Gerry Dulac: Ok kids, let's get our chat started. I will await your directives....

Dave: Gerry, tomlins reasoning for not calling a timeout made absolutely no sense. Could’ve saved our offense about a min. There’s no defending that. His clock management alone shouldn’t bring him back next year

Gerry Dulac: A lot of them never do, mainly because he never wants to tip his hand. So he offers some explanation that doesn't always make sense. Just like his explanation after the game why he didn't put Ben in earlier. Two days later, after being chastised widely for his reasoning, he clarified the entire thing.

Dave: Prediction for Sunday?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: You'll have to wait for that

BB: Gerry - Is there something amiss in the way the Steelers evaluate and grade defensive draft picks? They have missed terribly on a number of them over the past several years and they have drastically different grades on players than others....which has led to reaches and misses. Changing coaches doesn't clean up this mess...

Gerry Dulac: Since Mike Tomlin became coach in 2007, the Steelers have drafted 14 cornerbacks. Only one of them -- William Gay, the first CB he ever drafted -- has received a second contract. And, based on the way Artie Burns is performing, that number has a good chance of remaining intact.

MT: I appear to have taken on the proverbial “deer in the headlights” countenance. Please remind your chatters that BC missed the playoffs three years in a row. Gracias.

Gerry Dulac: Yes, Bill Cowher missed the playoffs in 1998, '99 and 2000

Advertise with us

FR: What does the future hold for Mike Tomlin? If the Steelers miss the play-offs this year, will he have one more season as headcoach? Do you think he'll make significant changes with his coordinators?

Gerry Dulac: I do not see the Steelers getting rid of Mike Tomlin. But I do see them asking to make some changes in the staff, should they miss the playoffs. After all, they fired coordinators who were doing a good job in winning seasons.

REID: Is this the worst Steelers defense you ever seen?

Gerry Dulac: Not by a long shot. I hate to tell you this, but they are not THAT bad.

Brian: Gerry, do you think the Steelers will consider going for 2 after every touchdown as they used to 3-4 years ago? A possible way to limit Boswell attempts while he works out of his funk.

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: For that reason, I wouldn't be surprised. But, all that does, of course, is further erode whatever confidence Boswell still has in himself

Linebacker Lounge - 3Rivers, MI: Hi Gerry, Suprised Ham didn’t attend alumni weekend.. any know reason? .. Ward for that matter to.. Thanks

Gerry Dulac: I do not believe there is any animosity at all on Ham's part. With Hines, maybe he's upset he didn't get the WR coaching position this year after Richard Mann retired

REID: Why does Tomlin continually defer When he wins the coin toss and results in the pathetic defense being on the field first? Seems it puts us in an in an immediate hole most of the time

Gerry Dulac: I'm sorry, I think it's a good move. Have you paid attention to how the Steelers have scored a TD at the end of the first half in 8 of the 13 games? That then gives them a chance to add another at the start of the third quarter. Plus, he doesn't ALWAYS do it. Depends how they are playing and where

Advertise with us

DaquidoBazzini : Gerry, how do you think Mike Tomlin would react to a similar ultimatum from upper management (at the end of the season) that was presented to Chuck Noll after the 1991 season?

Gerry Dulac: Depends if he agreed with it

Jesse: Gerry, the NFL is crazy. First we stink, then were looking at a bye for the playoffs, now were on the fence to even make the playoffs! I think this team has been overrated from the get go. Remove #7 from the lineup, I don't know if we win any games. What say you?

Gerry Dulac: They wouldn't win many, that's for sure. That was vividly apparent in Oakland

SR62: Lets move past the last few weeks and focus on the game this week - what is the tone around the locker room? Boswell still there?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Tone is the same every week -- win or lose. That's one of the reasons for their success year after year

reedboat: Do you think poor conditioning had any affect on the defense's pitiful fourth quarter performances? Are coaches allowed to "whip 'em into shape" anymore?

Gerry Dulac: No. And no.

John DD: Hey Gerry. Are there year to year stats regarding IR injuries? It seems there has been an abundance of injuries across the league (except with Pittsburgh...oh the irony.) I was just wondering if that info is available.

Gerry Dulac: I don't know if they compile them year to year. I'm sure the NFL medical people probably have something like that. I'm not sure if injuries are on the rise or it's just another typical NFL season.

Advertise with us

Linebacker Lounge - 3Rivers, MI: Hi Gerry, Keep hearing Matakavich doesn’t have the speed to play.. but continuously see Vince who has speed not know who to cover.. sooner or later = Try something different.. Thoughts?

Gerry Dulac: Uhhhh, you sure you watching the right guy???

REID: The offense of line is catching a lot of flak this week for the poor rushing performance. But Samuels was extremely slow hitting the hole. Do you think it’s fair criticism ?

Gerry Dulac: It's the first time in a long time they didn't play well against one of the worst rush defense in the league. But they had only three pressures on Ben and only three on Dobbs, so the protection all in all was very good. Except for that big sack on third down when Ben got hurt

Jim: You think we make the playoffs?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: yes

Bob: Will Boswell be the kicker Sunday if you had to guess

Gerry Dulac: Yep

Lambert Lunatic : Hey Gerry! Let’s say Grimble doesn’t fumble at the goal line in Denver, officials give us ONE of those bad calls on a Chargers’ TD, and Ben doesn’t get sacked to play the whole 2nd half Sunday, then we are likely 10-2-1. With a different outcome on those 3 plays, Steelers would be a serious SB contender heading into NE and NO instead of a team in turmoil. Funny how this scenario would overshadow all of our other issues. So my actual question is, would this change YOUR perspective or predictions the next 2 weeks?

