Ben Roethlisberger is supposed to be one of the Steelers’ greatest assets, but at least one publication doesn’t quite see it that way.
Pro Football Focus wrote yesterday that Roethlisberger actually is closer to a reason the Steelers might lose rather than a reason they might win.
I get the point the writer makes about Roethlisberger’s wildly inconsistent season, but calling Roethlisberger a liability is harsh. He is, at worst, the fourth best quarterback in the game right now. The article isn’t complete fiction, either, because he has been maddeningly inconsistent this year. He also hasn’t been the great playoff performer that his reputation would suggest he is in a long, long time. The bottom line is that Roethlsiberger needs to be great this weekend if the Steelers are going to beat the Patriots in the AFC championship.
With the great quarterbacks in recent history — Tom Brady and Aaron Rodgers — it’s easy to point to playoff games they virtually carried their teams to a win. We just saw Rodgers do it Sunday against the Cowboys, and Brady seems to do it just about every week because of the way his offense is built. But Roethlisberger, well, it’s been quite some time since he absolutely dominated a playoff game. I will note that Brady wasn’t very good in the Patriots’ sloppy win Saturday against the Texans and in last year’s AFC championship loss to the Broncos, so he’s in his own playoff mini-slump. But Brady has had great games in each of the past five Patriots playoff runs and thus he has been elite in the postseason more recently than Roethlisberger.
Roethlisberger was solid against the Dolphins, with a 105.2 rating and two touchdown passes, but the Miami defense was decimated. He threw two interceptions and really should have thrown a third. His game against the Chiefs was very average, throwing for 224 yards, no touchdowns and an interception. In last year’s playoff loss to Denver, Roethlisberger threw for 339 yards but zero touchdowns as the Steelers scored only 16 points. In the 2014 loss to Baltimore, he put up 334 yards, but a lot of those came in garbage time. He threw two interceptions and only one touchdown as the Steelers failed to score 20 points. Only once in his past eight playoff games (last year against Cincinnati) has he thrown for more touchdowns than interceptions.
If you look at all of his playoff games, the last time he was special was the 2010 wild-card win against Baltimore when he threw for 226 yards, two touchdowns and no interceptions and had a quarterback rating of 101. At that point in his career, he had thrown 17 postseason touchdown passes and only 12 interceptions. Since then, he has thrown 10 postseason interceptions and only seven touchdowns. The Steelers offense has failed to crack 20 points in four of its past five playoff games.
Read More
I’m not jumping on the “Roethlisberger is a liability” bandwagon because I think that really overstates things. The fact remains, though, that his reputation as a great playoff performer was largely built in his first 11 playoff games, mostly because he led his team to two Super Bowl wins in his first five seasons. Even then, he had some stinkers along the way — like Super Bowl XL — but he had a number of truly special games as well.
The Steelers won’t beat the Patriots if Roethlisberger isn’t the elite quarterback he is capable of being and they won’t win if he makes bad decisions and throws interceptions. It helps that he has his full arsenal of weapons available and the Patriots aren’t great at putting pressure on opposing quarterbacks. But ultimately, this game will fall on Roethlisberger’s shoulders.
If the Steelers get the Roethlisberger of 2005 or 2008, I think they win — and frankly, it might not even be close. But if the Steelers get the Roethlisberger that has showed up lately in the playoffs, I don’t see any way the Steelers win, even if Bell runs wild.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.