Note: This feature originally appeared in Sunday’s print edition of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. It was updated to reflect recent news and games. Statistics are updated through Saturday’s action. 

It all seemed to change on May 18.

That was the date of Austin Meadows’ big-league debut, the date of Starling Marte’s move to the disabled list. Heading into that day, the Pirates were 26-17, with a half-game lead atop the National League Central.

Then, they lost, 3-2, to the San Diego Padres at home. They lost their next two games, too, to the same inferior Padres team. That series kicked off eight consecutive series losses, and by mid-June, the Pirates had not won back-to-back games in nearly a month.

Advertise with us

The early season optimism, the chip-on-the-shoulder quality, the post-win dances — that was gone, at least for a while. While they put a stop to that series skid, the Pirates were not able to turn things around until the last week, when they won eight of nine games.

Heading into the All-Star break, the Pirates are one game below .500 and nine games back of the Chicago Cubs. Since that dreaded May 18 date, they have gone 22-32, their record rescued in recent days by a five-game sweep of the Milwaukee Brewers.

“The other teams have been playing better than us,” Francisco Cervelli said Wednesday. “That’s it. They’ve been the better team than us. That’s all I can say. If you start looking around — coaches, whatever — that’s an excuse. We have to be able to perform better.”

So, what changed? The answer may be all of the above.

Offense

Advertise with us

The offense was an early bright spot, and their 4.35 runs per game, while slightly below the league average, is still better than it was last year. The Pirates have fewer home runs and a slightly lower OPS than most teams, too. On the bright side, their strikeout rate (20 percent) is tied for third-lowest in the league.

However, the Pirates have not exhibited much more power than they did last year. Their 96 home runs are on pace to exceed last year’s total by about nine. Their slugging percentage (.406) has ticked up 20 points but is in the middle of the pack.

After hitting 26 homers in his rookie season, Josh Bell has homered just five times. Rookie Colin Moran, who has two grand slams, and Corey Dickerson have provided steady contributions, if not huge amounts of pop. Josh Harrison has produced a low .637 OPS. Starling Marte and Gregory Polanco lead the team with 13 and 16 homers, respectively.

For a while, the players who made up the four-man outfield were not been as productive as they were before the new setup was created. Polanco and Marte have heated up considerably, and Meadows was sent down to the minors Sunday.

Grade: C

Advertise with us

Defense

Advanced fielding metrics are not kind to the Pirates. The team ranks fourth from the bottom in MLB with -53 defensive runs saved and seventh-worst with a -14.7 ultimate zone rating. The eye test hasn’t been much kinder, either.

Still, the speedy Marte has acquitted himself well in his first full season as the center fielder, tracking down most every ball sent his way. His eight outs above average is tied for sixth in MLB.

Dickerson has proved to be a pleasant surprise in left field. While he doesn’t have the strongest arm, he picks his spots well and has seven outfield assists. Polanco and Bell continue to have occasional trouble on routine plays. Moran has a good arm but not especially strong range at third base, and he’s still developing his intuition at the position. Harrison and Jordy Mercer have been steady, but Sean Rodriguez’s earlier slip-ups in the infield presented an unexpected challenge.

Grade: D

Advertise with us
Pirates second baseman Josh Harrison loses his grip on a throw to first July 6 at PNC Park. (Matt Freed / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Starting pitching

The rotation is young, and as general manager Neal Huntington recently noted, “when you have good, young players, you have more variability.”

The starting rotation’s 4.30 ERA and 4.28 FIP (fielding independent pitching) are fifth-highest in the National League. Although they walk fewer batters than most NL clubs, they also strike out fewer batters, and going deep in games has been an issue.

Still, Ivan Nova believes this group is “pretty solid.”

“You’re going to give up runs,” Nova said. “You’re going to give up homers. You’re going to lose games. But it’s always something positive that you can take out of each and every one of the guys every time they start or they’re coming out of the bullpen. That’s what I mean when I say ‘solid.’ I’ve seen guys go in another direction.”

