Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com. Let’s get started:
Matt D, Murrysville: Why do the Pirates constantly preach “accountability” but never actually practice it? I’m talking about management as well as players.
Paul: This is a question comes up often when the same players seem to continually make the same mistakes. There have been a few third base coaches fired in recent years, but it does seem like Clint Hurdle has, at times, missed opportunities to send a message of accountability. There are too many of the same base running mistakes, for instance, made far too often, and nobody ever seems to get benched. At times, Gregory Polanco has looked like he is disinterested or lacks a sense of urgency, and he seems to get more playing time, not less. That’s the perception, but Hurdle and Neal Huntington would say discipline decisions and matters are handled behind closed doors. It has never been Hurdle’s style to rip into a player for all to see. hat doesn’t mean he isn’t holding players accountable. He could be, and I would bet he’s holding players accountable in other ways and keeping it within the confines of the clubhouse.
Chad Ruffner, New Alexandria: Do you think ranking teams farm systems in MLB are overrated? For the past several years we’ve heard how highly rated the Pirates minor league system is, yet here we are.
Paul: Ranking prospects is similar to recruiting rankings and mock drafts. They are all based on potential and/or perception of potential but don’t ensure anything about any one individual. Players are sometimes overrated. These rankings, though a bit overrated, are not totally meaningless. They are merely a gauge of the level and number of prospects a team has. Obviously, the more top prospects an organization has, the better it is for the future.
Paul Calibreese, Ellwood City: What did you think about David Carr’s comments about Ben Roethlisberger? Also, what are your thoughts on the NFL Network’s top 10 players list?
Read More
Paul: David Carr’s premise that talented players around Roethlisberger enable him to be a star isn’t new or that far out of line. It is true — great players enable other players around them to be great as well. It was a whole lot of nothing on a slow news day. As for the “Top 100,” it’s a list designed to get people to talk about the NFL during the offseason and not much more.The fact that Carson Wentz was No. 3 on that list meant I didn’t need to read past the first three names to know I had no interest in it.
Marty Caridi, Lawrenceville: Your co-worker Dorin Dickerson is trying out for the WWE. Why don’t you go with him and take a shot becoming a professional wrestler? Also, if you and Dorin wrestled, who would win?
Paul: Well he is young and in shape. I am old and fat. I probably couldn’t get through the first 10 minutes of the tryout. Have you seen Dorin recently? He is chiseled and looks like he could still play in the NFL. I wouldn’t wrestle him because it would be embarrassing for him to be pinned by an old, fat dude. (OK, maybe he’d win...)
Zach Phillips, Allison Park: How do you think Tim McConnell will do as a girls coach? Is there more to this story than just that he wanted a change of scenery?
Paul: I don’t know the whole story, so I am not going to speculate. I’ll take him at his word: He felt like he needed a new challenge and a new voice for the boys program was probably overdue. I think he will do great for two reasons: He is a great coach, and he has a roster that is fairly loaded. He also has one of the best point guards in the state to build around, and she happens to share his last name.
Greg Collen, Highland Park: Who is more likely to still be on a Pittsburgh team next year at this time — Phil Kessel or Le’Veon Bell?
Paul: Great question. I’d say Kessel. I just don’t expect Le’Veon Bell to get a long-term deal, so I think he will be a free agent after this season.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.