There are many people who deserve credit for the Penguins’ rise to the Eastern Conference final, but none more than general manager Jim Rutherford. Not for the reasons that you think, though.
Sure, the moves he made since the end of last season to change the roster, make the team deeper, faster and grittier are all a big part of the story.
But to me, the thing that Rutherford did that deserves the most credit is that he showed a little bit of humility and corrected a mistake he made last year.
Mike Johnston, by all accounts, is a really good guy, a straight shooter and a thoughtful, intelligent hockey mind with a lot of great ideas.
In my limited interactions with him, I always found him to be honest. He gave great answers, and it was pretty clear he treated people around him the right way.
It’s easy to see why Rutherford chose Johnston to replace Dan Bylsma following the 2013-14 season. Despite his lack of NHL coaching experience, he seemed like a coach who was capable of getting the Penguins back to the top before the Sidney Crosby/Evgeni Malkin/Kris Letang/Marc-Andre Fleury window to win another Stanley Cup closed.
Read More
It became abundantly clear as time wore on that Johnston wasn’t the right coach for this group of players.
His system didn’t maximize what this team did well. It was clear the stars were not happy playing his style of hockey, and, frankly, had he remained in place the Penguins wouldn’t be anywhere close to as good as they are.
Rutherford saw this, understood it, listened to his players and admitted he made a mistake.
The rest is history. Rutherford fired Johnston 28 games into this season and promoted Mike Sullivan from Wilkes-Barre/Scranton to be the Penguins’ next coach.
Sullivan’s influence on the team was almost instant, even though it took about a month for the team to really settle into his system and play at a high level.
He changed the culture in the locker room with his fiery disposition, he commanded respect with his no-nonsense approach and most importantly, he unleashed the hounds.
The best thing Sullivan did is bring the best out of the Penguins stars by taking the handcuffs off of them and playing to their strengths.
Rutherford also did his job by adding speed demons Carl Hagelin and Trevor Daley in two trades that look like absolute steals now.
Johnston’s system didn’t allow skilled players to be free, and it was too passive compared to the way Sullivan has them playing.
The Penguins now apply pressure on every inch of the ice and are relentless in every zone. They’re able to play that way because they have so much speed.
Daley can take chances up the ice other defensemen can’t because he is fast enough to recover and make plays in his own end. When Hagelin is on the ice, the Penguins play at a completely different speed than their opponents.
We could talk all day about the other moves (Phil Kessel, Eric Fehr, Nick Bonino, etc.) Rutherford made, but I’d argue none of them would be relevant if he didn’t first correct the mistake he made by firing Johnston.
I can’t tell you how many times I’ve watched news conferences where administrators refused to concede they made a mistake.
Rutherford could have preached patience because this was his first coaching hire as the Penguins general manager, and for a time it seemed like the fate of both men was going to be tied together.
He didn’t do that. He chose to be eat a little humble pie instead.
That’s why the Penguins are four wins from advancing to the Stanley Cup final and eight wins from lifting a fourth Stanley Cup instead of working on their golf handicaps.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.