Ray Fittipaldo: Merry Christmas everyone. Let's get the chat started. Post your questions...

Utah Jim: It feels like every decision Tomlin made this season was wrong. Is this year his worse performance yet?

Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin certainly hasn't had his best season. We can debate the fake punt all we want. I would have punted and forced the Saints to drive the length of the field. I thought the defense was playing well at that point int he game. But there have been so many decisions that have cost him. How about putting Ridley in the game on third-and-2? How about the decision to keep Ben out of the game in Oakland? I could go on and on...

Brad: Do the Ravens lose to the Browns? Best guess?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: No. It's in Baltimore. The Ravens have the NFL's No.1 defense and they're playing a rookie QB. It would be a monumental collapse if they lost to the Browns.

Smike: What's the biggest reason for steelers collapse in so many games this year, and also what do you think needs to be done to fix issues? Thanks

Ray Fittipaldo: I just think they have to be on their details more. They need to be better in turnover differential, both protecting the ball better and creating turnovers. They need better personnel in the secondary. Better coaching on defense. And I'm not pointing fingers at any of the defensive coaches, I just mean overall. You can't give up a 25-yard gain on third-and-20. The guy was wide open. Who's fault is that. It was obviously a blown coverage. So why aren't they being coached better in those situations. I'd be here forever today if I listed everything. It's a lot of things.

RI Steeler: If the defense didnt have a history of giving up long drives at the end of the game then I would agree with the fake punt. Your thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: But the defense was playing well at that point, no? I mean, you can argue the officials gifted the Saints 14 points in the game. The first pass interference on Joe Haden gave them their first touchdown. The second one kept a drive alive late in the red zone. So if I'm the coach I take all of that into consideration when I go for the fake. Also, the look can be there for the fake, but the execution has to be perfect by the blockers. It's not enough for the look to simply be there. It didn't look like it was blocked well enough. Or the Saints snuffed it out.

Advertise with us

Ike Steelheart: Ray, be honest. Let's say The Browns win. Are The Steelers capable of win a SB this year? It would not be better to pick in the late 20s the following draft and at least have a shot to real talent in round 1, 2 and 3? If they don't win a SB they will be again picking at 26,27,28!

Ray Fittipaldo: I kind of have a similar feeling about this year as I did in 2015, when they needed help to get in the playoffs on the final weekend. They got in, won a game and should have beaten Denver in Denver. They could have won the SUper Bowl that year. I feel the same way this year even though they are unlikely to make it in the tournament. They're good enough to win it all. The Saints didn't impress me. And they're the best team in the NFC? They're very beatable. There is no great team in the league. All of that being said, the Steelers are in this position because they lost to a bad Oakland team, a bad Broncos team and tied the Browns in the opener. If they take care of business in any of those games they're not in this position.

kevin in Punxsy: Hi Ray. Will the Steelers management, at least force HCMT to fire and replace some assistants, and will he be required to hire someone to call coaches challenges?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not sure, but it feels like they have to do something on defense, doesn't it. It's just more of the same -- blown coverages, giving up big gains on third-and-20. It's the same stuff that continues to plague this team. O while I don't know if Art Rooney II will demand changes it feels like something will happen.

Jay7: Steelers season is over because of ONE - OAKLAND! I have been seeing articles over past few years in which we see that these meltdowns will someday cost the season. Well that season has arrived

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't disagree with you. If I had to boil this down to one thing it's the Oakland game. There were so many thing in that game that mystified me. The decision not to bring Roethlisberger back earlier still doesn't make any sense to me. Their inability to run the ball against the NFL's worst run defense is inexcusable. The offensive line played so poorly in that game. Ramon Foster also allowed penetration on the sack that injured Roethlisberger. That's why he had to miss four series. Foster got beat to the inside. It's the No. 1 rule in pass protection and Foster couldn't do his job.

Han Solo: I really didn't find a problem with the fake. If anything it leaves your offense, or strongest part of your team, plenty of time to March down and win it. What say you?

Ray Fittipaldo: I would have punted it.

