Multiple reports say teams are pursuing a deal with the Pirates for close Mark Melancon.
The latest team to inquire appears to be the Washington Nationals, who are in the market for back end of the bullpen help.
If the deal is right, the Pirates should do it.
Melancon is obviously a big part of the Pirates’ success over the last few years and is one of the best closers in baseball.
But he costs too much money and is going to be gone after this season anyway because the price continues to rise.
He is, however, at the trade deadline a very valuable commodity to contenders whose fatal flaw is the back end of their bullpen. And that means he could bring a very nice return for the Pirates as opposed to him leaving for nothing.
Read More
Think Aroldis Chapman, to whom the Cubs paid a hefty price to get from the Yankees. That has to be the market or close to the market for Melancon, and if he can bring anything close to that back, it is worth the deal.
Sources: #Nationals talking to #Pirates about Melancon as well as #Royals about Wade Davis. Multiple teams pursuing Melancon.
— Ken Rosenthal (@Ken_Rosenthal) July 29, 2016
Trade of Melancon would NOT signal #Pirates are conceding. Could close with Feliz/Watson. Deal worth exploring given potential return.
— Ken Rosenthal (@Ken_Rosenthal) July 29, 2016
It weakens the Pirates for this year, but they do have Tony Watson to slide into the closer’s role and perhaps Neftali Feliz has shown enough to be the eighth inning guy.
I don’t think selling off a closer, a guy who will price himself out of town at the end of the year, is giving up on the season — especially since the Pirates do have options to replace him.
Being a small market team means you have to make tough choices sometimes, and this is one of them.
If the Pirates were legitimate World Series contenders, then maybe this isn’t a move they should consider.
But let’s be honest, they aren’t, and trading Melancon doesn’t prevent them from still winning a wild card berth.
Melancon has been a great player and a great part of the Pirates success, but at this point he is probably more valuable as a trade chip than a closer.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.