Every Steelers season since 2010 — with the exception of 2016 — has ended somewhere short of where their “talent” would seem to dictate it should have ended. In the wake of the Steelers’ 31-28 loss to the Saints on Sunday, this season seems destined to fall way short of expectations.
The Steelers now need a miracle to make the playoffs.
OK, not quite a miracle, but pretty close to one. They need to first beat Jeff Driskel and the Bengals, and if they can’t do that, then they need to tear things down and start over. They also need either a Browns road win over a team with a winning record or a tie between the Titans and Colts to have a chance. The Browns haven’t won on the road against a team with a winning record in at least three years, and it is unlikely a game between two teams who are both in “win or go home” mode will end up in a tie.
Stop right here and think about how silly this is. The Steelers, who have a Hall of Fame quarterback, a Hall of Fame wide receiver, six players who were selected for the Pro Bowl and a host of others who could have been, need help from the Browns or two other teams to tie just to make the playoffs.
Many fans were angry the Steelers didn’t have more players make the Pro Bowl, “snubs” such as JuJu Smith-Schuster and T.J Watt.
Here is something that maybe it is time to consider: We have greatly overrated the Steelers’ talent. It has to be that, or this team is annually poorly coached. Or maybe this team doesn’t work hard enough and doesn’t pay enough attention to detail to win at the level at which they are supposed to win.
Read More
One of those three things has to be true, and after watching this season, I’m beginning to think it is a combination of all three.
Ed Bouchette and Gerry Dulac break the Steelers' loss to the Saints
The Steelers’ talent has been overrated for years, especially on defense. They don’t have a playmaker on defense and haven’t since Troy Polamalu retired. They don’t have a cornerback other than Joe Haden who would start for just about any other team. It’s basically a defense devoid of the kind of game-changing talent that most great defenses have.
In terms of coaching, I believe Mike Tomlin is an excellent coach. The Steelers play hard for him, he gets them motivated and is the best fit for this team. He should be the Steelers’ coach for as long as he wants.
There is one caveat to that, though: He needs help on game day. His in-game coaching is not always where it needs to be. The Steelers’ game-planning is always sound, but it’s making those critical decisions on fourth down, clock management, how to use timeouts and challenging plays where Tomlin struggles.
It is incomprehensible how, in 2018, an NFL coach doesn’t have a quality control/analytics guy on the sideline to help him think things through in a rational and non-emotional way based on percentages and statistical analysis. It is also incomprehensible that a coach doesn’t have some sort of replay guru watching plays and telling him which ones to challenge and which ones aren’t likely to stand. The Penguins and Pirates both have one of those people on staff; the Steelers should, too.
Those little details in games are often the difference between winning and losing. The Steelers often are more talented, at least offensively, than the teams they play and can overcome those things most of the time. It is hard to overcome those things, though, week after week.
It isn’t just Tomlin, though; the “talented” players need to pay more attention to detail as well. They turn the ball over at the worst times. They fail to convert third downs at the worst times. They miss tackles at the worst times. It is a trend that really seems to hold this team back.
As Bill Parcells said, “You are what your record says you are,” and the Steelers’ record is three unimpressive playoff wins since 2010.
That’s not the mark of underachievers; it’s the mark of a team that has been grossly overrated.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.