Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com. Let’s get started:
Carlo Gambino, @Gambino_166: The Steelers defense has proven to be inept. Is it time to re-staff the defensive coaching & focus on upgrading the defensive talent by sacrificing offensive payroll ... aka No. 7 & No. 84? Nothing is being won with them on the roster; why not start developing their replacements?
Zeise: As long as Ben Roethlisberger is healthy and capable of playing at a reasonably high level, he gives the Steelers a chance. There is no way they should move on from him because that position is too important. Teams that have a franchise quarterback have a chance no matter who is around them. Teams that do not have to have a lot of other things in place in order to win. It isn’t impossible to win without a franchise quarterback, but it is much harder. The Antonio Brown thing is worth entertaining. I think if the Steelers wash out again this year, it may be a fair question to ask if they are getting enough bang for their dollars spent? If they were to move him, it would free up about $17 million to help rebuild the defense. They have won nothing with him, and he is a bit of a distraction. I am not saying he should be traded, but that isn’t as crazy of an idea as it would seem. If they took the money and turned it into players who help rebuild the defense, it might be worth it. As for changing the defensive staff, well, I’ve been asking why that hasn’t happened for at least a year.
Dac, @Dac00272734: Why does Joey Porter still have a job? Also, does Le’Veon Bell returning help Tomlin coach or Butler scheme? One guy will not win a Super Bowl.
Zeise: Other than befriend the head coach, I have no idea what Joey Porter has done to merit the position he has. The linebackers have not gotten better under his watch, even a little bit. T.J. Watt has regressed. Bud Dupree hasn’t progressed. And you are right, LeVeon Bell doesn’t play defense, but he certainly makes the team better. Also, his ability to give the Steelers’ running game a boost would help the defense because maybe it keeps them on the field a little longer each game. The less the defense is on the field, the better it is for the Steelers.
Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.
Read More
Support journalism. Subscribe today.
Roger Littleberry, @relgreyhound: When are the Steelers going to draft a dominant defensive player?
Zeise: Wait, you mean Ziggy Hood, Artie Burns and Jarvis Jones weren’t dominant? I don’t know what your definition of dominant is, so that makes this a tough question to ask. They drafted Ryan Shazier, and he was becoming an excellent defensive player. Dominant? No, but more than effective. Cam Heyward has been borderline dominant in his career. He isn’t, say, Khalil Mack or Von Miller, but he has been stellar for most of his career. In other words, the Steelers have drafted some good to borderline excellent defensive players over the years, but you probably have to go back to 2003 to find the last truly dominant defensive player they drafted: Troy Polamalu.
Andrew S, @burgthing: Who has the final decision at a Steelers draft? Can OC or DC have their say in rounds 4-plus?
Zeise: I don’t think anyone knows who has the final decision. I’d imagine, in some instances, that would be Art Rooney II. If for some reason he doesn’t want a player whom the coach and general manager wants, I assume he has the right to say no. I’d think that happens very rarely, though. Mike Tomlin and Kevin Colbert work together as a team. Tomlin likely has the final say on a player, and I’m sure those two have worked together long enough that Colbert knows what he is looking for. If Tomlin wants someone and Colbert doesn’t, I’m sure they have long discussions about it. In the end, though, I’d be shocked if Tomlin — 10-plus years into his time here — doesn’t have the power to take who he wants. As for the coordinators, I am sure they have input on some level. I doubt they make the final decision, but it would be counter productive for them not to be involved in the process.
Anthony Ferraro, @progman1975: Why does Clint Hurdle still have a job??
Zeise: Well it would be tough to get rid of him after a winning season. The Pirates actually made progress this year. They played well down the stretch, and he did a good job of guiding them through some tough times. The young pitching staff progressed, and the team kept fighting to the end of the season. I’m not saying you throw a parade after what was basically a .500 season, but I do thinkt the job Hurdle did merits another season. But now there will be expectations on him to take them to the next level next season. That is when the real heavy lifting begins, and we will see if he is up to it.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.