Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com. Let’s get started:

Wixie, @WixieEarlWilson: Is Mike Tomlin getting too stale like McCarthy in Green Bay?

Zeise: I think Mike McCarthy’s act wore thin with Aaron Rodgers, and that was the main reason that team fell apart. Rodgers thought McCarthy’s play-calling limited him and didn’t allow him to throw the ball down the field enough. Gee, where have we heard that one before? I don’t believe Mike Tomlin’s message is stale. I think the players still listen to him and respond to him. I just think the defense has gotten a little bit stale and the defensive personnel is not quite good enough. They need a difference maker on defense. Tomlin usually does a great job of rallying the team when their backs are against the wall, so let’s see if he can pull that off again.

Bruno, @BrunoGarrett1: Does Kevin Colbert as the GM not have any input into firing Mike Tomlin or is it 100 percent Art Rooney II’s decision and nobody else's?

Advertise with us

Zeise: I would be willing to bet that Colbert has very little say in that particular personnel decision. I am sure Art Rooney II would consult him, but that decision would 100 percent be Rooney’s to make. That’s how things operate over there.

Mike Tomlin talks about the injury to Ben Roethlisberger and kicker Chris Boswell

PittShawnC, @PittShawnC: Paul, should we also assume the Raiders had not provided lead vests for patients to wear while being X-rayed and therefore Ben may have been exposed to dangerous levels of radiation? (superpowers?)

Zeise: OK, this made me laugh, so I will play along. The X-ray machine story grew legs Tuesday and became silly, so this question isn’t that far out there. If Ben was indeed exposed to dangerous levels of radiation, shouldn’t he have emerged from the locker room looking like the Hulk? It happened for Bruce Banner, why not Ben?

LincolnEps324, @LEps324: As an X-ray tech of five years, do you think the tech told Roethlisberger to hold his breath?

Zeise: I’m not an X-ray technician and have no idea what the hell they did in the locker room. I am amused by how many X-ray machine questions I’ve gotten, though, so I guess I should offer my theory as to what happened. I can’t understand why Tomlin and Ben couldn’t just say “We tried to finish the game with Dobbs in order to save Ben from further injury, but once we fell behind we needed Ben to go in there and try to win the game.” That’s all that needed to be said instead of all this nonsense about X-ray machines. I don’t buy any of it.

Advertise with us

Neil Parker, Saltsburg: Since 2007, Willie Gay is the best DB the Steelers have drafted. I know the Rooneys have this fixation with stability, but at what point will [Art Rooney II] hold Colbert and Tomlin responsible for their ineptitude at drafting? (I include Tomlin because Colbert has said they make mutual decisions with the draft.)

Zeise: Tomlin/Colbert have invested 18 picks in defensive backs since they have been around, and very few have panned out. The fact that Willie Gay probably is the best one (look at the list, it is scary) since 2007 speaks volumes about how much they need to improve in this area. They need to do a better job of identifying talent and selecting players that can help them.

Joe Moore, Pittsburgh: Are we not at the point where most of the heat should be on the Rooneys for continuing to believe that every head coach they hire will be here for life?

Zeise: It has worked well for them until now. The stability model has been great for them, and that’s a philosophy to which they hold true. I agree it can get you in trouble if you are too loyal to coaches, but the Steelers have changed assistants as much as anyone. I don’t think keeping Tomlin around is a problem, but he needs to get the ship right.

Rob Ball, Monroeville: Can the Pirates not do a deal like Paul Goldschmidt because they don’t have the tradeable assets that St. Louis has, or is it Nutting’s teeny-tiny pocketbook? That said, this is a one-year deal and therefore very club friendly (low financial risk) to get a guy like Goldschmidt, but does this make sense for the Cardinals, in your opinion?

Advertise with us

Zeise: The Pirates won’t do a deal like Goldschmidt’s because they try to get rid of players on expiring contracts, not sign them. They like to have multiple years of control, and they don’t like giving up prospects for players, much less rent-a-players. The deal absolutely makes sense for the Cardinals, though, as they have made it pretty clear that next year is playoffs or bust. He brings a lot to the table, and there is some hidden value in him, too: If they are out of the playoff race in July, they could trade him to a contender that needs a power-hitting first baseman for a haul of prospects.

JohnnYinzer, @john1010miller: Will Jeff Capel’s crew win more than five ACC games?

Zeise: Only if the X-ray machine at Petersen Center is working.

Sorry about that, but I have X-ray machines on the brain right now. As for the Pitt men’s basketball team, no, I don’t think they will win more than five ACC games. I think five is actually a good over/under to shoot for. The ACC is a tough and deep league, and the Panthers have very few games you can point to and say, “Well they should win that one!” They also play most of the bad teams on the road and most of the good teams at home, so the ACC didn’t do them many favors with the schedule. If they go 4-14, it should be considered a really good season.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise