Is Ben Roethlisberger over the hill?

The Steelers’ quarterback has come down on both sides of that question over the past year, but NFL.com’s David Carr seems pretty confident that the 36-year-old’s teammates are carrying him at this point in his career.

The former NFL signal-caller — best known as the Houston Texans’ first-ever draft pick back in 2002 — produced his list of the league’s top 10 quarterbacks over the weekend, and Roethlisberger surprisingly wasn’t on it despite his pair of Super Bowl wins. The reason?

Yes, he's a future Hall of Famer and there's no doubt he can still help the Steelers. But he has the most talented skill players in the league on his unit, and that pair — Antonio Brown and Le'Veon Bell — makes him look great 14 seasons in. I don't think Big Ben could win a ton of games without them at this stage in his career.

That’s certainly a fair point in isolation. Brown and Bell are the types of players who make everyone around them look better. That analysis should certainly apply to their quarterback.

Advertise with us

The problem is that Carr undercuts his point pretty badly in explaining the rest of his rankings.

Five of his choices are age 33 and older. Tom Brady, 40, slots in at No. 1. Aaron Rodgers, 34 and injured for most of last season, was ranked second. And 39-year-old Drew Brees came in at No. 3, because...

Brees’ numbers dipped from past seasons, but it's understandable when considering the players in the Saints' historic backfield (Alvin Kamara and Mark Ingram).

Uh ... isn’t the presence of transcendent talent to carry him the reason Roethlisberger was left off the list entirely?

Adding insult to contradiction, Carr goes on to list Phillip Rivers — a 36-year-old member of Roethlisberger’s draft class — at No. 7 before delivering the real gobsmacker: San Francisco’s Jimmy Garoppolo at No. 10.

The former second-round pick spent most of his carer mopping up for Tom Brady in New England before getting off to an admittedly fast start with his new team, winning his first five starts with the 49ers last season.

Advertise with us

That’s a cool story. Until you consider that Roethlisberger started his career by winning his first 14 starts, losing only to Brady and the Patriots in the 2004 AFC championship.

Roethlisberger may not be among the elite of the elite at this point in his career, but until Garoppolo accomplishes at least that much, maybe Carr should make room for one more old guy on his list.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24. 

Our in-depth Steelers coverage is second to none.

Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.