Gerry Dulac: It only does because it's New England and they have to prove they can beat them w Tom Brady, either here or there. To your point, the last 4 games have been decided on the final play. The Steelers easily could be 10-2-1 and being talked about as the most dangerous and best team in the NFL. Or they could be 6-6-1 and out of first place in the division. That's how close the difference is. But, I do acknowledge that good teams win those games, at least 3 of the 4, instead of losing 3 of the 4.

Advertise with us

SAM: In your opinion should the steelers fire coach Tomlin next year?

Gerry Dulac: Ask Rocky

REID: Do you think the Steelers miss Martavis Bryant in the passing game? Seems like there is no one stretching the secondary for AB to have a lot of room on his underneath routes and runs after catch

Gerry Dulac: Nope

Dan: "A lot of them never do, mainly because he never wants to tip his hand. So he offers some explanation that doesn't always make sense. Just like his explanation after the game why he didn't put Ben in earlier. Two days later, after being chastised widely for his reasoning, he clarified the entire thing..." THAT doesn't make sense either.

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Goes right with the question.

LA Matt: Although it is easy to blame Tomlin, Boswell et al, how does Colbert get off so easy? Considering his FA signings the past two years (Green Bostic and Burkett) and his failure to have an adequate, backup running back, his job should be in jeopardy too!

Gerry Dulac: Yeah, let's fire them all.

steelersfaninHartford: Gerry, what do you make of Dobbs arm strength. It looked like a couple of the passes that were batted down were slow to get to the receiver

Gerry Dulac: I think it is perfectly fine, NFL-caliber

Advertise with us

John DD: Do you remember if Steelers fans had this type of animosity toward Cowher during his losing seasons '98-'00,03 or Noll's '69-'71, '85-'86, '88, '91? Tomlin hasn't had a losing season yet and these trigger happy fans want him burned in effigy.

Gerry Dulac: I think the animosity directed at Tomlin is because people believe the Steelers have too much talent and see the window closing with Ben to not get back to the Super Bowl. But, without really remembering, I can promise you that fans being fans, they were on Cowher, too, though not like this.

Steeler fan from buffalo: Hi Gerry, Happy Holidays, what is going on inside the locker room? last 3 losses have been torture. We are not that bad and can't understand why we lose to inferior teams. What is your take? Boswell come onnnnnn, you've been so clutch and this year he has contributed to a couple of losses.

Gerry Dulac: I have always believed that your record says what you are. You're right, they are not that bad. In most instances than not, they have shown they can beat anyone in the league. But they have not been always able to win games when they've had the chance. They did last year. They were 8-2 in one-score games in 2017. This year they are 4-4-1.

Bake: It is certainly problematic that the same issues repeatedly plague the team, poor defense, clock management and use of challenges. However, all those calling for HC change should look no further than the local college, which parted ways with successful coaches who didn't win championships (Wannstedt and Dixon) with catastrophic results. Not saying that would happen to Steelers, but it raises the question who is available that could do better?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: It is the rarest of circumstances, despite what people think, that poor clock management and use of challenges ever directly cost a team a game, let alone been the blame for a losing season. I don't think you have to worry about having to find a new coach, unless this thing completely falls apart...and I just don't see that happening.

LA Matt: Although it is easy to say "Fire Tomlin," have those same people ever questioned how difficult it would be to find another coach as successful?

Gerry Dulac: Pay the man

The4ngryG4mer: Unpopular Opinion: There was nothing wrong with Tomlin's clock management at the end of the game. People complaining about that don't understand the difficulty of going down the field quickly with between the hash marks out of play. Hook and ladder on the sideline had 0 chance without that timeout.

Gerry Dulac: Pay him too

Advertise with us

chiefar: What are is your evaluation of Dobbs at QB?

Gerry Dulac: Are you asking because he did not play so well in Oakland? Or did you have this question ready to go and forgot to send after he completed that 22-yard pass in Baltimore?

Leaper: Are you of the thought that Tomlin and/or Butler needs to be replaced?

Gerry Dulac: I am not. I am of the thought they need to do something about finding inside linebackers who can run and cover, something they had a whole year to address and, as it turns out, haven't. The NFL game is played with speed and passes and RPOs. You better have inside guys who can run. They don't.

Bake: Should ARII tell Tomlin after the season he has to hire /appoint someone to be in charge/advise on time management and challenges?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: I think they should have someone upstairs in charge of replay reviews and not leave that to the assistant coaches.

DK_pasadena : Le’Veon Bell is the best running back in the NFL. Big Ben, AB, JuJu 2 of the top receivers, O-line tops as well. LB could be the 3rd best receiver/running back. As Pouncey said last year “pay the man.” Ben’s time for winning a SB is waning. I doubt the Steelers don’t have the money, so why not sign him and move on knowing he’s locked up for long term?

Gerry Dulac: They wanted to. He didn't like their offer. He wanted more money. He made that choice. I haven't seen any Super Bowl appearances since LB arrived. But I've seen plenty before him and there will be more after him. Let's see how he does somewhere else

Gerry Dulac: OK, kids, we're out of time. Thanx for the questions.

Gerry Dulac: Sorry I couldn't answer them all. If I did, we'd be here till kickoff. Thanx for the interest.