Retire 21: How do judge Ben’s year? He leads the NFL in passing yards, has his most TDa ever and will 5,000 yards next week. But the TOs! BTW, I think Ben is at an even 500 sacks now, behind only Elway and Favre, remarkably similar QBs.

Ray Fittipaldo: Ben was excellent yesterday. I think that's why it's frustrating for fans. He craved up one of the NFL's best defense. Throw for 380 with three TDs and no INTs. Why doesn't he play like that every week though? Why is he careless with the ball in so many other games? They'd be a five-win team without him, maybe worse. He's not the reason they're in this predicament. But his inconsistencies do hurt this team. He most certainly contributed to them being in this position.

Advertise with us

Guest: Hey Ray! Given the team's likely playoff absence, how likely are we to see a defensive staff overhaul? Butler, Porter, Olsavsky, Bradley all gone?

Ray Fittipaldo: If I had to guess, I think there will be changes. I don't know about wholesale changes, but I think there will be changes.

Jerry: Steelers always gets beat in the turnover battle. I think it's the old Lebeau scheme that doesn't work anymore. Next year they need to change the scheme. Your thoughts

Ray Fittipaldo: They need to do something to create more turnovers. And it's not just the dropped INTs. There weren't that many dropped INTs. Butler has referenced that. They need to be in position to make more INTs. They're not close enough to receivers. They're not good at breaking on balls. They're not good at making plays on tipped passes. Just look at the Mike Hilton play yesterday. If he goes up in the air and catches the ball at its highest point he makes that INT. Instead, Brees comes in and breaks it up. It's about awareness. It's about having some football savvy. They need more players with savvy. And they might need a different approach with the way they coach.

Mike: Score prediction for Browns-Ravens? Do you think Jackson will fold under pressure probably the biggest game of his life ?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Ravens 24, Browns 10.

Jay7: Why did Tomlin fake punted it. He could have had better odds with the offense and 5 yards. Agree with Tomlin logic, but bad play call which gets coaches fired

Ray Fittipaldo: Nothing typifies the Steelers special teams more than Rosie Nix getting up and celebrating after he came up a yard short. I mean nothing.

Han Solo: Ok so the season is probably over now we can start talking draft? What is the Steelers #1 need heading into the draft?

Ray Fittipaldo: CB. They need to extend Joe Haden, but they also have to get their next No. 1 CB. Draft someone and let him learn from Joe. If you have to move up to get the player you want, do it. Just can't sit back again this year. And don't be afraid about drafting someone from a smaller school. They had a chance to get Darius Leonard, but they took Terrell Edmunds instead. Edmunds might turn out to be a good player, but Leonard might be the defensive rookie of the year. And he plays ILB, their biggest need last year. So what if he went to South Carolina State? Trust your scouts. And if your scouts didn't believe in him then ask them tough questions this winter about why. He could have made a big difference with this defense.

Advertise with us

Ike Steelheart: Ray, How many years of good and competitive football do you think Ben still has? How short is the window for another SB?

Ray Fittipaldo: Two or three years maybe longer. Brees is still playing well and he's approaching 40. Ben will turn 37 in March. They're wasting some of his best years, but it's not like the window is closing right now. In a few years, yes. But not right now.

Utah Jim: Should Tomlin had challenged the Thomas incomplete call that Burnett recovered? Sure looked like a fumble.

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes I thought he should have. He should have someone in the booth to help him. Art Rooney II should demand it.

Rod in Indy: Merry Christmas Ray! Pick one reason for Steelers results this year:

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Just one? OK lack of focus for the Oakland game.

Alan: Steelers biggest needs this upcoming offseason?

Ray Fittipaldo: Secondary. Have to upgrade there.

Brandon: I know the refs weren't the only reason the Steelers lost, but are there any repercussions for poor calls that cost points (Saints twice, Chargers, once)?

