It is hard to argue with the success Mike Sullivan has had since he became the Penguins’ head coach. He is in his fourth season and has already led the Penguins to two Stanley Cups. The Penguins’ star power is the biggest reason for their success, but Sullivan’s role should not be minimized, as he made seemingly every right move to push those teams to championships.

Sullivan has often been right, but that doesn’t mean he hasn’t, in some cases, been wrong. I happen to think his use — or lack thereof — and subsequent trade of Ian Cole, for instance, was the wrong move for a team starving for defensemen who actually play defense. I’m not saying Cole was the missing link to a three-peat, but the Penguins were better when they had him.

That brings me to this current small, but seemingly growing, goalie controversy that Sullivan has created. Matt Murray was signed to a long-term deal and made Marc-Andre Fleury expendable. He essentially had two rookie seasons (because of service-time rules for rookies), and the Penguins won the Stanley Cup with him as the starter both years.

Murray was inconsistent last season, but he was far more good than bad. He also wasn’t the reason the Penguins got knocked out of the playoffs by the Capitals. Murray played well enough, with the exception of Game 5, in that series for the Penguins to win it. They lost for a variety of other reasons, and Murray was really low on that list.

Advertise with us

He has now seemingly been relegated to backup duty, as Casey DeSmith has started the last two games, and all signs point to him starting again Tuesday night in New Jersey. DeSmith has absolutely outplayed Murray by every metric (Murray’s goals-allowed average, for instance, is 3.87, or basically twice DeSmith’s 1.89).

In general, I am in favor of a merit system in which the best player gets to play, but there are times when a player’s history needs to matter. Murray has proven he can win in the Stanley Cup playoffs. He has proven he can play like one of the top goaltenders in the NHL. He has been streaky in his career, and that’s probably all the more reason to let him play his way out of this.

There are some who’d argue the Penguins can’t afford to lose a game or two waiting for Murray to find his game. That’s way overstating the importance of a couple of points in November. The Penguins were middling when Mike Johnston was fired a few years ago and had no issues making the playoffs because they got hot when Sullivan took over. The Penguins have gotten off to slow starts in other years, as well, but they always seem to play well in the second half to make their playoff push.

That isn’t to say games don’t matter in November, but rather that losing a few in the name of a greater, more long-term good isn’t going to hinder the Penguins’ playoff chances. The Penguins need Murray to get right, and the only way that will happen is if he is allowed to play a string of games. The more he plays, the more likely he is to bust out of his slump.

Now is the time to find out if Murray is going to snap out of his funk. If he gets to a point where he plays a volume of bad games in a row, the Penguins should then make the change to DeSmith and see where it takes them. They don’t seem to be at that point with Murray yet (nor should they be), and if that is the case, then he needs to be treated as the No. 1 goaltender.

Advertise with us

Sullivan has had a method to his madness, and for the most part, it has worked. But he has to be careful not to overplay his hand. He tends to micromanage too much and is impatient. And while those can be good traits, they can also hurt when a coach is dealing with a veteran team that has had a lot of success.

Sullivan’s constant tinkering with the lines and his need to hold certain players accountable worked early, but he is now in Year 4. Those things can become annoying to the stars and veterans, and once Sullivan loses them, he will lose the team. That’s not to say he shouldn’t coach and coach hard, but he may need to back off of these constant lineup changes and just trust his team and let them play.

That starts with Murray, who deserves the opportunity to play his way out of this funk. The players respect Murray, they enjoy playing in front of him and they trust him. Sullivan needs to trust him, too, because he has proven himself over the past three seasons. It doesn’t mean Murray should get a lifetime pass or keep the job regardless of what happens, but it does mean he’s earned some leeway and the benefit of the doubt.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com