Quarterback: It was a big-time performance in the second half by Ben Roethlisberger, who completed 14 of 18 passes for 170 yards and two touchdowns to bring the Steelers back from a 24-14 deficit. He kept the Steelers’ hopes alive with a big fourth-and-15 completion on the final drive that ended in a fumble. He finished with 380 yards passing and three touchdowns and led three consecutive TD drives, beginning at the end of the first half.
Grade: A
Running backs: The Steelers ran only six times for 24 yards in the second half, but the most critical was the fumble by Stevan Ridley on third-and-2 at the Saints 34 with the Steelers trying to extend their four-point lead. Why Ridley was in game at that point is questionable because Jaylen Samuels had carried four times for 21 yards on that drive before the fumble. Samuels finished with 53 yards on 12 carries against the league’s No. 1 rush defense.
Grade: C-
Receivers: Big games by Antonio Brown (14 for 185) and JuJu Smith-Schuster (11 for 115) went for naught when Smith-Schuster fumbled after a 6-yard catch with 32 seconds remaining. Brown had nine catches for 122 yards in the second half that included a 20-yard TD for a 28-24 lead and a toe-dragging 19-yarder on fourth down to keep alive the final drive. Vance McDonald’s 49-yard catch-and-run set up the second FG.
Grade: A-
Read More
Offensive line: It was a strong performance by the line, even though Roethlisberger was sacked three times – most since Week 3 in Tampa – and the running game produced only 65 yards and averaged 3.6 yards per carry. Roethlisberger was sacked only once on 28 dropbacks in the second half and was given plenty of time to pick apart a defense that was fourth in the league in sacks.
Grade: B
Defensive line: The Steelers reached back to the old days and used a number of 4-3 alignments in an attempt to deal with RB Alvin Kamara. But it didn’t appear to have any impact on Drew Brees, who was sacked just twice – both on the same series in the third quarter. But the line did a good job holding Kamara and RB Mark Ingram to 58 yards on 18 carries – 61 yards fewer than the duo’s per game average.
Grade: B
Linebackers: Mike Tomlin used a lot of different looks against Brees, most involving getting his linebackers off the field. But that didn’t work when Kamara got loose for a 21-yard catch-and-run to set up a field goal at the end of the first half and a 43-yarder to set up a touchdown to start the third quarter. Those plays came after the Steelers had tied the score at 14-14 with 40 seconds left before halftime. Brees completed 7 of 8 passes for 100 yards in that stretch.
Grade: C
Secondary: A couple of debatable pass-interference calls against Joe Haden proved to be very costly and led to 14 points, including the winning TD. The most questionable occurred in the end zone on a pass to Kamara in the first quarter. The second came on fourth down on the winning TD drive. Brees finished with 326 yards passing, the most by an opposing QB since Week 4 (Joe Flacco). Sean Davis had a nice leaping interception in the end zone.
Grade: D
Special teams: It looked like it was going to a big day for the special teams when L.J. Fort blocked a 50-yard FG attempt with 6:13 remaining, preserving a four-point lead. That came after K Chris Boswell made his first two FG attempts, giving him three in a row for one of the few times this season. But an attempt to put the game away in the fourth quarter failed when Rose Nix was stopped a yard short on a fake punt on fourth-and-5.
Grade: C-
Coaching: Two decisions backfired on Tomlin – inserting the seldom-used Ridley on third-and-2 at the Saints 34 and Mike Tomlin’s gamble to keep the ball away from Brees on a fake punt with 4:06 remaining. But, no matter how well they played, it was their fourth loss in the past six games – all decided in the final seconds. It will likely knock them from the postseason. Two fumbles and two interference penalties were the difference.
Grade: C
Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com and Twitter @gerrydulac.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.