Ray Fittipaldo: I never heard of anyone being reprimanded for the Chargers game. I suppose they could reprimand the official who made the pass interference calls. But what good does it do to complain about the officiating. The owners should have demanded a change in leadership last year. They decided to keep Alberto Riveron in charge. As long as he is in charge there are going to be on-field problems with the officials and there are going to be questions about his reviews. I'm not suggesting he is corrupt. But he seems inept. Why do you think guys like Dean Blandino, Gene Steratore and Mike Perreira go work for TV? They go for the money. They make much more money working for networks. Digest that for a moment. The NFL is a multi-billion dollar industry and they lose their best people to TV because they're unwilling to invest in their officiating.

Advertise with us

Han Solo: What a weak season to not make the playoff. Is Baltimore the most dangerous AFC team? Who makes the superbowl from the AFC?

Ray Fittipaldo: Anyone can make it from the AFC. But I'll take the Patriots as long as Brady can get healthy. I heard he's dealing with an MCL. He'd carve up that Saints secondary.

me: If they punted, what would the odds have been that the Saints would have went 80 yards, used ALL the clock and scored a TD. Given the refs in that game, about 100%

That is why I was not against the try. Hoping that if the defense could not hold them the Saints would score quickly and the Steelers could have time to score again.

Almost worked. Any chance Tomlin was thinking that way?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Almost worked? He ran into a Saints defender three yards short of the line of gain and then came up a full yard short. You can tell me you're OK with the call, but don't tell me it almost worked. It really wasn't that close.

Tampa Too: Ray, Thanks for the Christmas eve chat. Do you think that the elite Qb's in the league such as Brady, Brees, Rogers and to a lesser extent Big Ben get more pass interference calls because the refs subconsciously believe that their passes should always be caught and if they are not the refs just think it must have been interference?

Ray Fittipaldo: Ben certainly didn't get one in the end zone when Vance McDonald was mugged. And that came after the phantom call on Haden early in the game. Guys like Brees throw up their hands in disgust every time there is a close play. Of course, they try to get calls. I think it works too. Maybe Ben should do more of that.

Larry in KY: The officiating is becoming bigger than the game. I was very impressed by the way our team responded to the challenge yesterday, but my biggest takeaway is the bonehead pass interference call. Worse yet, we will never hear of any action taken against the officials. The NFL product is tainted.

Ray Fittipaldo: Again, I'm not suggesting Riveron is corrupt as some are insinuating on Twitter. But he's not very good at his job. They should have replaced him last year. For whatever reason some owners were overruled because it was supposed to happen. They have to make a change there. They need new leadership.

Advertise with us

ShawnE: When will the front office finally have enough of Tomlin? I know his record is among the best in the league but it should be with the talent we have. We continue to under achieve under his leadership.

Ray Fittipaldo: I agree. Tomlin has been more involved with the defense and we're seeing the same stuff happen. He's involved deeply in draft process and the Steelers continually select defensive players that fail to live up to expectations. It's not all on Tomlin, but he certainly deserves a big portion of the blame.

Utah Jim: Maybe I'm just a homer, but has every bad call starting with Jessie James last year gone against the Steelers?

Ray Fittipaldo: There have been a lot of bad calls. Go back to the missed muffed punt in the Cleveland game to open the season. It was 21-7 and in the fourth quarter. The Steelers would have easily won that game if the correct call was made on the field or in a review by Riveron. I never thought I'd see another game as poorly officiated as the Chargers game, but then the officials one-upped themselves in New Orleans. And Riveron was there to muck it up more by not stopping the game to review the tipped pass on the supposed pass interference.

Guest: A lot of talk about the team's lack of homegrown defensive talent, but how feasible is it to expect them to hit on its early draft picks when they're always drafting so late each year (ie. do they need to be more aggressive in free agency ala NE)?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: They could have taken Darius Leonard in the first round. He went a few picks later at the top of the second round. He looks like he's going to be a franchise type of defender. I see your point. But let's not act like other teams aren't drafting better defensive talent. It's an obvious issue.

SP: When will Mr Rooney wake up and realize mediocre Mike Tomlin is wasting Ben’s prime years. This will be his biggest regret like his Dad passing on Marino.

Ray Fittipaldo: I sense change coming, but not with the head coach.

