In case you missed it, and most of you probably did, the Pirates have actually played some reasonably good baseball in the past week. They won five in a row before Monday’s loss in St. Louis and put themselves in position to finish .500 or better for only the fourth time in a quarter century. Yes, it came against the awful Reds and Marlins, but the Pirates — particularly the pitching staff — took care of business.
But it doesn’t matter if the Pirates are 79-83, 81-81 or 83-79; those records all suggest a team that was painfully mediocre. And they also suggest the roster still needs to be upgraded to take the next step back to the playoffs. The spin from the front office, however, will likely be “We are close, we just needed a few breaks and we would have have been right in the wild-card mix,” but that is nonsense.
That’s why this offseason should be make or break for Neal Huntington and company. The 2019 season should be playoffs-or-bust. The front office has done a reasonably good job of building a solid core of players that could be the foundation of a playoff team. There are some major questions, though, about the roster heading into next season.
The infield is not good enough: Maybe Jung-Ho Kang returns and solves some of the problem, but that seems like a long shot. Colin Moran is a platoon player who can play against righties, but defensively he is a liability. David Freese is no longer with the Pirates. Third base has to be the priority, with second base not far behind, as the Pirates will likely not pick up Josh Harrison’s option. Maybe that player is Kevin Kramer, but he hasn’t shown enough to feel good about him taking over full time.
There is not enough power in the lineup: Corey Dickerson began the season hitting like an MVP candidate and cooled off considerably, which is similar to what he did last season and may be a reason the Rays were so willing to trade him. Josh Bell was supposed to be that big bat in the middle of the lineup, but after an excellent rookie season, he has found a sophomore slump.
The Pirates’ two outfield stars — Starling Marte and Gregory Polanco — are extremely inconsistent: How they go, the team seems to go. They have proven they are capable of carrying the offense when they are hot. The problem is both are mostly feast or famine, and when they are not hot there doesn’t seem to be enough left in the lineup to enable the Pirates to score runs consistently.
Read More
They are still a bad defensive team: Adam Frazier has proven to be an extremely capable major league hitter, but his defense at second base is average to slightly below average. His best role is probably as a super utility player, and if the right side of the infield is Frazier and Bell, it is probably the worst defensively in the National League. It seems like Kevin Newman will be the shortstop next season, and he will certainly help solidify the Pirates’ infield defense.
That may seem like a lot, but it really isn’t in the grand scheme of things. The Pirates’ front office needs to commit to upgrading these areas. it needs to build on the trades made at the deadline and give the team a real chance to make a run at the playoffs.
If they do, next season will be a lot of fun. If they don’t make these upgrades, the Pirates will be stuck once again trying to convince the fan base that .500 baseball is something to be proud of.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.