Advertise with us

No one pitcher has solidified his place at the top of the rotation; everybody has had ups and downs. Jameson Taillon has, at times, appeared like the elite pitcher the Pirates have hoped he would be, but he is the first to admit that he has had to roll up his sleeves too much this season.

“In my head, again, I’m going to say, I shouldn’t have to battle, I shouldn’t have to grind with stuff as good as mine is,” Taillon said after a recent start in San Diego. Since then, he has allowed four runs in 12 2/3 innings and set a career-high with 10 strikeouts in a game.

Grade: C-

Bullpen

The bullpen has had occasional stretches of brilliance and stretches in which it seemed the relievers could not record an out. The relievers’ 4.33 ERA is fifth-highest in the National League, and the bullpen has squandered too many leads. They also have the fourth-highest strikeout rate in MLB.

Advertise with us

Right now, the bullpen is in an upswing. Felipe Vazquez, who has had 15 consecutive scoreless outings, seems to have returned to his 2017 prowess after a long, confounding stretch that included four blown saves in six appearances, and Kyle Crick has turned into a reliable No. 2 arm. Michael Feliz’s steep decline has been surprising, while Tyler Glasnow has made notable strides. Richard Rodriguez was a strong signing.

Grade: D+

Can't get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?

Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.

Coaching

Advertise with us

It’s difficult to quantify a manager’s impact, and a coach can only do so much with the personnel he has. But it is easier to question individual decisions, especially long-term ones. You can put Clint Hurdle’s decision to start Sean Rodriguez repeatedly — even at the height of Rodriguez’s struggles, even as the team was stumbling — in that latter category.

On the margin, other choices (how Hurdle handled Polanco’s down spell and Meadows’ hot start, for example) could be picked apart. Sitting Marte for three games on the West Coast has paid immediate dividends.

As an outsider, it is also hard to know what the mood is between players and their managers. In spring training, David Freese indicated his displeasure with the tone set in the organization, while Taillon’s outward disappointment at being pulled after 77 pitches in a recent outing was certainly different.

The addition of assistant pitching coach Justin Meccage has paid dividends. Nova worked closely with Ray Searage to make critical adjustments to his delivery during his stint on the disabled list. Nevertheless, the performance of the Pirates pitching staff has been uneven, and that’s on coaching.

With help from staff, Cervelli and Polanco have tweaked their approaches at the plate, although Polanco’s slump was rather long, and Bell only recently seems to be emerging from struggles at the plate.

Advertise with us

The base paths continue to be an issue for the Pirates, who have been overly aggressive at times, too timid at others, as Polanco’s non-tag in San Diego showed.

Grade: C-

Front office

Over the winter, Huntington said the 2018 Pirates were closer to the 2011 to 2013 teams than the rebuilding clubs of a decade ago. That may, ultimately, end up being true, but both those squads were better than .500 through the first half of the season.

Huntington previously said the Pirates would benefit from internal improvements, including better health and more availability from players such as Polanco, Cervelli and Marte, but the overall results haven’t always been there. He also has taken the fall for not shoring up the bullpen. Of course, Huntington has financial limitations, which must be factored into any evaluation. Still, the continued lack of power at the plate and the persistent issues developing reliable pitching are also on management.

Advertise with us

The trade for Dickerson, the signing of Richard Rodriguez and the decision to keep Meadows with the big-league club deserve praise, less so the handling of Meadows’ recent demotion. The return on Andrew McCutchen — Crick, who has been excellent, and prospect Bryan Reynolds — seems thin, considering the impact of the trade on the Pirates’ brand among fans and the fact that the money saved from McCutchen’s salary hasn’t gone toward improving other areas of the roster.

The Gerrit Cole trade has borne more fruit: The Pirates have a solid third baseman in Moran, a potential long-term starter in Musgrove and a terrific outfield prospect in Jason Martin.

Grade: D+

Elizabeth Bloom: ebloom@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BloomPG.