The Penguins are Matt Murray’s team for now and should be for the remainder of the playoffs.
There, I said it.
I know, I know.
“Marc-Andre Fleury is healthy, has experience, has won a Stanley Cup and has been a part of this core group.”
I know, I know.
“Matt Murray is just a 21-year-old rookie, he is bound to fail sooner or later!”
Read More
Please stop. You know who you are — media guys in this town and people who called me an idiot last week on my radio show for suggesting Murray should play regardless of if Fleury is healthy.
Do you know why this isn’t a debate right now? Because Murray is a really good goaltender. And if we have learned anything about the Stanley Cup playoffs, it’s that you don’t need a grizzled veteran goaltender to win. You need a guy who is playing well.
The Capitals probably should lead this series 2-1 and would be if Murray was not as good as he was last night.
He made 47 saves, he stoned Alex Ovechkin six times, he kept the Penguins in the game in the first period when the Capitals looked like they were moving at a pace twice as fast as the Penguins. He was the reason the Penguins won in a game they clearly were outplayed.
There is no reason to play Marc-Andre Fleury at this point — none — and there is no legitimate rationalization for playing him until Murray shows he can’t handle the job anymore.
I wouldn’t hold my breath, Fleury fans, because this kid has played out of his mind for the most part in this series.
Washington was the better team Monday night, at times much better, but they couldn’t beat Murray. They couldn’t Saturday, either. That’s all I need to see to know he is poised enough to keep the job, lack of experience notwithstanding.
And for the record, I love Fleury. I have and will still make the case that of the four stars who have been around since before the 2009 Stanley Cup run, Fleury has been the best and most consistent in the playoffs. He is a great goaltender and a guy whose number probably should be retired when he’s done.
But Fleury has been out for about five weeks, and in the meantime, Murray proved he is more than capable of putting the team on his back and winning playoff games.
Now, of course, if Murray gets lit up like a Christmas tree Wednesday, then it changes. But I have had arguments over the past few days and within the last week— even Monday night AFTER the game — with people who insist that Fleury has to play as soon as he is ready.
That’s nonsense. If the Penguins go on to beat the Capitals, Murray needs to be the starter in Game 1 against the Islanders or Lightning, too. It’s a very easy decision, to be honest.
There have been three rookie goaltenders to lead their team to a Stanley Cup title: Ken Dryden, Patrick Roy and Cam Ward.
As rookies, Roy, Ward and Ron Hextall (whose team lost in the finals) all won the Conn Smythe trophy for playoffs MVP. Roy was 20 when he won his first one, a year younger than Murray.
So, there is a precedent for rookie goaltenders leading their team to the promised land.
Here are a few more of my thoughts on the NHL playoffs:
• Monday night was a prime example of why it is so hard to win in the playoffs — and also why there are so many more upsets in hockey than any other sport. The Capitals outplayed the Penguins for almost the entire game. But the Penguins got a couple of fortunate bounces, including one off the back of Tom Kuhnhackl to take a 2-0 lead. A goaltender and a couple of fortunate bounces can completely change the outcome of a game.
I’ve seen many examples throughout the playoffs where I thought Team A clearly outplayed Team B, yet Team B won because of its goaltender. It’s why the Stanley Cup playoffs are so much fun and are so unpredictable. The best team doesn’t always win, and, in fact, more often than not the best teams in a given year don’t win the Cup.
• Jim Rutherford deserves a lot of credit for putting together a great team, but his best move was hiring Mike Sullivan. Adding guys like Trevor Daley and Carl Hagelin have made the Penguins an extremely fast team. But the reality is those guys are able to play their games because Sullivan’s system is predicated on speed and aggression.
If the Penguins had this roster with Mike Johnston coaching, would they still be as effective? Would they still be as dangerous? My guess is no. They’d be a greyhound on a leash and probably would already be home by now.
This is a fun team to watch because Sullivan has unleashed the hounds and allowed these guys to play.
• So far, Alex Ovechkin has been better than Sidney Crosby in this series, and the only reason it hasn’t been pointed out is the Penguins lead the series. I’m not saying he is better, I’m saying through three games he has been better.
Ovechkin has been more active, he has generated more scoring opportunities for his team and he has been very easy to see on the forecheck. He is hung with the label of best player to never win anything. The younger Ovechkin, who seemed aloof and far too willing to defer and pout when things got tough, deserved the criticism he got. But this version is more mature and playing with a sense of urgency. If the Capitals lose, it won’t be because he decided not to show up.
• The Kris Letang hit probably should draw a one-game suspension (there is a hearing set today), but only for this reason: The NHL suspended Brooks Orpik for three games. Frankly, I am tired of all the whining about every hit that happens at full speed. This is hockey, for God’s sake.
Because teams play six or seven grueling games against one another, it’s going to get chippy. That’s why we love it, by the way, because guts have as much to do with which team survives as skill does.
Hockey is a rough game, and guys get hit. Frankly, I think a five-minute major for Orpik and a one-game suspension, double-minor and $2,400 fine for Letang would be sufficient. I loved what Barry Trotz said, too, when he was asked if this series was getting too nasty: “No, not at all. The Philadelphia series was a lot more nasty than this.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.