Neal Huntington issued a challenge to his team July 8. He called this past week the most important one of the season. He even used the phrase “win-now mode,” which would suggest he wants to do everything in his power to put the team in playoff position.

The Pirates responded by going 7-1, and that includes a five-game sweep of the then-NL Central-leading Brewers. The Pirates played their best baseball since early in the season, when they were in first place after a 26-17 start. They played an exciting brand of baseball, the kind that contending teams play. It was an excellent week, and Huntington’s vision of a young, hungry team winning games came to fruition.

They answered Huntington’s challenge resoundingly, and now the ball is in his court. He told them to win games, and they won games. He told them this was an important week; they put themselves back into the playoff discussion.

No doubt, the Pirates’ general manager is ready to jump on the bandwagon, right? He’ll make the moves he needs to make to strengthen the Pirates in places where they need the most help, right? He’ll be willing to part with some of the Pirates’ most prized prospects in order to bring back major league talent, right?

Advertise with us

Austin Meadows should now be a trade piece. Mitch Keller, Kevin Newman, Ke’Bryan Hayes — all of them should be on the table. They have to be. Huntington said he was going to help this team if they proved they deserved it. Now that they’ve proved it, will he be all in?

Well, not quite. Judging from comments Huntington made Sunday to an assembled group of media, it’s pretty clear that won’t be the case. Huntington is still going to sell — not buy — and that becomes more and more obvious every day.

“While we’ve closed ground in the division, and while we’ve closed ground in the wild card — while we’ve had a really good week against really good teams — we need to do more,” he said.

Apparently, this past week was just for practice. The real test comes after the All-Star break. If they go 9-1 in their first 10 games, that’s when he will spring into action. That’s when he will go out and get the help the Pirates need to contend this year. That’s when he will start calling teams to offer a package of Keller and Hayes for a pitcher or two.

Hey, we’re just taking him at his word. He said this was an important week for the Pirates, and they delivered in a big way.

Advertise with us

It’s comical, actually, because the Pirates essentially called Huntington’s bluff. He put himself out on a limb and never thought his team would have that kind of week.

The Pirates could have gone 5-3 and it still would have been a successful stretch; Huntington likely would have spun it in a way to indicate that it was a fun week, yes, but wasn’t quite enough.

The bottom line is this is a classic example of how Huntington gets himself into trouble and undermines his credibility with the fans. The Pirates’ front office still doesn’t understand. They still think fans don’t trust them because of losing records the past two years.

That’s not the case at all.

Fans are just tired of Huntington’s constant spin and refusal to deal in reality. He is right to stay the course and sell, because this isn’t a playoff team. He would be a fool to trade any prospect of value to try to help this team. It isn’t realistic to think the Pirates can become a playoff contender with just a few additions.

Advertise with us

They are still nine games out of first place and still 5½ games out of the wild-card race. They have five teams between them and the second wild-card spot, and two teams between them and first place.

That’s the reality of this team — despite the great week — and a reality Huntington is smart enough to know and understand. That’s why declarations like “we are in win-now mode” when the Pirates clearly are not are just silly. Huntington isn’t dumb, but based on the things he has said, he clearly thinks we all are.

This time, his team called his bluff and put him in a most uncomfortable position. Hopefully, he learns from it. Hopefully, he’ll be more honest about what kind of team he has and just how far off they are from being a playoff contender.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com, Twitter: @PaulZeise.