The College Football Playoff weekly rankings are a silly exercise in the constant need to debate.

Everyone knows this, yet every week after the rankings are released there are massive debates about which teams are in and which teams are just on the outside looking in.

I’m not sure why it hasn’t sunk in yet that — by the committee’s own admission — the weekly rankings are meaningless. The only ranking that really matters is the final one, after the conference championships.

The methodology is correct, though. The committee is ranking teams the correct way and providing a blueprint for how AP voters and voters in other polls should cast their ballots. The committee isn’t projecting which teams are on the fast track to the playoffs, it’s coming up with its rankings based on the strength of every team’s current body of work. And that’s why the current top four — 1. Alabama 2. Ohio State 3. Michigan and 4. Clemson — makes sense and is correct. It doesn’t matter that Clemson and Michigan both lost this week and Louisville lost a few weeks ago. What matters is that Clemson’s and Michigan’s bodies of work are still better than Louisville’s.

Advertise with us

Publishing a ranking every week feels too much like the committee is just trying to generate hype and discussion when really there is no need for it.

When one of the most important pieces in the rankings is conference championship results, what’s the point of having rankings before any of the conferences are decided? The selection committee protocol values strength of wins, strength of schedule and conference championships over just about everything else. The committee also rewards teams for good wins more than it punishes them for bad losses. This is why USC is ranked so high despite three losses — it has two wins against teams currently in the committee’s top 10.

There is also the “look test,” which helped Ohio State be chosen in 2014 over Baylor and TCU. The Buckeyes were rolling at the end of the season and seemed to be playing at a higher level than those other two and belonged in the top four. Ohio State, by the way, won the national championship that year.

These criteria will far more often than not get the correct four teams into the playoffs.

Louisville fans are upset because Clemson lost to unranked Pitt and didn’t fall below the Cardinals. And the committee didn’t punish Clemson or Michigan at all for losing. The only reason Louisville fans are upset is because they’re thinking in terms of traditional polling and not what the committee is trying to do. Clemson and Michigan both lost to unranked opponents and their resumes are still better than Louisville’s.

Advertise with us

Let’s do a blind resume for Clemson and Louisville and see if we can’t see what the committee sees.

• Team A — 9-1 with wins against No. 5, at No. 15 and at No. 17 (CFP rankings).

• Team B — 9-1 with a win against No. 17.

There is no case to be made for Team B to be ahead of Team A. Of course, Team A is Clemson and Team B is Louisville, so when you throw in the fact that Clemson beat Louisville, this isn’t even a discussion.

The beauty of it is once everything plays itself out, the top four will be pretty clear, unless there is utter chaos in the conference championships. Even then, if the committee used blind resumes it would still be reasonably clear.

Advertise with us

I know it’s fashionable to complain about polls and everything around them, but for once the NCAA got it right with the playoff committee.

It isn’t a perfect system, but it has moved the sport closer to having results in September matter as much as in November and having wins against good teams, and thus tough schedules, matter too.