The Pirates at one point were 26-17 and the talk of Major League Baseball. They were in first place, featured one of the National League’s most potent offenses, and were hitting homers at an alarming rate. They had excellent starting pitching and a bullpen shutting opponents down nightly.
It all looked like this might be a dream season. It has now become a nightmare.
The Pirates are 10-24 in their last 34 games and sit 36-41 on the season, They are in fourth place and nine games out of first place in the NL Central. They are closer to the last place Reds (four games) than they are the Cardinals (4½ games), who are in third place. They are six games out and behind five teams for the second wild-card spot.
The idea that general manager Neal Huntington has outsmarted everyone again seems laughable. They got hot early in the season and took advantage of a large feast on bad teams such as the Marlins, White Sox, Twins, Tigers and Reds.
The Pirates are a mediocre baseball team at best, and maybe not even that good. They’re a 75-win team that traded away its two best players and probably didn’t get enough in return. Kyle Crick has been a moderately successful reliever and not much more. Joe Musgrove and Michael Feliz started out like gangbusters, and both have cooled considerably. Colin Moran is a one-dimensional player who looks far more like a platoon player long term than a full-time starter.
Gerrit Cole and Andrew McCutchen needed to be traded, and everybody knew it, so it isn’t a surprise the Pirates didn’t get as much in return as it feels like they should have. But at the point they made the decision to trade those two, they should have just broken the whole thing up, traded away veterans and/or dead weight such as David Freese and Sean Rodriguez and started over.
Read More
Can’t get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?
Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.
Instead, they insisted they were going to compete this year. Huntington referred to any discussion about them not trying to compete as “fiction.” Then, when the Pirates got off to a hot start, there was an element of “Told ya so” to all of his comments.
But a 162-game season doesn’t lie. Eventually a team has to play a long stretch against the better teams — the Pirates are amid such a stretch — and that’s when they get exposed.
Huntington said with a straight face they were looking to add players at the trade deadline. If that was the truth, then the Pirates are lying to themselves.This team needs to and will sell a few pieces and try to position themselves to get back to winning next year and beyond.
That doesn’t mean this team is destined to finish with 60 wins, though, as some of the issues they have had lately will seemingly rebound. Josh Bell, for instance, has been mired in an awful slump and has not hit many home runs. He is young and still learning how to become a consistent MLB hitter, but he has too much talent to not figure it out. Corey Dickerson was incredibly hot early but has cooled off since. He will stabilize, too, though there is a chance it will be too late for the Pirates to benefit because he could be traded in a few weeks.
Trevor Williams has also slumped, and he is too good of a pitcher to continue to be in such a funk. The same can be said about Felipe Vazquez, and Starling Marte is better than he has played as well.
Those things may sort themselves out, and the Pirates won’t be as bad as they have been lately. But there aren’t enough of those things to believe this team is headed anywhere but a third consecutive losing season.
This is exactly what we thought this team was at the start of the season. Nothing that has happened lately should be a surprise.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.