango. If I’m Taillon, I’m not taking any discounts. He could be looking at silly money in a few years.
In the meantime, feast your eyes on this:
Jameson Taillon, 2018 Highlights. pic.twitter.com/9gG1VyNWpk
— Rob Friedman (@PitchingNinja) January 28, 2019
Nicolas DeFrancesco, @your_agent_nic: Do you like the “Pens are rusty due to the break” excuse? It reminds me of the Steelers early in the season, sloppy, not cohesive.
Starkey: Yes, I do like that excuse, Mr. @your_agent_nic (could I just call you Nic?). The NHL scheduling any game that soon after the All-Star break is asinine. I expected it would be a horrible game, and possibly another loss to the Devils, and I was not wrong. Let’s see what happens Wednesday against the best team in the NHL. That will be interesting.
Josh Oswald, @gentelmenRich: Did you actually ever have those apple tartlets from the Omaha steaks promo ad?
Starkey: Yes, lightly heated in the microwave with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
@wolftrainer09, @wolftrainer09: What do you think about letting woman hockey players play in the NHL All-Star Game? I think it would add much needed intrigue to the weekend festivities. Give the women a national platform to show off their skills.
Starkey: LOVE the idea. Best one suggested in this venue is quite some time. Watching Kendall Coyne Schofield speed around the ice the other day was special, particularly as the father of a 10-year-old girl.
Samuel Fleming, @nashman92: So, any particular reason why the Penguins are adopting the Steelers strategy of not playing well vs. last place teams this year?
Starkey: None that I can think of, Mr. Fleming — but here’s the thing: The Penguins (1-7-1 against last-place teams) can afford to rise and fall relative to the competition because it’s an 82-game season, whereas the Steelers cannot. The Steelers could sabotage their season with one crap out against a terrible opponent. And they did (Oakland).
Plus, the Penguins have won the biggest of big games in their recent past, so they’ve earned a mulligan. The Steelers have three playoff wins in the past eight years. One against Matt Moore. One against Alex Smith. And one a gift from Pac Man, Jeremy Hill and Vontaze Burfict (thank you, Peezy).
Brettskie, @Cutch_22: If you could go back and tweak the outcome of one Steelers play in the last 10 years, which one would you change and why?
Starkey: Mendenhall fumble. Steelers had momentum, and I fully believe would have taken the lead and won the game.
OK, let's move on. It is with great excitement that I present our new “Yes & No” feature …
David Hammer, @DavidHa64889770: Is Malkin a trade piece?
Starkey: No.
Mark Kozlowski, @markkozlowski2: Would Antonio work out a better trade for himself than Colbert?
Starkey: Yes (and might draft better cornerbacks, too).
Mike McKain, @Midnight667: Do you think MLB will ever have a hard salary cap? This stupid "luxury tax" is a joke…
Starkey: No.
Nathan, @bigknuterockne: Is Pittsburgh a prime destination for NFL free agents?
Starkey: Yes (if the money’s right).
Christopher Matich, @PghMatich: Will Lonnie Chisenhall have a 3+ war season?
Starkey: No.
Tom Mosser Design, @tommosser: The first time that I heard you was on a Sat. morning during around the 6th game of the Cup Finals (editor’s note: 2008) against the Red Wings. You said that you didn't have a rooting interest but you were emotionally exhausted. You described the Wings as being the Red Army. So great. Do you recall?
Starkey: No.
Jimmy No-knows (bot), @jimmy_no_knows: How did u not notice @KDPomp was talking to someone when you thought he big leagued u last week @ the pitt/Duke game... trying to besmirch pomp??
Starkey: Yes.
Thank you, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.