SteelHeart: Hi Ray, For me, it isn't so much that they put Ridley into the game, but that he was running with the ball hanging out ! Shouldn't they have reminded Ridley of that before sending him in. AND, don't they make him practice properly ? Thanks

Ray Fittipaldo: Ridley has had a fumbling problem for years. That's what makes that decision inexcusable. Tomlin has these pet projects like Ridley. He was on the street last December before the Steelers signed him. And yet they brought him back and he ends up costing them the game and perhaps the playoffs. Enough of these pet projects.

Advertise with us

Fan: What will it take for the officiating to be held accountable for the big play mistakes it makes week to week? It seems to be getting worse, not better. Does the NFL not care that it damages their brand?

Ray Fittipaldo: The NFL should have taken action last year. They all but admitted Riveron had erred when they changed the catch rule for the playoffs. Yet they kept him.

Chris from MD: Hi Ray. Merry Christmas and thanks for the chat! While the Steelers have plenty of their own issues, the officiating across the league needs to be fixed. What can actually be done? Do the coaches have any input (e.g. through the competition committee), or is it entirely up to Goodell?

Ray Fittipaldo: It's up to the owners. They tell Goodell what to do. Apparently some owners didn't want a change after what happened last year.

Scott: When is the NFL going to change the pass interference penalty to 15 yards instead of spot foul. Those calls are game changers.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Or they can just hire competent officials. They don't have enough competent officials. It's a problem at every level of football.

Ed Bouchette and Gerry Dulac break the Steelers' loss to the Saints

Zeke5123: 3rd and 2 and 4th and 5.... You don’t think Roethlisberger converts those? Nix and the 4thnstring fumbling bum rob git the ball, not Ben. This proves Tomlin needs fired.

Ray Fittipaldo: They won't fire Tomlin. Not unless he refuses to make changes if ownership dictates. And I don't see that happening.

Tony E.: Face it, the Steelers aren't good this year. They started 1-2-1, are 1 - 4 their last five games--and that five game win streak? Four of those wins were against sub-500 teams and the only one good win was against Baltimore.

Ray Fittipaldo: They're good enough to win the Super Bowl. They're also bad enough to lose to Oakland. It's that lack of focus that Tomlin has to fix. Good teams don't lose to Oakland. I don't care where the game is played. I don't care about where the x-ray machine is located and how the results were unreadable. They weren't ready to play that game. It's inexcusable.

Advertise with us

Manny: Ray, yesterdays and chargers gameobvious awful officiating gent our way throw in there some costly mistakes on our part, however the season was lost in Denver and Oakland, every season we have a couple of those that get us No good seeding and obvious no trophy or out of playoffs with so much talent.. Are we good or not? Who to blame? It's Painful really! What say U ? Greetings from Mexico..

Ray Fittipaldo: The buck has to stop with the head coach. He's in charge.

Utah Jim: Usually when the refs are having a bad day it goes both ways. Not yesterday. Have you ever seen such a poorly, and one sided, called game?

Ray Fittipaldo: The Chargers game from a few weeks ago?

Derek: Do you think that there will be defensive coaching changes, Joey Porter, Keith Butler or both since it appears we won't be in the post season ? What are you thoughts on us finally drafting a defensive playmaker since we will be picking earlier in the 2019 draft ?

Ray Fittipaldo: Gotta go get a corner that can be a difference maker. They need someone opposite Haden.

RPinney: Has the league ever considered reviewing penalties? If not, what’s the logic of that as compared with reviewing any other play?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know if it's ever been seriously discussed, but the subject has been broached recently because the officiating has been so suspect.

Rod in Indy: Are turnovers for/against (and timeliness of them!) biggest reason we miss playoffs, or the defense not getting crucial stops at end of games, or Boz struggling? I say turnovers for/against. Your opinion on this, please?

Ray Fittipaldo: All of the above.

Doug in Raleigh: Care to speculate on what happened to the Chargers? Did they leave their hearts in Kansas City, were they due for a letdown, or had they never faced any decent defense in the first 14 games of the season? They looked helpless.

Ray Fittipaldo: The Chargers were due for a loss. And maybe they're not that great.

orangesteel: Fire Mike Tomlin.. that is all.

