Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.
Let’s get started:
Marty Petronski, Point Breeze: That is a devastating loss to the Chargers, but I don’t think it really changes the Steelers’ prospects for the playoffs all that much. Basically they just need to beat the Bengals and Raiders and they will be in regardless of what happens in the other two games. You seem to think otherwise based on your comments. Do you really believe the Steelers could miss the playoffs?
Zeise: The Steelers missing the playoffs is a very real possibility. Now, do I think they will? No, I think they will find a way to win one of the two games they aren’t supposed to win and finish 3-1 to put them at 10-5-1. That will be good enough to win the division. That being said, if they get swept by the Saints and Patriots, I think they will miss the playoffs. I think the Ravens will win three of their last four and finish 10-6. I know they play both Kansas City and San Diego on the road, but I have a hunch they will win one of those two games. The Steelers have played with fire here and it isn’t going to take a whole lot for them to get burned. And here is the thing —if they miss the playoffs, it would be one of the worst cases of a team underachieving I can remember. I will say it again, though: I do not think they will miss the playoffs.
Nate Throm, Pittsburgh: With Mike McCarthy being fired in Green Bay having won a Super Bowl and amassing 10 playoff wins in his career, do you think this false narrative about Mike Tomlin being irreplaceable will finally go away?
Zeise: No, there are some people who are enamored with all of his regular-season success. I don’t think he should be fired, but if that doomsday scenario we just talked about happens — the Steelers miss the playoffs — then he should absolutely be on the hot seat next year. As I’ve said many times, winning a championship does not ensure you a lifetime contract. It is a bottom-line business and the bottom line is the Steelers have not maximized their talent since 2010. That is a long stretch of years. I like Mike Tomlin. I think he has done a good job, but his playoff record of late has been abysmal given the talent he has. He needs to get this group to the Super Bowl, and if he doesn’t, then some hard questions need to be asked about whether he has taken this team as far as he can.
Read More
Ernie Actosa, Greensburg: Do you still think the Steelers shouldn’t have paid Le’Veon Bell his money? They are in a world of trouble now that James Conner is hurt.
Zeise: I absolutely still think the Steelers should not have given Le’Veon Bell a long-term deal. I will go one step further — they shouldn’t have tagged him, either. As I wrote before, they should have non-exclusive tagged him and allowed him to work out a deal with another team, traded him and moved on. They should have then signed a much cheaper veteran as a backup plan in case James Conner couldn’t get the job done or got hurt. The Steelers’ biggest mistake was not having a plan in place in case Bell decided to hold out once the games started. Stevan Ridley is not the answer and the amount of work he has gotten the last month — one carry — speaks volumes about what they really think about him.
Bill Washington, Pittsburgh: If the Pitt football team loses their bowl game and finishes with a non-winning record for the second straight year, would you still consider this season a success?
Zeise: Yes, I think the season is a success from the standpoint that they finally had a breakthrough and won the Coastal Division. That is something to build on. I also think that Pat Narduzzi seems to finally be building a strong defense. It has taken a little longer than most people thought it would, but the reality is the defense improved as the season went on. There have been clear strides made. Now they need to take the next step forward. They need to win all the games they should win and they need to be more competitive against the top teams on their schedule. This was a steppingstone season and they clearly took some steps forward, though not as many strides as they could have taken had they just played a little better in some spots.
Terry Unluvaro, Charleroi: How is it possible that Kenny Pickett threw for only 8 yards against Clemson? That’s ridiculous in football these days. What is the problem with Pitt’s passing game - play calling, Pickett, the receivers or the offensive line and protection? I have never seen a worse quarterback performance in a big game.
Zeise: I’d say all of the above were the issue. I’d add one more — Clemson’s front seven was a problem. Pickett needs to play better than he did, and he would tell you that. The offensive line needs to protect him better than they did and I’m sure they’d agree, too. The play calling lacked some imagination, but it is hard to call plays and take shots when you are struggling to handle the other team’s front seven. It was just one of those nights where nothing seemed to work and then they fell behind and Clemson’s front seven knew they had to pass. Pickett will get better with more work and the hope is that as he improves and the offense expands to incorporate more passing.
Jonathan Caridi, Fox Chapel: I think Pitt laid a good foundation this year, but what is going to be acceptable next year in Year 5? I say Pitt needs to win at least nine regular-season games, get back to the ACC title game and then win a bowl. Narduzzi has a lot of players coming back and it is his program now. There are no more losses to teams like North Carolina that will be acceptable.
Zeise: The next step is win the games they are supposed to win, be more competitive against the top teams on the schedule, and get to double-digit wins. That’s probably what should be expected next year. They should be able to get three wins in their nonconference games (as opposed to one, like this year) looking at their schedule. They should be able to go at least 6-2 in the ACC again. That would put them at 9-3 and likely give them a shot at a second trip to the ACC title game.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.