The Pirates held their annual PiratesFest Saturday at PNC Park, but that name implies it is some sort of celebration. Maybe it once was, but it has become a depressing event where Bob Nutting, through spin masters Neal Huntington and Frank Coonelly, explains to the fans why the Pirates did very little to improve themselves in the offseason.
PiratesFest might produce a few smiles among kids, but it always produces two other things:
1. Some sort of obnoxious righteous indignation by Huntington and/or Coonelly in response to any question suggesting they are not trying to win. Last year, Coonelly claimed he was insulted by the idea they aren’t trying to win. Saturday it was Huntington’s turn and he said he “will work to not be offended by people who say we do not want to win because the only reason we are here is to win a World Series.”
And I would tell both of them to stop insulting us.Teams that try to win don’t go back-to-back offseasons without adding any major pieces. Teams that are trying to win don’t trade a very competent fifth starter like Ivan Nova simply because he makes too much money. Teams that are trying to win don’t hope their infield magically improves even though at least three of the four positions will be manned by an inferior fielder. I could go on, but you get the point.
2. It also produces the annual spin about how spending money on payroll doesn’t lead to success and how the Pirates have budget constraints but will spend more when the time is right. This will then be qualified with some arbitrary and nonsensical number of wins from an arbitrary point in time that definitely shows they are having success.
Huntington last week gave us the nonsense about how the Pirates have the ninth-most wins in MLB over the past six seasons. I am just wondering where the “Top 10 in wins over the last six seasons” trophy is kept at PNC Park and whether fans will get to see it and touch it this summer. Huntington then doubled down with some long-winded ridiculous stuff about how you have to overpay to sign free agents and that is never a good business model. Then Coonelly gave his two cents (which is an apt phrase given that the Pirates budget isn’t much more than that this year) that the Pirates’ 25-man roster is full of young, cheap, prearbitration players and “that same roster will be more expensive the following year as the [eight] players become arbitration-eligible." He said the payroll will have room to grow because next year they will all get raises — of course, he forgot to mention they will take about $20 million off the payroll when Francisco Cervelli, Corey Dickerson and several other veterans will be allowed to walk in free agency.
Read More
These two things have been annual talking points at PiratesFest and despite the fact that they always blow up in Huntington and Coonelly’s face, they continue to go down this route. They continue to take bullets for Bob Nutting and they continue to treat us all as if we are stupid and can’t possibly understand baseball’s economics.
I’ll spare the details for those no longer interested — and judging by last year’s attendance, that is a fairly large and growing group — but the bottom line is the Pirates have a payroll of about $68 million to $70 million right now. The Brewers and Reds, two teams in similar markets with similar revenue streams, both have payrolls of about $114 million to $116 million. The Brewers added an $18 million catcher to a team that won 96 games and the division last year and the Reds were one of the most active teams in baseball.
If the Pirates want to tell us that they can’t keep up with the Yankees, Cubs or Red Sox in the payroll department, we will listen. Don’t, however, insult our intelligence by telling us that you can’t keep up with the Brewers and Reds.
Thankfully, Jameson Taillon, the Pirates union representative, provided some sort of sanity when he discussed the fact that teams like the Pirates are making it very difficult for free agents to get the money they have earned.
“The game is built on free agency, and if these guys aren’t getting rewarded, something has to change,” Taillon said. “No one is going to sympathize with baseball players making millions of dollars, but the owners are making money, too, and they’re making way more than we are.”
Taillon was diplomatic about his own employer and tried hard to toe the company line about younger, cheaper players holding the payroll down, but it is clear he isn’t buying it either. Nor should he because it won’t be long before Taillon will either be asked to take one of these team-friendly deals to buy out his arbitration years or be traded and replaced by someone due to make a lot less than he will.
I do hand it to Nutting, though, as he is clearly a brilliant businessman and has an incredible knack for finding people like Huntington and Coonelly who are willing to say silly things and fall on their sword in order to protect his company line. Nutting (who was a no-show again, and perhaps that is appropriate given that the Pirates have been a no-show this offseason) has found a business that guarantees him boatloads of profits regardless of how much he invests in it and what product he puts out for consumers to buy.
He — along with Huntington and Coonelly — is delusional, though, if he thinks that people are still dumb enough to buy the company line about the Pirates’ payroll and lack of spending. They need to come up with some different talking points for next year’s PiratesFest because the current ones have grown stale and are just not working any more.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.