It has been at least a decade since Jung Ho Kang last played a game for the Pirates. OK, that’s a bit of an exaggeration, but it sure seems like it has been that long.
Kang last played a major league game Oct. 2, 2016, two full seasons ago. It is hard to know exactly what kind of shape he is in. It is hard to know exactly how quickly he would retain his ability to play baseball at a high level or even if he will ever be able to be a productive major leaguer again. These are answers nobody will really know until next season begins, assuming he is healthy, and he starts playing again.
General manager Neal Huntington has said the Pirates would like to retain Kang but maybe not at the price his club option would dictate. The Pirates would have to pay Kang $5.5 million for 2019 if they exercise his option. They could decline the option and buy Kang out for $250,000, and at that point he would become a free agent.
“We like the upside of the player,” Huntington told the Post-Gazette’s Bill Brink last week. “Now we just need to put a dollar figure to the attainability of that, the risk that we’re willing to take, the risk he’s willing to take, and does it make sense?”
I understand why there would be hesitation on the Pirates’ part to bring back Kang. He has had two major injuries over the past two years and he also has had a myriad of legal issues to deal with. He has been arrested at least three times (internationally) for DUI, which denied him a visa to work in the United States.
There is a lot of risk involved in signing Kang, but there is also the potential for a lot of reward. And that is exactly why the Pirates should exercise the option and ensure that they keep Kang in the organization for next season. Kang may not be ready to return to being a legitimate right-handed power source and third baseman, but if he is, he would fill a lot of the Pirates’ biggest needs.
Read More
Huntington acknowledged as much and said the Pirates would really benefit from a healthy Kang.
“Obviously to add a right-handed bat that can hit 25 to 30 home runs and play good defense, if we can get him back to that, that’s a really interesting player,” Huntington said. “But we also haven’t seen that player in two years. There’s a middle ground hopefully we’ll be able to find.”
The Pirates need to find more than middle ground. They need to make sure they get a deal done. The reality is $5.5 million in the grand scheme of things is just not that much money to take a chance on a player with Kang’s potential. It just isn’t. The Pirates saved some money by trading David Freese, they will save money by not picking up Josh Harrison’s option, and they will save money by not re-signing Jordy Mercer.
This is a team whose payroll could be somewhere around $75 million to $80 million to start next season if they don’t add anything. The $5.5 million it would take to guarantee Kang is back with the Pirates is well worth it. They could waive the option and try to re-negotiate with Kang, but there is a risk there because he would become a free agent.
I don’t think it is always good business to take a risk on some players, but Kang checks so many boxes it would make sense for the Pirates to gamble on him. They have gambled on players in the past — Francisco Liriano and Edison Volquez — and it paid big dividends.
The bottom line is the Pirates desperately need what Kang brings. They need a much better defensive third baseman than Colin Moran and they need another infielder with legitimate power. A healthy Kang would solidify the Pirates’ infield and it would soften the blow of the potential loss of power if Gregory Polanco (shoulder surgery) isn’t able to return until late June.
The Pirates aren’t going to pay the kind of money it would take to sign a player with 30-home run potential. They aren’t going to go out in free agency and sign anyone of note who will add that kind of power. Frankly, there aren’t many legitimate options on the market.
Kang may turn out to be a bust. He may be done and his body may be too broken down to ever be the kind of player he has been in his short time in a Pirates uniform. If he is indeed done, the only risk is $5.5 million, which in the world of baseball is peanuts.
That’s the risk the Pirates are taking. The reward, however, could be a much better defensive infield and a player who hits between 25 to 30 homers and has an OPS of about .850. That is a risk the Pirates absolutely must take if they are truly interested in becoming a contender next season.
Paul Zeise: pzesie@post-gazette.com or on Twitter @PaulZeise.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.