The Pirates have a winning record and appear to again be one of the best teams in the National League. That’s amazing considering their pitching has been inconsistent at best.
It’s early still, and things can change, but the Pirates seem to be living a charmed life thanks to their bats and some favorable scheduling.
But it’s hard to believe the Pirates will continue to hit like they have, and the schedule gets much tougher in June. That means the pitching staff needs to pull it together.
The starters have been underwhelming, to say the least, and worse than that, they haven’t really pitched with much length.
Through 38 games, the Pirates had only 19 quality starts and only five starts of seven innings or longer. They had 15 starts of five innings or less.
The Pirates have given up seven runs or more 14 times already this season. They did that 19 times all of last year.
Read More
Gerrit Cole is coming off the best start of the season — his eight-inning, three-hit scoreless win against the Cubs — but in the three starts prior to that he gave up 20 hits and 12 runs (nine earned).
Francisco Liriano showed some signs of life in recent weeks, but then he got blown up by the Cubs.
Those two have to get better and more consistent for the Pirates to have a shot at returning to the playoffs. I’m not sure the other three starters are capable of much more than what we have seen.
Jon Niese has pitched like a fifth starter, not a third starter, but that’s what the Pirates knew they were getting when they traded for him.
Jeff Locke is Jeff Locke, which is to say he is capable of a really good start now and then but not much more. The Juan Nicasio experiment has just about run its course.
There were a number of people who questioned whether this rotation is good enough, and so far the answer has been no — not at all.
The easy answer is to have Tyler Glasnow and/or Jameson Taillon fly in with their cape from Class AAA Indianapolis to save the ship. However, we know that won’t happen until after the date the Pirates extend their years of club control and/or reduce their arbitration years, so there is no reason to talk about it.
I do think this is one instance where the Pirates should consider being a little less conservative with one of those two and bring them up to help immediately. But they don’t do business that way, and it’s worked for them.
That means there aren’t many other solutions other than finding a journeyman off the scrap heap or moving Ryan Vogelsong into the rotation. Based on what we have seen from Vogelsong out of the bullpen, we want to see less of him, not more.
In short, unless the Pirates are willing to break their unwritten rules about promoting prospects, the only solution for the pitching staff is that these five guys have to pitch better until Glasnow and Taillon arrive.
The Pirates rolled the dice with their pitching staff but had to know they were on shaky ground with Niese, Nicasio and Locke, and that’s why the company line focused on the bullpen.
This was going to be the year the Pirates used the Kansas City Royals model of a dominant bullpen requiring starters to go only five or six innings before handing off the game to the relievers.
That was a nice theory, too, but the first part of it — having a dominant bullpen — hasn’t exactly come to fruition, either.
In fact, as tough as some of the numbers look for the starters recently, it seems like the only two relievers the Pirates really can trust are Tony Watson and Mark Melancon.
One has to figure Jared Hughes is on the road back, and he’s been solid, so there are really three guys in the bullpen whom the Pirates can trust. If there are only three guys who can be trusted, their arms will fall off by mid-August from overuse.
Arquimedes Caminero was reliable down the stretch last season. This season, he has gone 14⅔ innings and given up 19 hits, 11 walks, three home runs and 10 runs.
Neftali Feliz has been a little better, albeit not very consistent.
Who else do you trust in a big spot?
Cory Luebke? Rob Scahill? A.J. Schugel? Kyle Lobstein?
Much like the starters, there doesn’t seem to be a lot of realistic hope for most of the relievers — outside of Caminero — to suddenly become more effective.
I’m not sure if a staff of two reliable starters and three reliable relievers is going to be quite good enough to get the Pirates to the heights they want to reach.
Again, it’s not yet time to sound the alarms, but I do think that there is some reason to be concerned about the pitching staff going forward.
This is a team and an organization that has been built on pitching, but it’s starting to look like the critics who said the Pirates didn’t do enough in the offseason to build their rotation and bullpen might have been right.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.