Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Bob McAdoo and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Actually, we’re going to start with our intergalactically acclaimed Twitter Poll segment today. I asked the following question Monday and had 948 votes as of early Tuesday morning:
The Pirates’ All-Star rep should be …
Cervelli: 14%
Dickerson: 14%
Nobody: 34%
Read More
No way Mullsy made 9 3’s: 38%
What we learned: This Mullsy thing has staying power, and the Pirates really don’t have an All-Star candidate who jumps off the page — although Cervelli, despite a recent slump and injury issues, still has the best numbers on the team relative to his peers.
Even with only 175 at-bats, Cervelli is second among National League starting catchers in RBIs (36) and OPS (.876). He’s also third in caught-stealing percentage (.324), having already thrown out one more baserunner than he did all of last season.
To me, that makes him the Pirates’ obvious choice. Every team must be represented, by the way, except in case of injury. In other words, if your team’s lone choice is injured, he doesn’t have to be replaced by another player on your team.
Corey Dickerson remains a player the Pirates are touting (along with Cervelli) for the All-Star Game, and he is seventh among NL outfielders in batting average at .296. But his power has disappeared. He has not homered since May 4. He has one RBI and only three extra-base hits this month, during which he is hitting .254 with a .296 on-base percentage and .299 slugging percentage.
If OPS is a good measurement for a hitter — that is on-base percentage plus slugging percentage — then it might be instructive to consider that Dickerson has fallen to 17th among NL outfielders in that category, right behind Starling Marte and some guy named Andrew McCutchen.
Dickerson’s defense has been far better than expected. Excellent, really. But he is not having an All-Star season.
Nobody else on the team is even mentionable in this category. And to think, it was only five years ago the Pirates had FIVE players at the All-Star Game: McCutchen, Pedro Alvarez, Jason Grilli, Mark Melancon and Jeff Locke.
Wait. Jeff Locke was at an All-Star Game? As a player?
Yes, Virginia, and so was Evan Meek.
Can't get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?
Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.
Matthew Houser, @MattyNice15: Best sports book you’ve read?
Starkey: I’m in the middle of a good one — “Serenity: A Boxing Memoir,” by Ralph Wiley. In the meantime, my top five …
5. “Showtime,” by Jeff Pearlman. Every detail you could possibly want, or not want, about the 1980s L.A. Lakers, one of my all-time favorite teams. Let’s just say they had a lot of fun.
4. “Paper Lion,” by George Plimpton. Riveting (and hilarious) because he went where no other sportswriter had ever gone — onto the field with a professional team. This book stands the test of time.
3. “My Losing Season,” by Pat Conroy. The story of Conroy’s senior year as a point guard at The Citadel — but really the story of his life, including the horror of living with an abusive father.
An excerpt (man, I wish I could write like him) …
“I would not sell my soul to be playing college ball somewhere in this country tonight, but I would give it long and serious consideration. It was only when I had to give up basketball that I began to attract the unfavorable attention of the rest of the world. Basketball provided a legitimate physical outlet for all the violence and rage and sadness I later brought to the writing table. The game kept me from facing the ruined boy who played basketball instead of killing his father. It was also the main language that allowed father and son to talk to each other. If not for sports, I do not think my father ever would have talked to me.”
2. “The Boys of Summer,” by Roger Kahn. Read it again last summer. Meaningful on many levels, as it is the story of growing up in Brooklyn in the 1930s and ‘40s (like my father did) and the story of stumbling into a sportswriting career (like I did).
1. “The Basketball Diaries,” by Jim Carroll. I think I read it in one night. Like most of the other “sports” books I love, this one is about way more than sports. It’s a collection of diaries Carroll kept from ages 12-16 growing up in New York City madness. Please pay no attention to the movie later made of this.
I would be remiss if I didn’t mention “Tales From the Pittsburgh Penguins Locker Room,” by Joe Starkey, available right here on Amazon:
DC PItt Fan, @hailtopitt2005: Why are teams so hesitant to have a 6 man rotation? Nova, Taillon, and Musgrove have all had injuries, and with Kingham looking legit, why not bring him up and have him pitch while saving the other guys some tread on the tires? If one falters, go back to 5.
Starkey: I’m with you, Mr. DC Pitt Fan, and I think teams are reluctant simply because the “five-man rotation” has been the rule for decades. Nothing more, nothing less. I mean, it’s one thing if you have a legit ace or three big-time pitchers at the top of your rotation. The Pirates have neither. So what’s the issue?
If this would be the way to get Kingham in the rotation, go for it. You know, the Angels and Rangers have experimented with six-man rotations this season.
Angels general manager Billy Eppler told The New York Times, "That's been the way the game's been trending, historically, if you look back, if it can help keep guys healthy and you're able to get a little bit more reliability out of your pitchers because of it, I'm all for it.”
Rangers manager Jeff Banister offered this logic behind a six-man rotation: “We think the benefits really outweigh the questions now. Even some of the elite pitchers in Major League Baseball, almost across the board, when you look at starters with an extra rest period, the [velocity] on the fastball goes up, the sharpness of their stuff goes up, they throw more pitches, they go deeper in games.”
Injuries kept both teams from following through on their plans.
On the other side of this debate stands Bill James, who wrote in favor of a three-man rotation a few years back.
I’m not against that, either, depending on the makeup of your starting pitchers. I just hate the idea of being held hostage by baseball convention.
MFH, @FakeHoltzy22: In honor of SRod getting a cluster of ABs, here’s a cluster of bad questions. Favorite beer? Favorite co-worker? Favorite SRod memory? Favorite excuse for playing SRod?
Starkey: In order …
1. Genny Cream
2. Chris Mueller
3. His walk-off HR in return game last year
4. In case game goes 17 innings
Thank you, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille this week. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.