Ray Fittipaldo: Won't happen.

Zach B: That Fake Punt call at our own 42 up 4 with 4 minutes to play was the dumbest coaching decision I have ever witnessed both as a sports fan and ex college athlete. That in my mind is a fireable offense. His decision making and lack of prep, in game management and total lack of discipline in the locker room - enough is enough - it’s time for a change in culture. Do you think this HC is capable of taking us to another SB? If so, why?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think the decision to keep Ben on the sidelines in Oakland was worse to be honest with you. But as I stated earlier I would have punted. I thought the defense was playing well enough.

kryder: honest opinion, do you think rooney rule would factor into steelers holding on to tomlin longer than they would actually like to? if mccarthy can get fired...why not tomlin.....

Ray Fittipaldo: The Rooney Rule has nothing to do with it. They hired him 12 years ago. Plenty of African-American head coaches have come and gone since then. They keep him because they believe he's a good coach.

Ryan: Why did the booth not review that 4th down PI call on Haden when the ball was tipped? Ive always understood thats a reviewable play

Ray Fittipaldo: It was reviewed. We reported that in our coverage last night. Al Riveron looked at it and determined the ball was not tipped. And he didn't stop the game to look at it longer. That, to me, is the biggest issue. I thought it was tipped. I've seen replays. You mean to tell me Drew Brees, who is often referred to as the purest passer in NFL history, is going to throw a tight spiral that suddenly turns into a duck after it leaves his hands? Come on now. Why have booth reviews?

Ryan: Do you think starting next season theyll make PI reviewable?

Ray Fittipaldo: You're going down a slippery slope there. I'd just rather hire better officials. Make them full-time. Train them. Make them work 40 hours a week. This is a multi-billion dollar industry. Why do we have insurance salesmen making season-changing calls. It's stupid.

Guest: As soon as I saw the 3rd and 2 formation, I knew it was a bad decision. I know there are nuances that a fan like me might not know about, but the Saints have been killing them in tight, north/south running plays all day.....I wonder what they are thinking?

Ray Fittipaldo: Can't use Ridley there. He has a history of fumbling.

JoeB: Next year, Ben, AB, and Haden are all one year older. There's a significant likelihood one of those 3 begins to drop off. That's why this year is so disappointing.

Ray Fittipaldo: Right. They're wasting talent.

Mikey: Does L Bell get transition tagged? And if not do u think we draft RB high?

Ray Fittipaldo: Why? You have Conner and Samuels. RB is way down their list this offseason.

Doug from Raleigh: Isn't it time for the NFL to break into their billion dollar piggy bank and hire full time refs? That bunch last night looked like a bad HS crew, and not just because of the Haden debacle.

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes they should. Something has to be done. Fire Riveron. Pay Mike Perreria or someone like him to come back and oversee the whole operation.

Jerry: NFL games are rigged! Your thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think the officials purposely rigs the game, but they have far too many who are inept.

me: Almost worked was not about the fake, it was about the Saints scoring with enough time to allow the Steelers to still score. But whatever...

Ray Fittipaldo: Gotcha.

Tom 88: Can anyone explain with this talent, and the talent Balt has how they are going to the playoffs and we're not? Could it be coaching?

Ray Fittipaldo: Ravens on their details more. Wining close games. Steelers finding ways to lose. Plus their defense is night and day better than the Steelers.

Steel stubborn : What's up with Bud Dupree? He seems like he has a ton of physical talent but he never makes plays. Always blocked. Does he get resigned?

Ray Fittipaldo: I wouldn't sign him to a big deal. I'd try to get him for $5 million or so a year. If he balks then pull the offer and don't pay him the $10 million he's on the books for 2019. He's not worth it.

AK: I thought the Saints receiver pushed off on the winning TD, your thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yeah it looked that way. That's why if you let that go you let the Haden one go too. Too many inconsistencies with the way the game is officiated.

Ray Fittipaldo: OK thanks for chatting today. Marry Christmas. We'll do another chat next week on New Year's Eve.