It really is no choice at all. It is a choice between the lesser of two evils, two really undesirable choices, and we all lose no matter who wins.

No, I’m not talking about the presidential election; I’m talking, if you’re a Pirates fan, about the World Series, which begins tonight.

On one side is the hated, evil Cubs, a team viewed by many Pirates fans as “arrogant” and “overrated” and one that represents all that is wrong about Major League Baseball’s economic system.

The Cubs also feature a smug, unlikable manager, according to many Pirates fans who will never forgive Joe Maddon for claiming that he thought Jung-Ho Kang had plantar fasciitis when he had his knee torn up by a hard slide into second by Cubs utilityman Chris Coghlan.

Advertise with us

It is amazing how much hatred I’ve heard sent toward the Cubs over the last few weeks, and it has gotten louder and far more intense as they have continued to win. But hey, I understand it.

A Cubs win is not something Pirates fans want, and I think that’s mostly because, above all of these fabricated reasons for the hatred, is the fact that the Cubs are what fans here wish the Pirates were.

Rooting for a Cubs loss is easy — until you realize that a Cubs loss means another world championship for the city of Cleveland.

Yeah, Cleveland, the mistake by the lake, the city that has served as the punchline for many jokes in these parts, the home of the Browns and horrible quarterbacks and a place that we forever have held as inferior to us.

A win by the Indians would mean two world championships in six months and a legitimate claim as “The City of Champions,” which might cause more than a few meltdowns in these parts.

Advertise with us

So there you have it, this election — I mean, World Series — from the perspective of a Pittsburgh fan is really a choice between the evil empire and the city we love to hate. Mo matter who wins, it isn’t a favorable outcome.

I’ve heard a number of fans say that if they have to choose a winner, they choose Cleveland, because at least that the Indians are a smaller market team and have a smaller budget, and that gives hope for the Pirates.

It also proves a small market team can win, and since they are in the American League, the Pirates hardly ever play them. And at the end of the day, well, we can still make fun of the Browns.

But the problem with that logic is that an Indians victory should actually further Pirates fans frustrations. The Indians are here (and the Royals were here last year) because they recognized there is a window for small market teams to win and thus went for it.

The Pirates had a three-year run of winning but never went for it with a big trade at the deadline like the Royals did with Johnny Cueto and the Indians did with Andrew Miller.

Advertise with us

Forget about the fact that the Indians have consistently had a higher payroll than the Pirates (this year by $9 million). The trade for Miller meant the Indians had to part with four good prospects.

And they were willing to try and trade for Jonathan Lucroy as well, but he nixed the trade, and that also would have required parting with prospects.

So while it is cool to bash the Cubs for being what the Pirates aren’t — a big market team with lots of money — the truth is the Indians and Royals are what the Pirates aren’t but should be.

And imagine how frustrating it would be for Pirates fans to see, in back-to-back years, smaller market teams win their divisions and win the World Series because they were willing to spend a few extra bucks while the Pirates have nothing but wild cards to show for their run of success.

To me, for Pirates fans, the choice has to be the Cubs. This way, at least we can go back to rationalizing that baseball’s system is rigged and that those big market teams all can just buy World Series titles.

Advertise with us

Forget for a moment that the Cubs just eliminated the Dodgers, who spent $40 million more than they did, or that the Cubs starting infield — Anthony Rizzo, Addison Russell, Javier Baez and Kris Bryant — costs less than Andrew McCutchen, and the Cubs were built by smart drafting, smarter trading, shrewd spending on pitching and the same set of analytics by which the Pirates are guided.

Nah, let’s go with “they are buying a World Series,” because it seems to fit and it is easy to rationalize.

Then the Pirates will be able to claim they have the World Series champs in their division, too, and if you think about it, maybe the Cubs won’t be quite so hungry next year, and the Pirates will come back to the division.

The other thing is this: If it’s just a Cavaliers title, and even if they repeat, we can rationalize that Cleveland still stinks at sports. They just so happen to have perhaps the best player in NBA history for a few years, and so those titles don’t count.

But if they win a second title in a different sport, in the same year, that’s no longer a fluke; it is a trend.

Advertise with us

We can’t have that. So Pirates fans, break out that big white flag with a “W” on it and start practicing singing, “Go Cubs Go, Go Cubs Go, hey Chicago, what do you say, the Cubs are gonna win today.”

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com