The Pirates finished the first half of the season strong, and there seems to be a lot of optimism about their prospects of not just winning a wild-card berth, but perhaps even the National League Central Division.
The Pirates won 12 of their final 16 games before the All-Star break, including two of three against the Cubs, have a 46-43 record, and their pitching — particularly their bullpen — is on a roll.
This is all nice, but the worst thing people do when it comes to baseball is view it in small samples and ignore the big picture.
The end of the break was a nice stretch, but the Pirates played 89 games, not 16, and they won only three more times than they lost. At their current winning percentage (.517) they will finish the season 84-78, which is a good season but not likely one that ends in a playoff berth. They are also in third place, 7½ games behind the Cubs, who just went 5-15 and are likely to regroup.
The Pirates have begun to pitch better in the past 15 games, but they are still 10th in the NL in team ERA and 12th in batting average against.
This isn’t my attempt to be negative, it’s my attempt to deal in reality. The reality is, while the Pirates have had a really nice stretch of games, the first half of the season has been mostly underwhelming.
The discussion now seems to be that the Pirates are playing their best baseball and it’s going to continue into the second half. That might be true, but from late April to late May they were 21-11, pitched pretty well and pushed their record to a season-high nine games over .500 (28-19). That was followed by a 6-20 stretch. That’s not to say it will happen again, but when you judge a baseball team, the entire body of work is what’s relevant, not short samples.
The Pirates may have fixed some of their pitching woes with Juan Nicasio, A.J. Schugel, Arquimedes Caminero and Jared Hughes seemingly pulling it together in the bullpen. The jury is still out on the young starting pitchers — Chad Kuhl, Tyler Glasnow and Jameson Taillon — in terms of consistency, but they all have talent. It seems they will get opportunities in the second half, and when you add Gerrit Cole, there’s reason to believe the Pirates will pitch better after the All-Star break.
However, none of that is a given. Baseball is a grind. Short samples aren’t particularly relevant, even though many people love short samples that prove their point.
The Pirates are set up to have a good second half. They might ultimately be able to get to the postseason, but not because of what happened the past two weeks. It’s because they have enough talent to win a lot of games if they play well.
The key phrase, of course, is “if they play well.” While they did that the past two weeks, this is mostly the same team that also lost 20 of 26 games.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.