Let’s empty the notebook again:
• If the Penguins win the Stanley Cup, there are many moves made by Jim Rutherford that deserve high praise but beyond changing coaches, the most important one was the trade for Phil Kessel.
At the time there were a lot of people who didn’t like the trade. They thought the Penguins added another malcontent prima donna who doesn’t do much more than try to score. Those criticisms grew louder as Kessel didn’t seem to play well with either of the Penguins’ two star centers and didn’t have the kind of season (in terms of goal scoring) that people expected.
But I maintained when the trade was made and I still maintain today that the Kessel trade was aimed at the playoffs. And given that, it has been an overwhelming success.
The problem the Penguins have had in recent years in the playoffs is that if one or both of the superstars weren’t scoring, the team struggled to score and win.
Also, with only the two stars, teams had an easier time matching up against them and neutralizing their ability to affect the games.
Read More
Now, however, the Penguins have an elite-level goal scorer on their third line. That has created matchup nightmares for opponents.
Kessel has 16 points in 14 playoff games, and that includes seven goals. I know that Nick Bonino and Carl Hagelin are a big part of the team’s success, but I’d maintain neither of those two would be nearly as dangerous if they didn’t have Kessel on their line.
Kessel is the kind of player teams need to account for at all times when the Penguins have the puck. His ability to score goals is impressive and his ability to create offense for his teammates is underrated.
Again, the most important move Rutherford made was firing Mike Johnston and hiring Mike Sullivan, but the second most important move was trading for Kessel. He has been exactly the kind of player the Penguins have needed to get over the hump in the playoffs.
• The last two Penguins games — both wins — suggest to me that the Penguins are a much better team than the Lightning. Both games were close on the scoreboard, but if you watched them, they were blowouts. The Penguins were dominant for pretty much 120 minutes (and 40 seconds).
The Penguins have outshot the Lightning, 89-49, over the two games, and frankly, they have really limited the number of good scoring chances Tampa has had.
Matt Murray has been good, but he also benefitted from how well the Penguins have played in front of him. They have possessed the puck, they have had an aggressive forecheck that has kept the puck in the Lightning zone and they have just not given the Lightning much of anything in front of the net.
And the bottom line is this: if you give a team as skilled as the Penguins a 20-shot advantage, most nights you will lose.
I think Tampa may be able to win one more game in this series, but it won’t shock me if the Penguins win in five games.
Tampa players and Jon Cooper talked last night after the game about having to fix some things and getting back to playing better hockey. But I’ll be honest, I’m not sure if there is a fix when the other team is clearly better. And the Penguins have shown they are clearly better.
• Pirates reliever Arquimedes Caminero has high-level stuff and throws hard. When he’s locating his pitches well and in control he is nasty. But he hasn’t been that this year. He has been wildly inconsistent and he has had a hard time getting outs.
Clint Hurdle said Wednesday that Caminero is not an arm you turn your back on after six weeks of inconsistency, but Caminero has to be pitching on borrowed time.
Caminero has appeared in 18 games, pitched 15⅔ innings, given up 21 hits, 10 earned runs, three home runs and issued 12 walks. He has also given up a run in five of his past seven appearances, including each of the past two games he has entered against the Braves.
Hurdle said when Caminero is having a hard time finding the strike zone, he tends to try to throw perfect pitches and ends up leaving them in the middle of the plate to get hit.
Tuesday night, that turned into a two-run homer. Wednesday night it was an RBI double. It may not yet be time to give up on Caminero, but if he doesn’t get this straightened out soon the Pirates are going to have to make some kind of move with him. You can’t keep running a guy out there who can’t get the job done, no matter how good his stuff is.
• Pitt returned to its “roots” Wednesday and brought back the “Script Pitt” logo. That’s pretty cool, if for no other reason than it makes the fans happy.
The new uniforms are slick and all, but why stop with the script?
If you’re looking for that vintage look, the football team should go back to the mustard yellow pants and helmets as well. Now that would be cool.
Incidentally, I keep hearing how this is Pitt getting back to its “tradition,” and that’s simply not true.
Pitt has won nine national titles in football, and only one of them came wearing the script. The football program is more than 100 years old, and the script was worn for about 23 of those seasons.
I’m not raining on the parade, I’m simply saying the word tradition is not accurate in describing the script. It’s a throwback to the last run of glory that Pitt football had —- that period from 1975-83 — and that’s why people love it, but it isn’t Pitt’s tradition.
I think the new uniforms look good, but the important thing is that the teams wearing them play well. If they don’t, the goodwill bought Wednesday by a brilliant day-long marketing blitz will go away rather quickly.
• Speaking of hot-button Pitt issues — it was just announced that the Pitt-Penn State game Sept. 10 is a noon kickoff, which caused some of Pitt fans to go into meltdown mode.
I have never understood the instant anger over noon kickoffs, and I’ve never bought any of the reasons fans have tried to sell about why it’s so awful and why it’s different.
I watch noon kickoffs at places in the Central Time Zone (which means it’s 11 a.m. local time), and fans seem to be able to wake up and get to the games. At Pitt, this seems to be an issue, and I can’t quite figure out why.
If you’re a fan of your team, you will show up to watch them and plan your day around it once the schedule goes out.
Personally, I love noon games — get there early, and you’re on your way home by 3:30 p.m. with the rest of the day to do whatever you want.
And it’s funny the Steelers never seem to have an issue filling that place on Sundays, and they often kick off at 1 p.m. Is that extra hour really that big of a deal?
Noon kicks are fine. People who complain about noon kicks are just inventing reasons to complain.
Penguins' Rutherford a finalist for NHL GM of the year award





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.